Daniel CarvalhopersName, Carlos SequeirapersName, Ana QueridopersName, Catarina TomáspersName, Tânia MorgadopersName, Olga ValentimpersName, Lídia MoutinhopersName, João GomespersName, Carlos LaranjeirapersName (2022date). “Positive Mental Health Literacy: A Concept Analysis..” Frontiers in Psychologytitle·j.
Object of study — the attributes, characteristics and applications of positive mental health literacyterm·key
Research question — what the current definition of positive mental health literacyterm·key is in recent literature
Contribution — six defining attributesterm of positive mental health literacyterm·key, with its antecedentsterm, consequencesterm·key and case scenarios
phenomenon · claim-type · cross-domain-transfer · mechanism · claim-relation · replication-status · limitation — grounded in the full text| phenomenon | the lack of a clear definition of positive mental health literacy among healthcare practitioners — “Although explored recently, the term still lacks a clear definition among healthcare practitioners.” | |
| claim-type | existence — “The PMeHL concept is considered a component of MHL, integrating positive mental health, which deserves attention throughout the lifespan in different contexts and intervention levels.” | |
| method — evidence | — “This concept analysis was based on the framework proposed by Walker and Avant (2019) .” | |
| object of study — evidence | — “To identify the attributes and characteristics of PMeHL, as well as its theoretical and practical applications.” | |
| research question — evidence | — “To fill this gap, we aim to describe the current definition of PMeHL based on the more recent literature incorporating well-grounded practices and potential measurement tools.” | |
| contribution — evidence | — “The concept’s attributes include: (a) competence in problem-solving and self-actualization; (b) personal satisfaction; (c) autonomy; (d) relatedness and interpersonal relationship skills; (e) self-control; and (f) prosocial attitude.” | |
| mechanism | PMeHL PMeHL makes help-seeking more effective: knowing when, where and how to get good mental health care. — “For Kutcher et al. (2016b) , PMeHL increases the effectiveness in seeking help (knowing when, where and how to get good mental health care and developing the necessary skills for self-care) ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ).” | mechanisms[0] |
| sense | PMeHL (as a process) - seeking knowledge and skills for hedonic and eudaimonic well-being — “Therefore, PMeHL can be understood as a process covering the search for knowledge and skills to obtain hedonic well-being (based on positive emotional states like happiness) and eudaimonic well-being (focuses on positive individual and social experiences and functioning) ( Santini et al., 2020 ).” | senses[0] |
| sense | PMeHL (operationalized) - a resource or mediator of health outcomes, or an outcome itself — “Thus, PMeHL can be operationalized in two ways: (a) as a resource or potential mediator between individual determinants and health(-related) outcomes and (b) as an outcome when attempting to decrease the impact of social/contextual inequalities on health(-related) outcomes.” | senses[1] |
| sense | mental health literacy (earlier notion) - mere knowledge of mental disorders — “Bjørnsen et al. (2017) emphasized that this conceptualization goes beyond previous notions of MHL as mere knowledge of mental disorders and proposed the concept of PMeHL.” | senses[2] |
| relation | positive component of Mental Health Literacy —same-as→ PMeHL — The positive component of Mental Health Literacy (PMeHL) refers to a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health. — “The positive component of Mental Health Literacy (PMeHL) refers to a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health.” | concept_edges[0] |
| weight | positive component of Mental Health Literacy —same-as→ PMeHL — 0.9 — “The positive component of Mental Health Literacy (PMeHL) refers to a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health.” | concept_edges[0] |
| relation | Mental Health Promoting Knowledge —same-as→ MHPK-10 — Across evaluated studies, only the 10-item Mental Health Promoting Knowledge (MHPK-10) scale measured knowledge of how to obtain and maintain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ). — “Across evaluated studies, only the 10-item Mental Health Promoting Knowledge (MHPK-10) scale measured knowledge of how to obtain and maintain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).” | concept_edges[1] |
| weight | Mental Health Promoting Knowledge —same-as→ MHPK-10 — 0.9 — “Across evaluated studies, only the 10-item Mental Health Promoting Knowledge (MHPK-10) scale measured knowledge of how to obtain and maintain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).” | concept_edges[1] |
| relation | PMeHL —part-of→ MHL — The PMeHL concept is considered a component of MHL, integrating positive mental health, which deserves attention throughout the lifespan in different contexts and intervention levels. — “The PMeHL concept is considered a component of MHL, integrating positive mental health, which deserves attention throughout the lifespan in different contexts and intervention levels.” | concept_edges[2] |
| weight | PMeHL —part-of→ MHL — 0.85 — “The PMeHL concept is considered a component of MHL, integrating positive mental health, which deserves attention throughout the lifespan in different contexts and intervention levels.” | concept_edges[2] |
| replication | not-applicable | |
| limitation | The search covered only two databases and English and Portuguese literature, so relevant work may have been missed. — “First, the literature search was thorough, but limited to two databases and the English and Portuguese literature; therefore, relevant publications may have been missed.” | limitations[0] |
| limitation | The field is dominated by a mental-illness perspective and few measures of PMeHL exist. — “Finally, the area is still dominated by a mental-illness perspective, with just a few measures used to examine PMeHL.” | limitations[1] |
finding · quantity · variable · definition · key-term — grounded in the full text| finding | Stand-alone education-based interventions are likely more effective for improving mental health literacy in adolescents. — “The same authors concluded that stand-alone education-based interventions are likely more effective for improving MHL among adolescents.” | content_tags.findings[0] |
| finding | People with higher PMeHL are more likely to engage in self-care and seek out resources. — “Individuals with greater PMeHL levels are more likely to engage in self-care and seek out resources from their family or social structure, community, or healthcare system.” | content_tags.findings[1] |
| quantity | 18 — — “Three additional articles were found with Google search engine, resulting in 18 included studies.” | content_tags.quantities[0] |
| key-terms | positive mental health literacy, mental health literacy, positive mental health, concept analysis, defining attributes, antecedents, consequences, self-control, prosocial attitude, help-seeking |
| concept | positive component of Mental Health Literacy — a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health — “The positive component of Mental Health Literacy (PMeHL) refers to a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health.” | concepts[0] |
| concept | PMeHL — positive component of Mental Health Literacy — “The positive component of Mental Health Literacy (PMeHL) refers to a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health.” | concepts[1] |
| concept | Mental health literacy — consists of components related to the knowledge and abilities necessary to benefit mental health — “Mental health literacy consists of components related to the knowledge and abilities necessary to benefit mental health ( Jorm, 2012 ; Kutcher et al., 2016b ).” | concepts[2] |
| concept | MHL — Mental Health Literacy — “Mental Health Literacy (MHL) is an evolving concept, originally conceptualized by Jorm et al. (1997) (Wei et al., 2015 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ) and today recognized as a determinant of a population’s mental health ( Jorm, 2012 ; Wei et al., 2013 ; Kutcher et al., 2016a ; Bröder et al., 2017 ).” | concepts[3] |
| concept | defining attributes — critical characteristics that help differentiate related concepts and clarify their meaning — “From the perspective of Walker and Avant (2019) , defining attributes are critical characteristics that help differentiate related concepts and clarify their meaning.” | concepts[4] |
| concept | Antecedents — the events or attributes that must exist prior to the occurrence of a concept — “Antecedents are the events or attributes that must exist prior to the occurrence of a concept ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ).” | concepts[5] |
| concept | borderline case — contains most of the defining attributes but not all of them — “According to Walker and Avant (2019) , a borderline case contains most of the defining attributes but not all of them.” | concepts[6] |
| concept | Empirical referents — measurable indicators of the concept’s occurrence — “Empirical referents are measurable indicators of the concept’s occurrence ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ).” | concepts[7] |
| concept | Self-control — the capacity to manage stress/conflict, via emotional balance/control, and tolerate frustration, anxiety, and stress — “(e) Self-control—the capacity to manage stress/conflict, via emotional balance/control, and tolerate frustration, anxiety, and stress ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ).” | concepts[8] |
| concept | Prosocial attitude — an active predisposition toward society, including altruism and helping/supporting others, as well as acceptance of others and different social characteristics — “(f) Prosocial attitude—an active predisposition toward society, including altruism and helping/supporting others, as well as acceptance of others and different social characteristics ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ).” | concepts[9] |
| concept | Mental Health Promoting Knowledge — not defined in this paper's own words; a ten-item scale of how much a person knows about staying mentally healthy — “Across evaluated studies, only the 10-item Mental Health Promoting Knowledge (MHPK-10) scale measured knowledge of how to obtain and maintain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).” | concepts[10] |
| concept | MHPK-10 — Mental Health Promoting Knowledge — “Across evaluated studies, only the 10-item Mental Health Promoting Knowledge (MHPK-10) scale measured knowledge of how to obtain and maintain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).” | concepts[11] |
Full text — tagged
Positive Mental Health Literacyterm·key: A Concept Analysisterm·key.
Abstract The positive component of Mental Health Literacyterm·dom (PMeHLterm·dom) refers to a person’s awareness of how to achieve and maintain good mental health. Although explored recently, the term still lacks a clear definition among healthcare practitioners.
To identify the attributes and characteristics of PMeHLterm·dom, as well as its theoretical and practical applications.
Literature search (using the Medline and CINAHL databases) and review, covering the last 21 years, followed by concept analysisterm·key according to the steps described by Walker and Avant approach.
Positive component of Mental Health Literacyterm·dom is considered one component of MHLterm·dom, integrating positive mental healthterm·key. The concept’s attributes include: (a) competence in problem-solving and self-actualization; (b) personal satisfaction; (c) autonomy; (d) relatedness and interpersonal relationship skills; (e) self-controlterm·dom; and (f) prosocial attitudeterm·dom. Four case scenarios (model, borderline, related and contrary cases) were used to clarify the antecedentsterm (individual factors and social/contextual factors) and consequencesterm·key (individual sphere; relational/social sphere; contextual/organizational sphere) of PMeHLterm·dom.
Positive component of Mental Health Literacyterm·dom is considered a component of MHLterm·dom, which deserves attention throughout the lifespan, in different contexts and intervention levels. Considering PMeHLterm·dom as a multi-faceted and dynamic construct will help understand the mechanisms that improve mental health and promote healthy behaviors. Priority should be given to robust primary research focused on nursing interventions that enhance and sustain PMeHLterm·dom in people and families.
Keywords: mental health literacyterm·dom, mental processes, positive mental healthterm·key, concept analysisterm·key, health literacy, personal autonomy Introduction Mental Health Literacyterm·dom (MHLterm·dom) is an evolving concept, originally conceptualized by Jorm et al. (1997) (Wei et al., 2015 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ) and today recognized as a determinant of a population’s mental health ( Jorm, 2012 ; Wei et al., 2013 ; Kutcher et al., 2016a ; Bröder et al., 2017 ). MHLterm·dom should not be limited to mental health professionals or people with mental health illnesses ( Sweileh, 2021 ). Rather, MHLterm·dom at the societal and community level is of great importance, as a means of promoting mental health and healthcare and achieving the economic, environmental, and social ambitions of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development Goals ( World Health Organization [WHO], 2019 ). Integrating MHLterm·dom interventions into strategies of health promotion, disease prevention, and acute and chronic disease management will be essential to engage individuals in a person-centerd model that configures individual and holistic approaches ( Pelletier and Stichler, 2014 ; Jorm, 2019 ).
While originally developed for adults, the concept of MHLterm·dom has since been extended to adolescents ( MorgadopersName et al., 2021a ), as the first onset of many mental disorders usually occurs in childhood or adolescence ( Jorm, 2019 ). MHLterm·dom has been recognized as an important factor in promoting the youth’s mental health, potentially benefiting both individual and public mental health ( Kutcher et al., 2015 ; Wei et al., 2015 ; Marinucci et al., 2022 ). MHLterm·dom can be further strengthened through educational initiatives ( Kutcher et al., 2016a ). A recent systematic review found a positive effect of school-based educational interventions on improving mental health literacyterm·dom (MHLterm·dom) in adolescents ( Olyani et al., 2021 ). The evidence has also underlined the need to promote MHLterm·dom throughout the life span and in different contexts ( MorgadopersName et al., 2021b ), because it increases the quality of life of people ( Jafari et al., 2021 ).
Mental health literacyterm·dom consists of components related to the knowledge and abilities necessary to benefit mental health ( Jorm, 2012 ; Kutcher et al., 2016b ). Based on MHLterm·dom research, Kutcher et al. (2016b , p.567) defined distinct but related components, the foremost being: “Understanding how to obtain and maintain good mental health.” This central element for health promotion—referred to as Positive Mental Health Literacyterm·key (PMeHLterm·dom) ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 )—is complemented by the following three components of MHLterm·dom: the recognition of mental disorders; help-seekingterm·key efficacy; and help-seekingterm·key strategies (e.g., Jorm, 2012 ; Kutcher et al., 2013 , 2015 ; Wei et al., 2013 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ). Bjørnsen et al. (2017) emphasized that this conceptualization goes beyond previous notions of MHLterm·dom as mere knowledge of mental disorders and proposed the concept of PMeHLterm·dom.
Practice and research have mostly focused on mental ill-health; however, growing evidence demonstrates that supporting positive mental healthterm·key has long-term benefits (PMH) ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ; Teixeira et al., 2019 ). Note that PMeHLterm·dom does not exist in a vacuum, but rather interacts with other factors such as personality traits, literacy skills, availability of information, and personal motivation.
Therefore, fully understanding and defining the concept of PMeHLterm·dom is necessary. Although there has been increased research on the concept of MHLterm·dom, few concept analyses, if any, have specifically addressed PMeHLterm·dom ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ). To fill this gap, we aim to describe the current definition of PMeHLterm·dom based on the more recent literature incorporating well-grounded practices and potential measurement tools. We also propose an illustration of the concept analysisterm·key.
Materials and Methods This concept analysisterm·key was based on the framework proposed by Walker and Avant (2019) . The method involves eight steps: (1) selecting the concept; (2) identifying the aim of the analysis; (3) identifying how the concept is used; (4) determining the concept’s defining attributesterm; (5) identifying model cases, where all attributes are exhibited; (6) identifying borderline, related and contrary cases, respectively, where most, part or no attributes are exhibited; (7) identifying determining antecedentsterm and consequencesterm·key; and (8) defining empirical referentsterm.
Database Search A comprehensive literature search from 2000 to the present was conducted using two databases (Medline and CINAHL). The following search terms [MeSH] were used in combination: (Mental health literacyterm·dom OR mental health*) AND (Positive mental healthterm·key*) AND (Nursing OR Positive, Psychology) NOT (Child*). The studies published over the last 21 years reflect the changing perspectives and uses of the term.
The inclusion criteria for articles included in the analysis were: (1) a definition of PMeHLterm·dom, a concept analysisterm·key, or a list of defining attributesterm; (2) instruments or methods to measure PMeHLterm·dom; and (3) strategies to enhance PMeHLterm·dom. We also included (4) position statements and definition papers addressing PMeHLterm·dom. Only articles published in Portuguese and English were included.
Data Source Figure 1 shows an overview of the article selection process. Of the 68 articles retrieved, 19 duplicates were excluded, and 30 titles/abstracts were deemed irrelevant, leaving 19 for full-text screening. Full-text screening excluded another four articles. Three additional articles were found with Google search engine, resulting in 18 included studies.
PRISMA flow diagram.
Results The 18 articles found during our search were critically analyzed to help identify PMeHLterm·dom’s key attributes and develop case scenarios.
Definitions and Uses of Concept During the initial stage of concept analysisterm·key, Walker and Avant (2019) emphasize the need to identify the concept’s definitions and multiple uses.
Positive component of Mental Health Literacyterm·dom is one component of MHLterm·dom and refers to the knowledge and ability to obtain and sustain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 , 2018 , 2019 ). This is in line with the previous broader concept of MHLterm·dom, as defined by Kutcher et al. (2016b) , which contains two aspects: knowledge about mental health, implying access to information and understanding that information; and the abilities to obtain and maintain good health, namely the skills needed to promote mental health and well-being and reduce the impact of mental illness in a Mental Health Continuum ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ; Teixeira et al., 2019 ; Santini et al., 2020 ).
Positive component of Mental Health Literacyterm·dom can include three dimensions of Positive Mental Healthterm·key: (a) emotional (hedonic), covering the presence of positive affect and satisfaction with life; (b) social (eudaimonic), including both social functioning and connection to broader society; and (c) psychological (eudaimonic), covering intrapersonal and interpersonal functioning ( Santini et al., 2020 ). Therefore, PMeHLterm·dom can be understood as a process covering the search for knowledge and skills to obtain hedonic well-being (based on positive emotional states like happiness) and eudaimonic well-being (focuses on positive individual and social experiences and functioning) ( Santini et al., 2020 ).
When making informed, effective decisions, PMeHLterm·dom demands a strategy that appropriately conceptualizes the complex, dynamic nature of mental health literacyterm·dom and includes the positive side of mental health for all participants.
Defining Attributesterm From the perspective of Walker and Avant (2019) , defining attributesterm are critical characteristics that help differentiate related concepts and clarify their meaning. These characteristics are always included in a concept’s description. The key attributes of PMeHLterm·dom are linked to fulfilling basic psychological needs (Deci and Vansteenkiste, 2004 cited in Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ), namely three inherent psychological demands for competence, relatedness, and autonomy. These are vital ingredients for proactivity, optimal development, and psychological health (Deci and Vansteenkiste, 2004 cited in Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).
The multifactorial model of Positive Mental Healthterm·key—based on a holistic perspective of health, wherein physical and mental health are intimately related—is also one of PMeHLterm·dom’s critical characteristics ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ; Puig Llobet et al., 2020 ). Lluch’s conceptual model of PMH includes six factors, which are also used to define PMeHLterm·dom attributes: personal satisfaction, prosocial attitudeterm·dom, self-controlterm·dom, autonomy, problem-solving, self-actualization, and interpersonal relation skills ( Teixeira et al., 2022 ).
Furthermore, connection to mind and emotions encompasses the entire spectrum of basic cognitive, emotional, and psychological human experience, including the seven rights for mental health: a sense of belonging, control or mastery, self-esteem, meaning-making, values, motivation, and the need for secure relationships ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ).
Therefore, the defining attributesterm of PMeHLterm·dom are synthesized as follows: (a) Competence in problem-solving and self-actualization—refers to a sense of mastery and efficacy in controlling one’s surroundings (e.g., handling stressful situations in a good manner, believing in oneself, having good sleep routines, mastering negative thoughts and experiencing school mastery) ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ; Santini et al., 2020 ); includes analytical capacity, decision-making ability, and flexibility to adapt to changes, demonstrating an attitude of continuous growth and personal development ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ; Santini et al., 2020 ).
(b) Personal Satisfaction—alludes to self-concept, self-esteem and self-acceptance, the ability to be satisfied with one’s personal life, and having an optimistic outlook on the future ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ; Santini et al., 2020 ). This attribute also includes interest and motivation that leads to emotional and psychological well-being ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ; Santini et al., 2020 ) and feelings of happiness and life satisfaction ( Santini et al., 2020 ).
(c) Autonomy—relates to personal security and self-confidence, as well as independence, a sense of personal choice or acting toward one’s own goals and according to one’s ideals, and self-regulation of one’s behavior (e.g., influencing daily living activities, acting out one’s wishes, making decisions based on one’s will, setting limits for one’s actions and setting limits for what is good for oneself) ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).
(d) Relatedness and interpersonal relationship skills—includes the capacity to form interpersonal relationships, as well as empathy, which is defined as the ability to comprehend another’s feelings ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ). It covers the need to engage with, connect with, and care for others (e.g., having at least one good friend, being a good friend, feeling secure at home, feeling like a member of a community, and feeling worthwhile regardless of one’s own successes).
(e) Self-controlterm·dom—the capacity to manage stress/conflict, via emotional balance/control, and tolerate frustration, anxiety, and stress ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ).
(f) Prosocial attitudeterm·dom—an active predisposition toward society, including altruism and helping/supporting others, as well as acceptance of others and different social characteristics ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ). This predisposition is evidenced in terms of social functioning, such as contributing to the community, functioning well in the respective community and broader society, searching for social acceptance, actualization, and integration ( Santini et al., 2020 ).
Antecedentsterm Antecedentsterm are the events or attributes that must exist prior to the occurrence of a concept ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ). The 2000s brought enormous advances in “people’s knowledge, motivation, and competencies to access, understand, appraise, and apply information to make judgments and take decisions in everyday life concerning healthcare, disease prevention, and health promotion, and thus maintain and improve quality of life throughout the life course” ( Sørensen et al., 2012 , p. 3). From a salutogenic and socioecological perspective, the intervention of health care professionals takes place in different contexts and on a continuum, with special emphasis on health promotion and prevention.
The growing interest in searching for credible mental health information and being an active part in health decision-making has highlighted the person-centerd care model ( Pelletier and Stichler, 2014 ). Many factors affect individual PMeHLterm·dom, such as (a) individual factors (e.g., sex, race and ethnicity, educational level, mental health literacyterm·dom, cognitive and emotional skills, feelings of vulnerability and resilience, physical and mental condition, self-determination and help-seekingterm·key behavior) and (b) social/contextual factors (e.g., cultural background, social and interpersonal skills, environmental events, exposure to health information and social resources in community) ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 , 2018 , 2019 ; Santini et al., 2020 ).
Consequencesterm·key Consequencesterm·key are occurrences or incidents that might happen because a concept is present and that frequently leads to new ideas or study areas for that concept ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ). In this sense, consequencesterm·key of PMeHLterm·dom can be grouped into three spheres: (a) Individual sphere • Potential to promote, protect and restore mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 , 2018 , 2019 ).
• Prevention of the development of mental disorders, with positive relevance to physical health ( Iasiello et al., 2019 ; Mansfield et al., 2020 ; Puig Llobet et al., 2020 ).
• Maximization of hedonic and eudaimonic well-being ( Santini et al., 2020 ).
• Improved satisfaction with life ( Santini et al., 2020 ), connection, optimism and well-being ( Jay et al., 2021 ).
• Increased autonomy in problem-solving ability and improved productivity, self-esteem, learning outcomes, resilience and motivation ( Lluch-Canut et al., 2013 ; Sokołowska et al., 2018 ; Iasiello et al., 2019 ; Mansfield et al., 2020 ).
• Management of mental disorders and their treatments ( Kutcher et al., 2016a ; Sweileh, 2021 ).
• Increased help-seekingterm·key efficacy ( Kutcher et al., 2016b ).
• Improved health decisions to promote well-being ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).
(b) Relational/Social sphere • Promotion of interaction, social well-being, and social functioning and satisfaction ( Sokołowska et al., 2018 ; Iasiello et al., 2019 ; Mansfield et al., 2020 ) at the family, community or societal level (social contribution, social integration, social update, social acceptance, and social coherence) ( Santini et al., 2020 ).
• Promotion of good mental health and personal wellness among nurses, leading to more human connections, positive feelings, work satisfaction, and better care provision ( Jay et al., 2021 ).
• Promotion of the positive component of MHLterm·dom among non-professional caregivers through mhealth intervention ( Ferré-Grau et al., 2021 ).
(c) Contextual/organizational sphere • Development of mental health promotion programs ( Garmy et al., 2014 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ; Teixeira et al., 2020 ) involving a mixture of professions [school social workers, teachers, psychologists, and other healthcare professionals] ( Garmy et al., 2014 ; Diaz and Caboral-Stevens, 2021 ) and aligned with all development phases ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 , 2019 ; Teixeira et al., 2019 ; Santini et al., 2020 ).
• Decreased stigma associated with mental illness ( Kutcher et al., 2016a ; Sweileh, 2021 ).
• Development of “organizational empathy” ( Jay et al., 2021 ) as part of the nursing curricula. This competence facilitates the student’s transition to real workplace environments.
Diagram Model of PMeHLterm·dom Figure 2 illustrates the link between antecedentsterm, attributes, and positive consequencesterm·key in a comprehensive model of PMeHLterm·dom.
The link between PMeHLterm·dom’s antecedentsterm, attributes, and positive consequencesterm·key is illustrated in this conceptual model.
Case Scenarios Cases help articulate the concept’s meaning. The model case displays all of the concept’s defining attributesterm, whereas the borderline caseterm demonstrates most but not all of them, and the related case demonstrates only half of them. Lastly, the contrary case shows what the concept is not ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ).
Model Case According to Walker and Avant (2019) , a model case is a circumstance in which all of the concept’s defining characteristics are present. In order to improve comprehension of PMeHLterm·dom, we created a scenario to describe it with all of its identifying characteristics.
John is a 15-year-old son of divorced parents, has no siblings, and lives with his mother, with whom he has a good relationship. He feels safe at home. He has already flunked twice and is currently attending the 7th grade. He doesn’t identify much with his classmates because they are younger, although he demonstrates a willingness to participate in class activities and support his colleagues when they ask. He has a special friend with whom he shares his daily difficulties. To be with friends of the same age, who are already in high school, he spends some time at the skate park, which gives him personal satisfaction. His mother gets home quite late, for she has two jobs to balance the family finances. John reveals a good study-life balance and is able to set limits to his own actions. His remaining free time is spent on social media and the internet, which ends up being a source of information when he wants to learn more about Mental Health, problem-solving strategies and self-esteem promotion, and ways to deal with stress and anger. One of his favorite sites is https://mentalhealthliteracy.org/ . He is accompanied by the Advanced Practice Psychiatric Nurse (PMH-APRN) from the school’s health service, whom he often turns to on his own initiative. Due to these regular encounters, he feels more relaxed, confident and valued after talking. In addition, these meetings help him deal with adversities and daily problems. Sometimes he analyses and discusses the information obtained from these sources with his colleagues and teachers. He considers himself a resilient person, but sometimes he feels pressured by the stereotypes and negative social visions around him. In this model case, John has adequate PMeHLterm·dom to make his own decisions, as demonstrated by his accurate understanding of how to obtain and maintain good mental health.
Borderline Caseterm According to Walker and Avant (2019) , a borderline caseterm contains most of the defining attributesterm but not all of them. John is now 17 years old. After attending high school, he began to distance himself from friends, spending most of his time playing computer games, which gives him great satisfaction. For this reason, sleepless nights are increasingly common. His classmates begin to notice some anger and irritability in John’s behavior, revealing a lack of self-controlterm·dom. His school performance and results have deteriorated. In conversations with the PMH-APRN, he recognizes and expresses some depressive symptoms and loneliness. He accepts the idea of a specialized medical consultation, which his mother supports. John is ambivalent about taking sleep medication, as he fears becoming addicted. After sharing his concerns and receiving information, John decides to start his medication regimen. Whenever he has doubts or attributes an effect to the medication, he looks for information on the internet and asks the nurse for help. John receives support and understanding from his friends and feels comfortable sharing what is happening to him. This is an example of a borderline caseterm, because John demonstrates all PMeHLterm·dom attributes except one (e.g., self-controlterm·dom), but still demonstrates moderate PMeHLterm·dom and makes some inappropriate health decisions.
Related Case Related cases are instances in which the concept has some relation to the concept of focus, but does not contain every defining attributeterm ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ). Upon entering higher education, John moves to another city, leaving his closest friends behind. As part of his new academic routines, he goes out at night and parties with new colleagues, which provides him personal satisfaction. These new routines interfere once again with his sleep pattern. He begins to have difficulty accomplishing the therapeutic regimen and sometimes voluntarily suppresses some doses. John becomes more anxious and testier with colleagues, which affects school performance and generates conflicts with classmates and housemates. He seeks help from the PMH-APRN, but does not feel the same empathy and understanding as in high school, and consultations become less frequent. John begins to question his symptoms and treatment regimen, and his medication adherence wavers. He searches for new ways to control symptoms and gets information from less reliable sources, without scientific support. Colleagues move away from him, due to some of John’s disruptive behaviors. This related case scenario lacks half the PMeHLterm·dom attributes (e.g., relatedness, self-controlterm·dom, competence in solving problems).
Contrary Case Mary is a 17 years-old college student who has been diagnosed with schizophrenia. She questions her diagnosis and the need for treatment, showing little insight into her situation. She is very reluctant to adhere to the proposed therapeutic regimen, which she abandons frequently, thinking herself cured. She does not seek help or information and is very unreceptive and sometimes reactive when health professionals offer her help. Her symptoms worsen and begin to interfere with her social relationships, family dynamics, and school performance, even leading her to drop out of school. This final case is an example of a contrary case because Mary lacks all of the defining attributesterm of PMeHLterm·dom. She does not make the best judgments for her own care. She fails to control her mental illness, and because of her lack of PMeHLterm·dom, she will suffer long-term effects.
Empirical Referentsterm Empirical referentsterm are measurable indicators of the concept’s occurrence ( Walker and Avant, 2019 ). Across evaluated studies, only the 10-item Mental Health Promoting Knowledgeterm (MHPK-10term) scale measured knowledge of how to obtain and maintain good mental health ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ). This valid and reliable one-dimension instrument was developed from the previous MHLterm·dom definition, presented by Kutcher et al. (2016b) , and the three dimensions of Basic Psychological Needs Theory (competence, autonomy, and relatedness) (Deci and Vansteenkiste, 2004 cit in Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ). To establish a solid grounding for the instrument, the items were based on a sound theoretical framework, adolescents’ opinions, and recognized experts ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ). Respondents are asked to rank each item on a 6-point scale [do not know (0), completely wrong (1) … completely correct (5)], where a higher score implies greater knowledge. The MEST project ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 , 2019 ) used the MHPK-10term to assess mental health-promoting education activities aimed at enhancing variables favoring mental health and better customizing these programs among Norwegian adolescents. Every item in the MHPK-10term is deemed appropriate and translatable to public health practice, since MHLterm·dom is recognized as an outcome of mental health promotion actions ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).
Discussion In the current literature, PMeHLterm·dom is a dynamic concept, viewed simultaneously as: a) an outcome of mental health promotion actions, with a positive connection to physical health, social interaction and functioning, problem-solving ability, productivity, self-esteem, learning outcomes, resilience and motivation ( Lehtinen, 2008 ; Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ; Iasiello et al., 2019 ; Mansfield et al., 2020 ); and b) a resource or mediator of mental health and well-being, allowing the person to play a preventive role in the development of mental disorders ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 ).
In a broad sense, the antecedentsterm that promote PMeHLterm·dom represent the balance between the individual and the environment. These antecedentsterm are clustered into two main categories: individual factors and experiences, and social/contextual interactions (including societal resources, and cultural values) ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 , 2018 , 2019 ; Santini et al., 2020 ). The defining attributesterm that characterize people with PMeHLterm·dom include: (a) how they accept and value themselves; (b) how they control emotions by focusing on positive thoughts; (c) how they establish positive connections with others; (d) how they transform life’s disappointments into personal satisfaction; and (e) how they make their own decisions, revealing problem-solving skills. PMeHLterm·dom is a phenomenon that manifests positive consequencesterm·key, including the maximization of individual well-being on emotional, psychological and social domains ( Santini et al., 2020 ). This potential to promote, protect and restore mental health protects the individual against several negative outcomes in both people with and without mental disorders ( Bjørnsen et al., 2017 , 2018 , 2019 ). For Kutcher et al. (2016b) , PMeHLterm·dom increases the effectiveness in seeking help (knowing when, where and how to get good mental health care and developing the necessary skills for self-care) ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 ). Interestingly, age, gender, personality, educational, urban-rural, and cross-cultural differences in PMeHLterm·dom may differentially affect rates of help-seekingterm·key across different settings/sectors, including health, education, and workplace context ( Furnham and Swami, 2018 ).
According to Seedaket et al. (2020) , two types of interventions are widely used to improve PMeHLterm·dom: education-based and community-based interventions. The same authors concluded that stand-alone education-based interventions are likely more effective for improving MHLterm·dom among adolescents. Nevertheless, community-based interventions could be more effective in later stages of the lifespan, namely adulthood and old age, because they include a wider range of outcomes, including mental health-related knowledge, quality of life, and social well-being ( Castillo et al., 2019 ).
Because PMeHLterm·dom is dynamic, it is important to assess a person’s level of comprehension, motivation for behavioral change, and changes in age or health condition. Individuals with greater PMeHLterm·dom levels are more likely to engage in self-care and seek out resources from their family or social structure, community, or healthcare system. Individuals should be asked questions in an active voice that motivates them to ask more questions or seek more information while they are being educated ( Parnell et al., 2019 ). Importantly, nurses and other healthcare professionals must realize that every encounter with individuals and family members is a chance to assess people’s mental health literacyterm·dom and encourage learning and capacity to attain and maintain good mental health. Encouraging autonomy and personalizing treatment are two important aspects of effective nursing care.
Nurses must be educated on how to teach and incorporate mental health education into all elements of their normal care delivery, rather than consider it an additional duty ( Parnell et al., 2019 ). Traditional methods of education, such as those based on written materials or delivered in a classroom setting, must be reconsidered. Other active learning strategies, such as roleplaying simulations, digital health interventions, and communication skills training (e.g., conveying compassion and empathy, offering hope and humor, assertiveness, and active listening techniques), are required in basic and continuing education ( Parnell et al., 2019 ; LaranjeirapersName and QueridopersName, 2021 ).
Besides, a systematic approach to mental health promotion, such as MEST ( Bjørnsen et al., 2018 , 2019 ), suggests that school nurses, teachers and stakeholders collaborate and include positive MHLterm·dom in mental health education. In addition, primary research focused on nursing interventions that enhance and sustain PMeHLterm·dom in people and families should be prioritized. The findings of this concept analysisterm·key can be used to provide a conceptual framework for future study in this area.
Limitations There are a few limitations to this concept analysisterm·key. First, the literature search was thorough, but limited to two databases and the English and Portuguese literature; therefore, relevant publications may have been missed. Moreover, the established list of attributes, antecedentsterm, and consequencesterm·key may not be complete, and other existing PMeHLterm·dom elements may have been excluded from the current concept analysisterm·key. Third, while the research focuses mostly on adolescents, PMeHLterm·dom is a phenomenon that may occur in a variety of contexts (families, schools, streets, and workplaces) and health/illness type transitions, throughout the lifespan. Finally, the area is still dominated by a mental-illness perspective, with just a few measures used to examine PMeHLterm·dom. Further studies should look toward creating new measures that are reliable, valid, and feasible, as well as testing measurement invariance on existing PMeHLterm·dom measures across cultures. This might help understand cultural differences in mental health discourse and what it means to be positive mental healthterm·key literate.
Conclusion The PMeHLterm·dom concept is considered a component of MHLterm·dom, integrating positive mental healthterm·key, which deserves attention throughout the lifespan in different contexts and intervention levels. Emphasis on person-centerd care calls for a transformation of the mental-ill health paradigm ( Whitaker et al., 2021 ). Thus, PMeHLterm·dom can be operationalized in two ways: (a) as a resource or potential mediator between individual determinants and health(-related) outcomes and (b) as an outcome when attempting to decrease the impact of social/contextual inequalities on health(-related) outcomes. PMeHLterm·dom is not restricted to a particular action and may alter as circumstances change. In sum, by approaching PMeHLterm·dom as a multi-faceted and dynamic construct, we must learn more about the processes of improving mental health and promoting good behaviors.
Author Contributions All authors listed have made a substantial, direct, and intellectual contribution to the work and approved it for publication.
Conflict of Interest The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.
Publisher’s Note All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
Funding This work was funded by national funds through FCT—Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, I.P. (UIDB/05704/2020 and UIDP/05704/2020) and under the Scientific Employment Stimulus—Institutional Call [CEECINST/00051/2018].
References