Where the method came from

For 377 of 1673 papers in this corpus, the field a paper borrowed its machinery from · what crossed · and the sentence that says so

761transfers
377papers
563lending fields
698field→field edges
Nobody inferred any of this. Each row below is a note somebody wrote while reading the paper: the field its method came from, what crossed, and a quotation from the paper itself. Nash’s equilibrium proof borrows a fixed-point theorem — and thanks the colleague who suggested it, in the paper. Mendel borrows counting and ratios from mathematics and says he means “definitely to ascertain their statistical relations”.

Who lends, who borrows

field the method came frompapers
machine learning41
statistics22
information theory17
artificial intelligence15
psychophysics14
signal detection theory11
network science10
psychology10
signal processing10
statistical physics9
cognitive psychology9
computer science7
natural language processing7
linguistics7
frominton
machine learningneuroscience23
information theoryneuroscience15
psychophysicsneuroscience13
signal detection theoryneuroscience9
signal processingneuroscience8
visual neuroscienceneuroscience7
optogeneticsneuroscience6
systems identificationneuroscience5
network scienceneuroscience4
statisticsmedicine4
bayesian statisticsneuroscience4
virologyneuroscience4
statisticsneuroscience4
clinical neurologyneuroscience4
statisticsbiology4
artificial intelligencechemistry3

How these are counted

from_field is free text and often names more than one source — “mathematics / statistics (counting, proportions, combinatorics)”. The parenthetical is an explanation rather than part of the name, so it is dropped, and the rest is split on / ; , and “and”. A row naming two fields counts as a transfer from each, because that is what it is. A different rule would give different totals, so the rule is printed rather than the number alone.

Every transfer, by the field that borrowed

neuroscience 463 transfers
← communications engineering / radio transmission
The carrier-wave and demodulation model: theta is treated as a carrier whose modulation carries the message, and the analysis strips the carrier phase to read that message out
By analogy to radio communication, we defined the theta oscillation to be a carrier wave whose modulation contains information.
← signal processing / applied mathematics
The compressed-sensing result that sparse signals can be recovered from mixed, subsampled measurements, used to justify recovering position from pooled field potentials by unsupervised learning
Because position encoding is sparse, a theoretical result ( 14 ) based on compressed sensing ( 15 ) suggests that unsupervised learning can discover position-dependent sparse structure in the LFP without explicit knowledge of the rat’s position.
← radio communication / signal processing
the carrier-and-modulation model of a signal, and the demodulation operation that recovers the message from it, applied to a brain rhythm
By analogy to radio communication, we defined the theta oscillation to be a carrier wave whose modulation contains information.
← compressed sensing
the result that a sparse signal is recoverable from mixed and subsampled measurements, used to justify reading position out of pooled field potentials
Because position encoding is sparse, a theoretical result ( 14 ) based on compressed sensing ( 15 ) suggests that unsupervised learning can discover position-dependent sparse structure in the LFP without explicit knowledge of the rat’s position.
← information theory
the classical measurement of information as reduction of uncertainty in bits, applied to brain states and conscious experience
Classically, information is the reduction of uncertainty among alternatives: when a coin falls on one of its two sides, it provides 1 bit of information, whereas a die falling on one of six faces provides ~2.6 bits.
← information theory
the bit and the reduction of uncertainty among alternatives, imported wholesale as the measure of how much experience a brain state constitutes
Classically, information is the reduction of uncertainty among alternatives: when a coin falls on one of its two sides, it provides 1 bit of information, whereas a die falling on one of six faces provides ~2.6 bits.
← network science
small-world topology, used to explain why a small pharmacological insult to a few long-range connections can fragment the whole system
Small-world networks have mostly local connectivity with comparatively few long-range connections. Augmented with hubs, such networks maximize interactions while minimizing wiring.
← information theory / time-series analysis
transfer entropy, borrowed as a directional measure so that feedforward and feedback interactions can be scored separately
transfer entropy, a measure of directional interactions among brain areas, is balanced in the feedforward (green) and feedback (red) directions
← probability, via games of chance
the die as a model of a state repertoire, extended so that losing integration shatters it into many dice and losing information flattens it to two faces
If integration is lost (as in anesthesia or sleep), the die disintegrates into many two-faced dice, each generating 1 bit of information.
← reading research
the expertise-driven ventral visual shift toward symbols and away from faces, transposed from literacy to mathematics
Those results are analogous to previous findings on literacy, showing that the acquisition of expertise in reading shifts the responses of left ventral visual cortex toward letters and away from faces
← multivariate pattern analysis
representational similarity, used to test whether math, arithmetic and numeral viewing share an activation topography within each subject
Second, we used representational similarity analysis to probe whether a similar pattern of activation was evoked, within each subject, by all math-related activities: i.e., mathematical reflection, calculation, and numbers or formula recognition.
← classical experimental psychology of arousal and performance
the Yerkes-Dodson inverted-U law, imported to explain why the same amphetamine dose helps low-NP and harms high-NP rats
This “rate-dependent” effect of AMPH recalls the widely observed pattern described in the Yerkes-Dodson law, which states that performance, especially in difficult tasks, initially increases with physiological or mental arousal, but when levels of arousal become too high, performance is degraded
← primate behavioural neurophysiology
the head-fixed operant behavioral technique, which currently did not exist for visual discrimination in mice, and the comparison to visual behavior and neurophysiology in carnivores and primates
The mouse is the pre-eminent mammalian model system for genetic labeling or manipulation of specific cortical cell classes (O'Connor et al., 2009 ). Cellular imaging in mice offers immense potential for understanding cortical function in healthy mice, as well as in mouse models of neurologic disease (e.g., Eichhoff et…
← signal detection theory
the discriminability measure and its inverse-normal definition
A useful measure of behavioral discriminability of targets from non-targets is given by d ′ = norminv(HR) − norminv(FA), where norminv() is the inverse of the cumulative normal function (Green and Swets, 1966 ). Values for HR and FA were truncated between 0.01 and 0.99. Higher d ′ values indicate better…
← mouse genetics
transgenic labeling of an entire inhibitory class, which is what makes the recorded identity more than a waveform
Excitatory neurons and inhibitory neurons could be classified in vivo in this mouse due to expression of green fluorescent protein in all GABAergic neurons (Figure 2 A, green neurons; Tamamaki et al., 2003 ; Sohya et al., 2007 ; Kerlin et al., 2009 ). An example of orientation-tuned responses to drifting gratings…
← astrocyte imaging
the red calcium-insensitive dye, repurposed here as a motion reference rather than as a cell marker
A local volume was loaded with a green synthetic calcium indicator (OGB1-AM), and astrocytes were co-loaded with sulforhodamine (SR101; Nimmerjahn et al., 2004 ), a red, calcium-insensitive fluorescent dye that generates a constant average fluorescence level in the absence of brain motion
← spatial navigation electrophysiology
place cells, grid cells, border cells and head direction cells, carried into a task with no spatial dimension
SMT firing fields of both place cells and grid cells were similar to those of other cells and spanned the entire task, including periods when the rat was immobile ( Extended Data Fig. 10 ). Other spatial cell types, including border cells and head direction cells, were also SMT-modulated (e.g. cell 9 in Fig. 4b…
← spatial navigation electrophysiology
the spatial information measure, applied unchanged to time bins instead of spatial bins
To detect place cells, we calculated “spatial information” 34 – the mutual information rate between spikes and location – using the same formula as above ( Eqn. 2 ), but using the 1600 spatial bins instead of time bins. Place cells were defined as cells for which the information rate exceeded 99% of the values for the…
← auditory psychophysics
the perceptually uniform logarithmic frequency axis, used as the continuous dimension to be traversed
To test this idea, we designed a “sound manipulation task” (SMT), in which rats changed the frequency of sound in their environment ( Fig. 1a ). Animals deflected a joystick to activate a pure tone produced by a sound speaker. They continued deflecting in order to increase frequency along a perceptually uniform…
← human fmri of cognitive spaces
the claim that continuous non-spatial dimensions are mapped by this circuit, brought down to single units
However, the hippocampal/entorhinal circuit is involved not only in spatial navigation, but in a variety of memory-guided behaviors 6 . The relationship between this general function and the specialized spatial activity patterns is unclear. A conceptual framework reconciling these views is that spatial representation…
← signal processing / wavelet analysis
Morlet wavelet convolution at roughly six cycles, used to resolve gamma power in time without committing to fixed epochs
For each trial, bipolar derivations were analyzed in the time–frequency domain by convolution with complex Gaussian Morlet wavelets with a bandwidth parameter f 0 /σ f = 6, i.e., wavelets of approximately six cycles length.
← computational statistics
Monte Carlo resampling used not to test the hypothesis but to establish that the reported null had the power to have found an effect
Post hoc power analysis was done with Monte Carlo simulations.
← multiple-comparison methodology
false discovery rate control applied across the full electrode-by-time grid, which is what lets the per-electrode table be read as a whole
Results were corrected for multiple comparisons using false discovery rate across all time windows and electrodes.
← visual cortical neurophysiology
the neural-timescale metric (decay constant of an exponential fit to the spike-count autocorrelation), developed for hierarchies of visual cortical areas and here applied to the auditory pathway
Neural timescales also increase across hierarchies of visual cortical areas, where it is quantified as the decay time constant ( τ ) of an exponential fit to the temporal spike count autocorrelation.
← visual neuroscience
the autocorrelation-decay measure of neural timescale, and the expectation that it lengthens up a hierarchy
Neural timescales also increase across hierarchies of visual cortical areas, where it is quantified as the decay time constant ( τ ) of an exponential fit to the temporal spike count autocorrelation.
← human cognitive neuroscience
the paradigm of contrasting repeating with random acoustic patterns
The protocol we introduce here was inspired by changes in cortical activity and perceptual awareness of complex repeating acoustic patterns in human subjects.
← machine learning
the binary support vector machine, used here as a readout of ensemble state
We then used a binary support vector machine (SVM) on the principal components projection to classify whether ensemble activity for each cycle came from the rhythmic or random stimulus context
← visual attention research
the finding that harder tasks recruit more attention, and the probe-trial design used to demonstrate it
To test the hypothesis that more attentional resources were devoted during difficult (low SNR) tasks than during easy (high SNR) tasks, we modified the task structure by randomly inserting probe trials (25%) of intermediate difficulty during a block of difficult or easy trials (75%). We reasoned that if detection…
← signal processing
the matched filter, imported as the model for how a receptive field should adapt to separate foreground from background
In all these experiments, the pattern of STRF changes that emerged followed a simple model in which the acoustic features of the foreground were enhanced and those of the background suppressed, a hypothesis which we called a “contrast matched filter
← classical memory psychology
serial position curves and the primacy effect, imported as the behavioural handle on a neural question
It has been proposed that the primacy effect is due to the fact that items at early list positions undergo more extensive rehearsal than items presented later ( Rundus, 1971 ; Brodie and Murdock, 1977 ). This idea suggests a link between LTM formation and rehearsal processes, which are attributed to working memory
← educational assessment
the PISA socioeconomic questionnaire, adapted as the grouping variable
The SES criteria consisted of parental education, occupation, and family resources, which together represented SES better than any of these alone
← psychophysics
the distance effect from Moyer and Landauer's reaction-time paradigm, used here as the task manipulation
Moyer and Landauer (1967) were the first to measure the RT in a selection paradigm by pressing the associated button. They found that participants made more mistakes and required more time when the two numbers to be compared were close (e.g., 7 vs. 9) than farther apart (e.g., 2 vs. 9). That is, there is a distance…
← optogenetics
a channel expressed in one projection population, which is what makes a single pathway separable from the three that share its target layer
To explore this, we expressed the optogenetic excitatory channel oChIEF ( Lin et al. 2009 ) in layers 2 and 3 (L2 and L3) of medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) to study the impact of these inputs onto PCs and interneurons with cell bodies located in the SO of hippocampal CA1. The MEC was chosen as the viral expression…
← mouse genetics
the driver lines that decide which region can be targeted - and here, which region was studied
To explore this, we expressed the optogenetic excitatory channel oChIEF ( Lin et al. 2009 ) in layers 2 and 3 (L2 and L3) of medial entorhinal cortex (MEC) to study the impact of these inputs onto PCs and interneurons with cell bodies located in the SO of hippocampal CA1. The MEC was chosen as the viral expression…
← neuropathology
the reported distribution of tau across the two pathways, used to argue the studied one matters clinically
In addition to being important for normal brain function, the EC is one of the first regions in the brain to display neurodegeneration and dysfunction in Alzheimer’s disease (AD) ( Braak and Del Trecidi 2015 ). The initial pathology associated with AD is hallmarked by an accumulation of hyperphosphorylated tau protein…
← oscillation research
theta burst stimulation as the physiological input pattern, rather than single shocks
Although the timing of action potentials in individual MEC L3 projection neurons do not correlate well with population EC theta field potentials, MEC L3 projection neurons do fire coherently with their own internal theta activity
← structural biology
a crystal structure and an electrostatic potential calculation, used as the design specification for a behavioural tool
The design and functional features of these next-generation chloride-conducting channelrhodopsins provide both chronic and acute timescale tools for reversible optogenetic inhibition, confirm fundamental predictions of the ion selectivity model
← synaptic physiology
shunting inhibition by GABA-A receptors, used as the model for how the engineered channel acts
through iC++ activation will reduce excitability, just as seen with endogenous chloride-conducting channels such as GABA A receptors, providing efficient inhibition via shunting of excitatory inputs
← genomics
genome-wide sequencing and gene-ontology network analysis, imported to turn a memory manipulation into a direction of transcriptional change rather than a candidate-gene test
Gene ontology and gene network analyses of differentially expressed genes revealed that genes up-regulated in the mPFC during associative memory encoding form a highly interconnected network involved in biological processes that promote synaptic plasticity and memory formation, including synthesis of cAMP…
← microbial optogenetics
a light-driven chloride pump under a cell-type-specific promoter, which converts a regional correlation into an epoch-specific causal test
Next, we used an in vivo optogenetic approach to permit real-time manipulation of excitatory mPFC neuronal activity in freely behaving mice.
← visual object perception
the definition of a perceptual object - AN AUDITORY PERCEPTUAL OBJECT, LIKE ITS VISUAL COUNTERPARTS, IS DEFINED BY THE BINDING OF MULTIPLE SENSORY FEATURES, REPRESENTS A SOURCE DISTINCT FROM OTHERS IN THE SCENE, AND IS INVARIANT OVER DIFFERENT SENSORY INSTANCES
An auditory perceptual object, like its visual counterparts, is defined by the binding of multiple sensory features, represents a source distinct from others in the scene, and is invariant over different sensory instances
← spatial navigation research
the volume-function logic of the taxi-driver finding, applied to musicians and piano-tuners - POSITIVE RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN YEARS OF TRAINING AND ANTERIOR HIPPOCAMPAL GRAY MATTER VOLUME
Such associations have been found, with positive relationships between years of training and anterior hippocampal gray matter volume in musicians ( Groussard et al., 2014 , Groussard et al., 2010a ) and piano-tuners
← movement and state neurophysiology
the low dimension and brain-wide footprint of behavioral signals, used here as a diagnostic signature
This hypothesis predicts that sound-evoked activity in V1 should have the typical attributes of behavioral signals: low dimension 13 and a broad footprint 14 , 21 , 22 that extends beyond the cortex 13 . Moreover, sound-evoked activity should be independent of direct inputs from auditory cortex and should be…
← factorial analysis of variance
the marginalisation that separates video-related from sound-related components
We then identified the visual and auditory components of each neuron’s sensory response. A typical V1 neuron responded differently to different combinations of videos and sounds (Fig. 1a ). To characterize these responses, we used a marginalization procedure similar to factorial ANOVA. To measure the neuron’s…
← high-dimensional visual coding
cross-validated principal component analysis, and the contrast with a high-dimensional image code
The arrays of sound-related activity A , of video-related activity V and of audiovisual interactions I describe the activity of many neurons. To summarize this activity, we used cvPCA 15 . In this approach, principal component projections are found from one-half of the data, and an unbiased estimate of the reliable…
← connectomics
a published fiber atlas, used to estimate what fraction of the projection the cut actually removed
To estimate the extent of the fibers that were cut by the transectomy, we took advantage of the large-scale connectivity database of experiments performed by the Allen Brain Institute (Allen Mouse Brain Connectivity Atlas 26 , https://connectivity.brain-map.org/ ). Using custom Python scripts, we selected and…
← optogenetics / viral circuit tracing
retrograde Cre plus a FLEX opsin, used to make a projection — not a cell type and not a region — the unit of manipulation
We used viral transfection methods to selectively drive excitatory or inhibitory opsin expression in AC-IC projections.
← sensory coding / information theory
sparseness as the measure of how selective a tuning curve is
To examine frequency selectivity of neurons, sparseness of frequency tuning was computed as:
← systems identification
the spectro-temporal receptive field, estimated from dynamic random chords
The unbiased nature of this stimulus allowed us to estimate the spectro-temporal receptive field of neurons (STRF), which quantifies the dynamics of sound waveform in time and frequency that lead to a neuronal response.
← regression modelling
slope and intercept of an on-versus-off fit, used to separate a multiplicative change in gain from an additive one
This analysis can reveal whether changes in frequency selectivity are linear/subtractive, multiplicative/divisive, or some combination of these transformations.
← primate and human neuropsychology
Posner's covert orienting paradigm, rebuilt for rats - the transfer this review argues may have failed in translation
However, the procedural parameters of the tasks used in primates and rodents are necessarily different. For example, the location of the eyes on the rat’s head prevents it from fixating a central point like primates. Instead, in the rat version of this task, subjects must maintain a nosepoke into a central port for…
← human clinical neuropsychology
the Wisconsin Card Sorting task, transferred as a rodent perceptual set-shifting procedure
The fact that PPC damage impaired discrimination after an extra dimensional shift suggests that it may be involved in attention that is required when the meaning of a stimulus has changed.
← associative learning theory
the Pearce-Hall account of attention as driven by violated prediction, used as the framework for interpreting lesion effects
According to one influential theory ( Pearce & Hall, 1980 ), a CS will capture attention if its meaning surprisingly changes. This increase in attention to the CS enhances subsequent learning about that cue
← drug-use epidemiology
the anonymous online survey, adopted because the substances are illegal and cannot easily be studied otherwise
Since psychedelics have been classified under Schedule I in the 1971 conventions of the United Nations 21 and remain illegal in many countries, observational studies such as anonymous online surveys have been used to assess the use, misuse and potential therapeutic properties of psychedelics
← clinical psychometrics
the OCI-r severity scale, used to screen respondents who had no clinical diagnosis
We then selected our population of interest based on OCD symptoms and kept for analyses the data from participants who had either a diagnosis of OCD performed by a health professional (n = 9), or an OCI-r score superior to 18 (n = 62) 29 or both (n = 103). The rationale was to include participants who had not been…
← nineteenth-century philosophy and psychology
the primary and secondary memory distinction, carried into neuroscience under new names
As Squire (2004) points out, the first theoretical approaches relevant to current neuroscience come from the 19th century. These include Maine de Biran (1804/1929) ( Maine de Biran, 1929 ) who, at the beginning of the century, wrote of mechanical memory, sensitive memory, and representative memory. The philosopher…
← conditioning research
Pavlov's work, reclassified afterwards as the origin of associative memory
The importance of Pavlov (1927) and Fitts and Posner (1967) are especially noteworthy during the first two thirds of the 20th century. Pavlov’s studies are related to a type of memory that later would be called associative memory. Meanwhile, Fitts and Posner’s studies are considered the first model to explain…
← clinical neuropsychology
the amnesic patient as the instrument that separates memory types
The experimental modern era arguably began when Milner (1962) demonstrated, with HM experiments, that a seriously ill patient could acquire a new skill (hand-eye coordination) without any memory of having encountered the task before. “While this finding showed that memory is not unitary, discussions at the time tended…
← medical genetics
two syndromes with opposite spared abilities, used as a natural double dissociation
Wang and Bellugi (1994) presented a genetically based test that supports the functional and anatomical separation of Baddeley’s model with phonological and visuospatial storehouses. They compared two genetic syndromes (Williams and Down) with different brain morphology. Williams syndrome patients, despite having…
← primate psychophysics
the whole task toolbox - random-dot motion, forced choice, psychometric curves - carried into rodents together with the standards for interpreting it
However, rigorous psychophysical methods are not yet as developed for these rodents as they are for primates.
← signal detection theory in engineering and psychophysics
the separation of sensitivity from criterion, imported as the reason a rodent task must measure false alarms and not only hits
In SDT, one measures not only the rate of correct detections, but also the rate of false alarms: trials where the animal reported the stimulus or attribute was present when it wasn't. These rates yield a measure of detectability called d ', which is independent of criterion, and thus immune to its changes.
← microbial/algal photobiology
a microbial light-sensitive cation channel is imported as the tool for driving a specific mammalian cortical cell type in vivo
we used the light-sensitive bacteriorhodopsin Chlamydomonas reinhardtii channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2), a cation channel activated by ~470 nm blue light
← non-human primate motor physiology
the encoding of movement in M1, transferred to human brain-computer interfaces - the transfer the paper says IS licensed, because the anatomy is evidently similar
Largely through research with non-human primates, a foundation was developed for understanding the anatomic and functional organization of primary motor cortex and other motor-related areas ( Evarts, 1966 , 1967 , 1968b , 1968a ; Fetz, 1969 ; DeLong, 1971 ; DeLong and Strick, 1974 ; Tanji and Evarts, 1976 ; Weinrich…
← animal models of epilepsy
the transfer the paper says is NOT licensed, because the correspondence to human epilepsy is unclear
Unlike the motor prosthesis approach in which the similarity between nonhuman primate M1 and human M1 is evident in the underlying anatomy (and, as now being demonstrated, physiology), the relationship between any given animal model of epilepsy and the various forms of human epilepsy is unclear.
← computer science and machine learning
clustering algorithms, dimensionality reduction and point-process methods, imported to make terabyte-scale spike data tractable
First amongst these are new methods for extracting spiking information from large data sets. These ‘clustering’ algorithms are now available in a variety of different forms with optimization for high speed (essentially real-time) and for working with particularly large data sets.
← microbial optogenetics
two opsins with opposite sign in the same cell type, which is what makes a bidirectional test of an optimum possible at all
Optogenetic enhancement and suppression of SOM-IN activity during training destabilized and hyper-stabilized spines, respectively, and both manipulations impaired the learning of stereotyped movements.
← developmental biology
in utero electroporation, used to place a postsynaptic inhibitory marker in excitatory neurons so that inhibition onto them can be counted directly
To address this issue, we expressed GFP-tagged Gephyrin, a postsynaptic scaffolding protein at inhibitory synapses, in L2/3 excitatory neurons using in utero electroporation
← cortical two-photon imaging
the Vglut2-Cre and VGAT-Cre lines, chosen because IC excitatory neurons express the Vglut2 but not Vglut1 and glycinergic neurons are absent from the IC
To target glutamatergic excitatory neurons, we used the Vglut2-Cre line (Fig. 2a ), as IC excitatory neurons express the Vglut2 but not Vglut1 28 . To target GABAergic inhibitory neurons, we used the VGAT-Cre line (Fig. 2b ), as glycinergic neurons, which also express VGAT, are absent from the IC
← visual system research
the disinhibition circuit motif and the locomotion-gain literature, used as the expectation this structure then fails to meet
The mechanism of locomotion-related effects is still unclear. In the ACx, Zhou et al. found that the excitatory and parvalbumin-positive inhibitory neurons are inhibited by the cortical layer 1 (L1) neurons, while Schneider et al. 23 reported that inhibitory neurons are excited by motor cortex, which in turn inhibits…
← auditory brainstem anatomy
sharply tuned ventral cochlear nucleus projections, used to explain a selectivity the local circuit does not account for
What might be the source of the high-frequency selectivity seen in the IC shell L1 inhibitory neurons? Using two-photon-guided whole-cell recording, Geis and Borst revealed that the IC shell L1 inhibitory neurons that have large somas receive shorter first-spike latency excitatory inputs than other neurons 49 . Using…
← superior colliculus research
the finding that inhibitory neurons there are the more selective ones, used as a cross-structure parallel
It is worth noting that inhibitory neurons in the mouse SC superficial layers are also more direction selective than the excitatory neurons 41 , and the origin of the direction selectivity is the retina 51 . Inhibitory neurons in the IC shell and SC superficial layers project to the nonlemniscal thalamus and…
← tissue optics / radiative-transfer photon-transport modelling
Monte Carlo simulation of light propagation with Henyey-Greenstein and Gegenbauer-kernel anisotropic scattering phase functions, imported to predict how deep red light penetrates brain tissue and skull
To achieve accurate simulations of light propagation close to the optical fiber, before the orientation of photon trajectories is randomized by multiple scattering events, we used an anisotropic scattering model with either Henyey-Greenstein or Gegenbauer kernel phase functions, as indicated below.
← microbial biology
a rhodopsin from a halophilic archaeon, screened as a scaffold rather than studied for itself
We therefore screened members of the cruxhalorhodopsin class in primary neuronal culture to identify molecules with both red-shifted action spectra and robust photocurrents ( Fig. 1a and Supplementary Fig. 2 ) and identified a hyperpolarizer we named Halo57, the cruxhalorhodopsin from H. salinarum (strain Shark), with…
← ion channel biology
trafficking sequences taken from the Kir2.1 potassium channel to improve membrane delivery
We subsequently engineered Halo57 by identifying K200R and W214F point mutations 19 , 20 ( Fig. 1b ), which significantly boosted photocurrents without altering its red action spectrum ( n = 9 or 10 cells; P = 0.02, ANOVA with Dunnett’s post hoc test), and by appending the KGC 21 or ER2 (ref. 22 ) trafficking…
← biomedical optics
Monte Carlo modelling of light transport, used to justify the wavelength choice before any protein was made
Because red light is less absorbed by hemoglobin than blue, green or yellow wavelengths, we reasoned this red-light sensitivity might render deep brain regions more accessible. We validated this through Monte Carlo modeling and direct measurement in the live mouse brain
← visual masking research
equal numbers of stimulus and blank trials within each masking condition, so that mask-blank-mask ERPs can be subtracted from mask-stimulus-mask ERPs
Complementary blanks were presented on 50% of all trials, with 25% lightly masked and 25% heavily masked. This was to ensure equal numbers of stimulus and blank trials within each masking condition, for purposes of subtracting mask-blank-mask ERPs from mask-stimulus-mask ERPs.
← no-report paradigms
participants count how many times the green circle appeared during each 64-trial block, with a single button-press response at the end of the block
During the no-report condition, participants were instructed to count how many times the green circle appeared during each 64-trial block, providing a three-alternative-forced-choice (3-AFC) button-press response at the end of each block to indicate four, six, or eight green circles (number of circles presented varied…
← bayesian hypothesis testing
a Bayes factor against a specified prior, used to argue for an absence rather than merely fail to reject
Because our hypotheses included the absence of a P3b in the no-report condition, we also conducted planned Bayesian analyses to determine whether our nonsignificant result was due to statistical insensitivity, or whether this result provides evidence in favor of the null hypothesis. First, we compared the mean voltage…
← recognition memory testing
an unexpected memory test with foils, used as an objective measure of what was consciously seen when no report was collected
After the 15 blocks of each condition, participants were given an incidental memory test, to verify the manipulation of visibility via masking, regardless of the task. Accordingly, during these memory tests, participants were shown the eight visible (lightly masked) images, the eight heavily masked (invisible) images…
← cell assembly theory
Hebb's idea that memories are represented by distributed ensembles activated concurrently, used as the reason synchrony should matter to memory
Such rhythms reflect the synchronized activity of large numbers of neurons because synchronous currents sum together to generate large-amplitude fluctuations in LFP, whereas non-synchronized currents do not sum together and thus remain too small to be detected.
← computational modelling
network simulations in which gamma frequency follows excitatory drive and GABA conductance, used to explain why one circuit could produce both subtypes
Theoretical work has shown that the frequency of gamma rhythms generated by networks of hippocampal interneurons can vary depending on the strength of excitatory and inhibitory inputs 141 . Specifically, in simulations of gamma activity in a model neuron network, gamma frequency was found to increase with increased…
← virology
monosynaptic rabies tracing, adapted to single starter cells and to developmental time points
In addition to providing specific insights regarding the development of connectivity onto Re + interneurons, our findings suggest that monosynaptic tracing using the rabies virus provides an effective method for determining the afferent connectivity of cortical neurons at different developmental time points.
← retinogeniculate development
the finding that specific rather than global activity refines connectivity, used as the frame for this result
These observations emphasize that understanding how brain wiring is achieved will require a case-by-case examination of how different cell types and the cortical microcircuits they contribute to are assembled.
← behavioural economics
the BDM incentive-compatible auction, used to elicit each participant's willingness-to-pay as an objective measure of item value
BDM is widely used in behavioural economics and neuroeconomics to elicit non-strategic reservation prices also known as willingness-to-pay (WTP).
← perceptual decision-making research
the idea that confidence is a second-order metacognitive judgement measurable separately from the choice itself, imported into value-based choice
In contrast, the field of perceptual decision-making has highlighted the fact that confidence can be measured independently of the choice process itself
← perceptual decision-making
the second-order framing of confidence and the requirement to measure it separately from choice
In contrast, the field of perceptual decision-making has highlighted the fact that confidence can be measured independently of the choice process itself 9 , 10 , where it is conceptualized as reflecting a “second-order” metacognitive evaluation. Critically, dissociating confidence from other features of the decision…
← experimental economics
the BDM auction, used to make stated values incentive-compatible
To establish value for individual items we asked participants at the end of the scanning session to place a bid for each food item using a standard incentive compatible procedure, the Becker–DeGroot–Marschak (BDM) mechanism 15 . BDM is widely used in behavioural economics and neuroeconomics to elicit non-strategic…
← sequential sampling theory
the race model, imported from perceptual choice into value-based choice
We adapted a race model 7 , 21 wherein evidence in favor of each option (the snacks presented on the left and right side of the screen) is accumulated over time and the decision is made on the basis of the first option to reach a threshold ( Figure 2b ). In this model confidence is defined as the absolute difference…
← psychophysics
per-subject psychophysical detection thresholds measured beforehand and used to set the stimulus values for single-unit recording, so neural responses are read against each animal's own perceptual scale
The precise AM and ∆BW values used during recording sessions were tailored to each subject’s psychophysical thresholds for detection of each sound feature (AM and ∆BW) in isolation, determined prior to recording.
← molecular virology
a Cre-dependent viral construct carrying tetanus toxin light chain, used to make a silencing permanent rather than reversible
To demonstrate a possible causative role of defunct PV neurons in the generation of TLE, we permanently inhibited GABA release selectively from PV neurons of the ventral subiculum by injecting a viral vector expressing tetanus toxin light chain in male mice. Subsequently, mice were subjected to telemetric EEG…
← chemogenetics
the designer-receptor system, imported specifically to supply the SHORT time course the toxin cannot give
At this point, we asked whether already transient inhibition of GABA release from PV-containing interneurons would be sufficient to induce C-SWDs and SRSs. We therefore injected PV-cre mice into the ventral subiculum with AAV vector-expressing hM4Di receptors (AAV -hM4Di ), which are exclusively activated by designer…
← cannabinoid pharmacology
a CB1 agonist used not as a treatment but as a subtraction, to remove one inhibitory source so the other becomes visible
However, when we applied the CB1 receptor agonist WIN 55,212–2 to suppress GABA release from non-PV, cholecystokinin (CCK)-containing basket cells we observed, consistent with a previous report on CA1 neurons ( Murray et al., 2011 ), that the amplitude of the WIN 55,212–2-insensitive component of the eIPSC…
← clinical neuropathology
the observation that these cells are preferentially lost in patients, which is the correlation the whole experiment tries to convert into a cause
Interestingly, PV-containing interneurons are preferentially lost in the subiculum of patients with TLE even without Ammon's horn sclerosis ( Andrioli et al., 2007 ). Also in animal models of TLE, PV-containing interneurons of the subiculum selectively degenerate after an initial status epilepticus ( Dinocourt et al…
← short term memory research
the magic number of seven plus or minus two items, related to the number of nested gamma cycles a theta cycle can hold
This would enable the hippocampal network to represent four to eight items per theta cycle (corresponding to the number of nested gamma cycles), which has been related (Lisman and Idiart, 1995 ) to the “magic number” of 7 ± 2 items that humans can typically hold in short term memory (Miller, 1956 ).
← neuroimaging
the argument that robust activation patterns can be detected without access to the fine time scale of neuronal computation, carried over to tagged-ensemble experiments
A parallel can be made with fRMI studies showing robust and consistent activation patterns in response to similar stimuli, despite the low temporal and spatial resolution of the technique (Guest and Love, 2017 ). Thus, while certain types of computation can still be detected or elicited even without having access to…
← coupled oscillator theory
two oscillators of slightly different frequency drifting apart from a common start, used as the original model of phase precession
The detuned oscillators model was originally proposed by O'Keefe and Recce ( 1993 ) in their initial report of phase precession, and remains one of the most elegant hypotheses to date 1 ( Figure 3A ). This model considers a place cell that oscillates at a slightly faster frequency than theta. These two oscillators…
← network modelling
transmission delays through an asymmetrically connected chain, used to produce phase precession without any assumption about single-cell oscillation
In the network connectivity models , contrary to the above cellular models in which no particular synaptic connectivity is assumed, phase precession results from transmission delays between asymmetrically connected cells ( Figure 3C ; Jensen and Lisman, 1996 ; Skaggs et al., 1996 ; Tsodyks et al., 1996 ; Romani and…
← visual neuroscience
the what and where stream division, applied to audition
acoustic features well known to stimulate distinct ventral (“what”) and dorsal (“where”) neural pathways in humans
← psychoacoustics
HRTFs, used to render spatial separation over headphones
The HRTF coefficients were individually determined by a brief sound localization task at the beginning of the experiment. On each trial, 1 of the 4 vowels was presented at 1 of the 5 azimuth locations (i.e., −90°, −45°, 0°, 45°, 90°) using a variety of HRTF coefficients selected from the TDT library that best suited…
← animal electrophysiology
the finding that task relevance, not exposure, drives rapid receptive-field change
For instance, changes in the receptive fields of ferret auditory cortex can occur within minutes of a tone discrimination task that was previously learned ( Fritz et al. 2003 , 2005a , 2005b ). However, these neuroplastic changes were smaller or absent if the animal listened passively to the same sounds (i.e., when…
← information theory
the decrease in noise entropy associated with increasing correlations, which is where the improvement in encoding accuracy comes from
We found that this improvement results from a decrease in noise entropy that is associated with increasing correlations if the marginal distributions are unchanged. Surprisingly, for constant noise entropy and in the limit of large populations, the encoding accuracy is independent of both structure and magnitude of…
← signal processing
diagonalisation of a circulant matrix in the Fourier basis, which is what makes very large populations analytically tractable
When correlations are increased, the noise power increases in a few low-frequency Fourier components while it decreases in all higher-frequency components (it quickly asymptotes to 1 − c 0 with increasing frequency; Fig. 1 D ). Because in homogeneous populations the stimulus encoding is confined to the low-frequency…
← estimation theory
the Cramer-Rao bound and estimator bias, used to check that the measure being compared is attainable at all
One potential caveat that has to be addressed when using Fisher information is that it provides only a bound (the Cramér–Rao bound) on the accuracy of a population code. Unfortunately, under some conditions potentially relevant for neural coding this bound is not tight, which means there exists no estimator that…
← experimental v1 physiology
408 measured orientation tuning curves, used to set the heterogeneity parameter rather than to test the theory
We set κ = 0.25 as determined from a dataset of 408 orientation tuning curves of neurons recorded in macaque primary visual cortex ( Ecker et al., 2010 ). We further assume that the noise correlation between two neurons depends only on their difference in preferred direction (limited range structure) and that…
← spatial navigation research
the cue-and-structure vocabulary carried over term by term: temporal cues answering to spatial cues, temporal structure to spatial structure
Time cells are controlled by the temporal cues (the beginning and end of an episode) and the temporal structure (critical intervals) of an experience, just as place cells are controlled by the spatial cues (landmarks) and the spatial structure (shape) of the environment.
← psychophysics of time judgement
scalar timing, imported as the criterion a neural code must satisfy to count as a code for time
Importantly, the authors 18 observed that cells firing later in the delay period were active for longer durations (that is, they had larger ‘time-fields’) ( FIG. 1 ), a phenomenon that was also observed in other studies 19 , 20 (discussed below). This pattern suggests a scalar coding of time, which parallels a…
← signal detection theory
the type 1 versus type 2 distinction, which is what makes metacognition measurable separately from performance
Perceptual performance was assessed using type 1 signal detection theory (SDT; Green and Swets, 1966 ). We calculated sensitivity
← metamemory research
the object-level versus meta-level model, imported as the framework for perceptual metacognition
An influential model of metacognition postulates a dissociation between the “object” level cognition and the “meta” level, conceptualized as monitoring and controlling the object level
← evolutionary biology
the adaptation versus neutral side-product distinction, imported as the test for whether a measured feature may define a cell type
However, the same question arises here as in case of morphological details, i.e., which characteristics are relevant from a functional point of view, which are those that evolved as an adaptive property to enable the cell type to fulfil its job more efficiently, and which are those that exist simply as a side product…
← electrical engineering
the impedance profile and resonance, used to explain why particular cell classes participate in particular frequency bands
Some neuronal classes show distinct peaks (" resonances ") in their impedance profiles at characteristic frequencies, which may contribute to their differential involvement in the generation of network oscillations in various frequency bands.
← computational theories of coding
sparse representation as a design goal, imported to give feed-forward and feed-back inhibition a shared computational purpose
At the network level, both feed-forward and feed-back inhibition act to reduce the number of simultaneously active principal cells, working towards the creation of sparse representations (Acsády and Káli, 2007), which are thought to be advantageous for both sensory processing (Olshausen and Field, 2004) and long-term…
← barrel cortex sensory-motor physiology
the SST-hyperpolarisation-during-whisking result, used as evidence that the same circuit may run in another modality
Considering the similar distribution pattern of VIP neurons through the cortical areas, and the broad projection of NDB to other cortical areas, we examined whether VIP neurons in other primary sensory cortices are also modulated by locomotion.
← virology
rabies virus monosynaptic retrograde tracing, imported to find the afferents of a genetically defined cell type
Interestingly, such retrograde tracing identified the nucleus of the diagonal band of Broca (NDB), a basal forebrain nucleus enriched in cholinergic neurons, as a prominent source of input to upper layer VIP neurons in V1
← statistics
conditional inference by surrogate construction, with the null chosen to preserve every timescale but the one under test
Because the jittered data sets preserve firing rates on timescales much broader than that of the jitter interval, the overall effect of the analysis is to identify as monosynaptic those pairs that showed excess co-firing at short latencies that cannot be accounted for by firing rates varying only at timescales of tens…
← survey sampling
thinning - deleting observations at random until a nuisance variable is flat - imported as a power control
To more rigorously demonstrate position-dependent monosynaptic effects (the statistical issue is one of power; see Methods), we used a heuristic randomization argument based on thinning. For a given cell pair, we randomly and iteratively removed spikes occurring in maze segment(s) of interest until the remaining…
← rodent hippocampal electrophysiology / spatial navigation
the place-cell response profile — sparse firing from a very low baseline, sharply selective for one condition — imported as the expected shape of a human episode-selective response
The sparse neuronal responses arising from a very low baseline to robust firing during a specific episode are reminiscent of the responses of hippocampal place cells in rodents ( 26 ), in which a cell responds whenever the animal is in a particular place in the environment.
← rodent hippocampal electrophysiology
the claim that navigational machinery was conserved and repurposed, used to license reading a spatial-memory literature as a memory literature
The hippocampal and entorhinal machinery used in spatial navigation in rodents may have been preserved in humans but put to a more elaborate and abstract use
← taxonomic theory, via tyner's application of it to cellular populations
the requirement that A CLASSIFICATION OF NEURONS REQUIRES A MULTIFACETED ANALYSIS OF MORPHOLOGICAL AND PHYSIOLOGICAL FEATURES
It has long been argued that the classification of neurons requires a multifaceted analysis of morphological and physiological features ( Tyner, 1975 ). More recent efforts have emphasized the importance of combining these features with molecular markers ( Ascoli et al., 2008 ; Tremblay et al., 2016 ; Zeng and Sanes…
← cerebral cortex interneuron classification
the marker-plus-morphology-plus-physiology scheme, which THERE has ENABLED INVESTIGATIONS INTO HOW SPECIFIC CLASSES OF INTERNEURONS SHAPE CIRCUIT COMPUTATIONS, SENSORY PROCESSING, AND ANIMAL BEHAVIOR
In the cerebral cortex, a multifaceted classification scheme including molecular markers has enabled investigations into how specific classes of interneurons shape circuit computations, sensory processing, and animal behavior ( Cichon et al., 2017 ; Kato et al., 2017 ; Kato et al., 2015 ; Kuchibhotla et al., 2017…
← primate
the change-detection working-memory paradigm and the accompanying capacity models, built and tested on macaques, were imported wholesale to test an avian, non-cortical brain area
To investigate the neurophysiology of WM capacity in birds, we adopted a task design developed for monkeys ( Buschman et al., 2011 ) to use it with carrion crows ( Corvus corone ).
← monkey electrophysiology
the change-detection task, copied unchanged so that the neuronal results are directly comparable
We probed the WM capacity of crows using colored squares, based on the task design of Buschman et al., 2011 . Using the identical task allowed us to directly compare our neuronal results of WM capacity from NCL to results from PFC of monkeys. Task similarity is very important for such cross species comparisons as even…
← visual neuroscience
divisive normalization and the selectivity-against-interaction regression built to detect it
Divisive normalization is a computational principle that acts upon neurons when presenting multiple stimuli simultaneously, it normalizes neuronal responses by creating ‘a ratio between the response of an individual neuron and the summed activity of a pool of neurons
← attention research
the normalization model of attention, used to explain how the same computation can create information rather than destroy it
We wanted to understand if DNR, the mechanism that we found reduced color information at load 2, could also produce color differentiation. The ‘normalization model of attention’ ( Reynolds and Heeger, 2009 ) incorporates divisive normalization, and can explain how attention can modulate neuronal responses. By…
← psychophysics of working memory
the discrete and continuous families of capacity model, imported as the alternatives the data are held against
Discrete models’ of WM argue that a fixed number of items can be stored. Once this capacity is reached, an additional item can only be maintained if it replaces a previous item ( Awh et al., 2007 ; Fukuda et al., 2010 ; Luck and Vogel, 1997 ; Vogel and Machizawa, 2004 ; Zhang and Luck, 2008 ). ‘Continuous models’…
← animal laminar electrophysiology
the finding that feedforward and feedback information flow tends to involve different cortical layers, which is what lets the laminar data lead to hypotheses about the sequence of network interactions
The current study used a novel technique in humans that is capable of localizing transmembrane currents and multiunit activity not only to particular cortical areas, but also to different layers in those areas. Since feedforward and feedback information flow tends to involve different cortical layers ( Barbas and…
← volume conduction physics
the forward model that turns a laminar current pattern into a predicted surface potential
The local and distant ERPs and MEG produced by a cortical column can be directly estimated from its laminar CSD pattern. Specifically, in IT and PR, the initial sharp sink in layer IV combined with a source in layers II/III would be expected to produce a surface positive local field potential peaking shortly before…
← clinical epilepsy monitoring
the electrodes themselves, placed for a purpose unrelated to the question
Three patients with long-standing pharmaco-resistant complex partial seizures participated after fully informed consent according to NIH guidelines as monitored by the local Institutional Review Board. Participants were implanted with depth electrodes ( fig. 1 ) in order to localize their seizure focus and thus direct…
← macaque single-unit physiology
the sequential-then-simultaneous account of ventral stream activation, and the dispute about it
These issues have been partially addressed in macaques, where the latencies and durations of unit responses in ventral visual stream areas imply their sequential then simultaneous activation, and the delayed onset of distinctive unit responses to certain visual stimulus distinctions suggests that some processing may…
← psychophysical modelling
a fitted trial-by-trial accumulator, used as the independent variable that neural responses are plotted against
We used the behavioral model previously developed for this task 10 to obtain trial-by-trial, moment-by-moment estimates of the accumulating evidence, denoted by a(t) ( Extended Data Fig. 2 , Extended Data Table 1 ). Together with the simultaneously recorded firing rates r(t), this enabled the estimation of “tuning…
← reverse correlation
the click-triggered average, isolating one stimulus quantum's effect by subtracting the expected response for that Poisson rate
Due to the Poisson nature of the stimulus, given an underlying click-generating Poisson rate, the presence of a click at one moment in time has no bearing on the probability of a click at other times. Therefore, if one aligns the residual response to a click, it describes the change in response associated with that…
← optogenetics
halorhodopsin silencing on a random quarter of trials, used to convert an encoding claim into a timing prediction
Laser illumination occurred on a random 25% of trials. Behavioral bias was measured as the mean difference between the observed “go ipsi” rate for inactivation and control trials for each of 10 binned stimulus strengths. Thus, a positive value represents an increase in ipsilateral responses on laser illumination…
← model selection
single-parameter variants of one behavioural model compared by bootstrapped likelihood ratio
We performed statistical comparisons of the quality of the fits using a nonparametric resampling bootstrap procedure. We first generated 200 sets of trials with the same trial count as the original data by resampling the original data with replacement. We then fit each of these sets with the models described above and…
← dynamical systems and invertebrate neuroscience
the state-space trajectory view of population activity, taken explicitly from work on behavioural choice in the leech nervous system
Our results motivate consideration of a conceptual framework for decision-making and working memory in which sensory information used for the decision activates a neuronal sequence of activity. The sequence begins in a choice-independent state, which could be mediated by neurons that are not choice-specific (…
← computational models of memory
feedforward architectures and liquid state machines, offered as possible implementations
During working memory decision tasks the PPC may therefore perform computations through sequence-based circuit dynamics, rather than long-lived stable states, implemented using anatomically intermingled microcircuits.
← information theory
the MI between the spiking of a neuron and the movement condition, in or out of the response field
We studied the encoding properties of neurons’ firing rates by quantifying the MI between the spiking of a neuron S and the movement condition C (in or out of response field) M I ( C , S ) = ∑ s , c P ( c ) P ( s | c ) l o g 2 ( P ( s | c ) P ( s ) ) . To derive the marginal and conditional probabilities of spiking…
← circular statistics
the trigonometric moment of a phase histogram, which is how the temporal concentration of spiking is measured in detail
In the beta-frequency band, the peak-to-trough modulation of spike counts was 13.6%, corresponding to a modulation in firing rate by about 6.6 spikes/s ( Fig. 3 B ). Spiking was distributed symmetrically about the spike-preferred beta-phase with no significant differences in the amount of spiking between the bins…
← cross-frequency coupling analysis
PAC and N to M phase-phase locking, imported to ask how the three time scales relate
We found significant PAC between theta phases and beta amplitudes (permutation test, P < 10 −4 ) ( Fig. 4 A ). PAC for theta phases and gamma amplitudes (permutation test, P = 0.031) and beta phases and gamma amplitudes (permutation test, P < 10 −4 ) also was significant, albeit weaker (permutation tests, theta–beta…
← psychophysics
a fitted psychometric function relating the reward difference between the two shapes to the probability of choosing one
We recorded neuronal activity while monkeys performed reward-guided look-and-reach decisions. At the start of each trial, in the baseline epoch, the monkeys maintained touch and fixation on a central target. Then, in the choice epoch, they were presented with two alternatives, a circle and a triangle, and had to…
← linear systems analysis
the gain function and a high-pass cutoff predicted from a time constant, applied to spike trains
The high-pass characteristic, however, can be predicted by time constants of SFA. If onset and steady-state response curves were approximated by linear functions, the cutoff frequency f hi for transmission of AM stimuli depended only on the time constant of SFA τ and can be predicted by f hi (τ) = (2πτ) −1
← error analysis
propagation of error by partial differentiation, carried through an interpolation into the reported ratios
Propagated errors were calculated by partial differentiation for all four spike frequencies contributing to the interpolation equation.
← mathematical psychology
retrieved temporal context, brought from list-memory modelling to a prediction about single units
However, unlike short-term memory models, in retrieved temporal context models, the contiguity effect is a result of a “jump back in time.” A repeated stimulus need not cause the same input as it did when it was first presented; a repeated stimulus can recover the state of context that was available before it was…
← list-learning behavioural research
recency and contiguity as the two effects any account must produce
Episodic memory exhibits two extremely robust temporal effects in the laboratory: the recency effect and the contiguity effect. The recency effect describes the finding that more recently presented items are better remembered ( Murdock, 1962 ; Glenberg et al., 1980 ), while the contiguity effect refers to the finding…
← visual and somatosensory physiology
LFPs and magnetic fields CONSIDERED TO PARTIALLY REFLECT INPUTS to a region of tissue, IN CONTRAST TO SPIKE ACTIVITY, WHICH HAS BEEN CONSIDERED TO PREFERENTIALLY REFLECT OUTPUT to connected areas
Although our approaches revealed sites where neural activity was related to WM, it is likely that other mental processes contribute to the persistent changes in activity during the delay relative to baseline. In the spike activity, effects of other mental processes seem to be relatively small, because the spike rate…
← human neuroimaging
the sensory-recruitment hypothesis, tested here with direct electrical measurements rather than fMRI signal patterns
Our report provides evidence for the sensory-recruitment hypothesis of WM ( Sreenivasan et al., 2014 ), which posits that storage of information recruits the same neurons in sensory cortex that represent the information. This hypothesis has mainly been based on multivariate analysis of fMRI signal patterns in early…
← cognitive psychology
the definition of working memory as temporary storage for goal-directed behavior, with retrospective and prospective codes
Working memory (WM) has been defined as a cognitive process for temporary storage of task-relevant information for goal-directed behaviors ( D’Esposito, 2007 ; Sreenivasan et al., 2014 ). The information can be related to past sensory events (e.g., short-term sensory memory), or to future sensory events (e.g., sensory…
← macaque single-unit electrophysiology
the core/belt field layout, used as the template against which a human fMRI map is read and labelled
In the auditory cortex of nonhuman primates, each of the three divisions of primary “core” cortex – A1, R and RT – exhibit tonotopic gradients that are mirror symmetric to each other
← visual neuroscience
retinotopy used as the contrast case for how a receptive-field gradient behaves at an areal boundary
In contrast to the visual cortex, where retinotopic gradients reverse direction at the boundary between primary and secondary cortices, the receptive field gradients in auditory cortex run parallel to the primary/secondary (i.e., core/belt) boundary, such that the two mirror symmetric gradients observed in A1 and R…
← information theory
Shannon's mutual information is adopted as the measure of stimulus-response dependence in spike trains, chosen over conventional statistical tests because it yields a common scale across experiments
we opted to use information theory measures because they provide a uniform scale that can be used to compare results from different experiments
← information theory
mutual information with a bias correction, chosen for a uniform scale comparable across experiments
From among the many statistical methods that could be applied (ANOVA, classification techniques such as linear discriminant analysis, etc.), we opted to use information theory measures because they provide a uniform scale that can be used to compare results from different experiments, their properties and biases have…
← auditory neuroscience
artificial vowels, chosen as a more naturalistic class of stimuli than pure tones
Artificial vowels were chosen as a more “naturalistic” class of stimuli than pure tones. Artificial vowels are a simplified version of vocalization sounds used by many species of mammals and have been used in studies of the ascending auditory pathway from the auditory nerve
← psychophysics
a published discrimination threshold, used to set the formant spacing well above where rats reach plateau performance
For the training and for analysis of neuronal responses, it was crucial for the sounds to be easily distinguishable. For this reason, we ensured that the distance between formant peaks (0.585 octave) was well above the frequency difference at which rats reach plateau performance in tone discrimination
← spike sorting practice
the L-ratio and isolation index as cluster separation measures, applied on top of manual inspection
Only well-isolated single units that exhibited a clear refractory period were included in further analysis. In addition, we used two measures of spike separation, the L-ratio and the isolation index, to define the separation between the clusters in the multidimensional space
← primate systems neuroscience
the two-alternative forced choice psychophysical paradigm, brought down to rodents
Smaller mammals, rodents in particular, provide several advantages over primates for physiological experiments: faster breeding times, lower costs, smaller housing needs, and currently, easier access to molecular and genetic tools.
← psychophysics
the fitted logistic and its two parameters, boundary and slope, as the description of a subject's categorisation
We then fitted a logistic function to the psychometric performance and evaluated two parameters: the subjective category boundary and the slope of the curve.
← psychology
the concept of 'occasion setting' is imported to reinterpret the CLM motif representation as a predictive mapping onto the learned response rather than a sensory trace
In this context, which psychologists refer to as occasion setting ( Schmajuk and Holland, 1998 ), we suggest that the neural representation of motifs in CLM is less a sensory trace than a predictive mapping of the learned behavioral response.
← animal learning psychology
occasion setting - the idea that a stimulus signals which response is appropriate rather than predicting reward itself - used to reinterpret what the cortical representation is for
In this context, which psychologists refer to as occasion setting ( Schmajuk and Holland, 1998 ), we suggest that the neural representation of motifs in CLM is less a sensory trace than a predictive mapping of the learned behavioral response.
← statistics
multinomial logistic regression, chosen because stimulus identity is categorical and cannot be parameterised
Because motif identity is best regarded as a nominal, or categorical, variable (i.e. motifs cannot be easily described with a small number of parameters), we use multinomial logistic regression (MNLR) to find the optimal classifier that maximizes the predictability of motif identity from the firing rates of multiple…
← viral tracing
monosynaptic rabies tracing from genetically defined starter cells, used to ask how much local input each class receives
To address this, we assessed the extent to which VIPs, compared to SOMs, are innervated by nearby PCs, by tracing presynaptic neurons of VIPs and SOMs with rabies (see Methods). Since similar experiments have been performed in V1
← two-photon photostimulation
sequential stimulation of soma-sized volumes while recording two cells, to ask whether their inputs are shared
Since these data suggest that VIPs and SOMs do not share presynaptic partners, as a positive control we ran the same protocol on PVs. We chose PVs because they had the highest subthreshold cross-correlations in our data ( Figure S3C ), suggesting that they share many presynaptic partners
← motor control
agonist and antagonist muscle pairs, used as the argument for why two mutually inhibitory populations should not share excitatory drive
The situation is similar to motor coordination of agonist/antagonist muscle pairs where simultaneous contraction of both would not be energetically advantageous. Along this line of reasoning, it would make sense to segregate PC networks to feed only into one population of a mutually inhibitory pair of IN populations…
← ensemble physiology
co-activity of principal cells during ongoing activity, imported as the question to ask of inhibitory cells
Co-activation of neurons inevitably depends on synaptic connectivity of excitatory as well as inhibitory neurons, but while co-activity of neocortical principal cells (PCs) has been studied extensively ( Ch’ng and Reid, 2010 , Miller et al., 2014 , Bathellier et al., 2012 , Sakata and Harris, 2009 ), that of…
← attention research
the spotlight metaphor, imported as the functional interpretation of a local disinhibitory hole
VIP interneurons, themselves regulated by neuromodulators, may therefore enable selective patterns of activity to propagate through the cortex, by generating a “spotlight of attention
← dynamical systems
attractors, offered as what selectively sculpted circuits might implement
This type of local control could be use to dynamically sculpt selective cortical circuits out of a neural network type of connectivity matrix, and use them to implement specific perceptions, behaviors, memory states or, more generally, dynamical attractors.
← genetically targeted imaging
Cre-dependent expression of a calcium indicator, which is what makes the cell-type split possible at all
We used adeno-associated virus (AAV) vectors to express the calcium indicator GCaMP6s ( Chen et al., 2013 ) in auditory cortex neurons of transgenic mice containing the activity independent reporter tdTomato in GABAergic neurons ( GAD2-IRES-Cre × Rosa-LSL-tdTomato ). This allowed us to optically distinguish…
← intrinsic signal mapping
a macroscopic tonotopic map used to place the cellular imaging field inside the right area
Two to three weeks following virus injection and the implantation of a glass window over auditory cortex, we performed intrinsic signal imaging to map the precise position of A1. Responses to pure tones of three frequencies (3, 10 and 30 kHz) routinely revealed three cortical regions that displayed tonotopic…
← spike inference
deconvolution of fluorescence into an inferred rate, with the conclusions then rechecked without it
To better estimate the time course of evoked activity, we calculated inferred spike rate from changes in fluorescence using deconvolution ( Vogelstein et al., 2010 ) and we used a single frequency based on the tone that activated the most cells during TRF mapping of each field.
← psychophysics
a psychometric threshold for tone detection, used as the readout of a cortical silencing experiment
Cortical photoinactivation shifted the psychometric curve to the right (n = 5 mice, Figures 5C and 5D ) indicating an increase in threshold (63% success rate) for sound detection (LED on : 51.9 ± 4.0 dB; LED off : 40.7 ± 2.6 dB; p = 0.03).
← information theory
Shannon's mutual information, defined over a set of stimuli and a set of responses, is imported as the direct measure of what a spike train tells an observer about the sound
We thus used Shannon information [ I ( S ; R ); Eq. 1 ] to directly quantify the information carried by temporal spike patterns sampled at different temporal precision.
← information theory
Shannon mutual information estimated directly, chosen because it bounds all the information a response could carry rather than what a particular decoder can extract
Shannon information measures the reduction of uncertainty about the stimulus gained by observing a single trial response (averaged over all stimuli and responses) and was computed from many (average 55) repeats of the same stimulus sequence by using the direct method
← visual neurophysiology
the finding that response precision scales with stimulus speed, imported as the prediction that the auditory answer should depend on stimulus dynamics
Our results reveal a dependency of neural response precision on the prominent stimulus time scales: The average PSTH-derived response precision ( Figs. 1 D and 2 D ) was finer, and the information loss with decreasing response precision ( Figs. 1 E and 2 E ) was larger, for the chord stimulus, which had a much shorter…
← systems identification and state-space modelling
the linear dynamical system, used to turn simultaneous recordings into a weight matrix between identified cells
To address these questions, we fit the data to a linear dynamical system (LDS) model which predicted the activity of each cell based on two main components: (1) a weighted contribution of inputs from all other simultaneously recorded cells on the previous time step (the recurrent input), and (2) a contribution from a…
← signal detection theory
d-prime style normalisation - the selectivity index is a response difference divided by the pooled standard deviation
We quantified the selectivity of each cell as the selectivity index (SI) which was the difference between the mean response (0-1 s) to the vertical and angled grating divided by the pooled standard deviation.
← immunohistochemistry
post-hoc staining registered to the in vivo imaging plane, so that functional records acquire a molecular label
To measure the overlap of labelling by transgenic mouse lines and immunostaining, we performed immunostaining on PV, SOM, and VIP transgenic mice (2 mice each) expressing tdTomato in the respective interneuron class, and determined the percentage of overlap between immunostaining and transgenic marker expression…
← slice electrophysiology
loose-patch recording with simultaneous imaging, imported purely to calibrate the indicator against spikes
To test that the increased preference for task-relevant stimuli was not a result of nonlinearities in the relationship between a neuron’s firing rate and calcium concentration, we performed loose-patch recordings of spiking activity while simultaneously imaging GCaMP6 calcium fluorescence in from the three interneuron…
← bayesian statistics
the MAP rule, which supplies the decision boundaries instead of their being assumed
This MAP criterion results in the segregation of representational space into distinct regions separated by sharp decision boundaries (importantly, the placement of these boundaries does not constitute an additional hypothesis of the model, but derives directly from the hypothesis that decisions are based on a MAP…
← signal detection theory
likelihood distributions and a decision rule, moved from one axis into a multi-dimensional space
Indeed, although SDT is not limited to a single dimension, it is often depicted as a binary problem with two Gaussian distributions plotted along a single axis. We argue that this classic diagram fails to capture the interaction between multiple features, classes and tasks, whereas a two-dimensional depiction fulfils…
← quantum mechanics
non-commuting projections, offered as a way to model why the order of two questions changes the answers
Busemeyer et al. [ 69 ] have proposed accounting for the latter phenomenon with a computational principle inspired from quantum mechanics, according to which each successive judgement alters the input vector by projecting it onto a subspace defined by the task. As projections are not commutative, the order of…
← categorical perception research
within-category compression and between-category separation as the definition to be met
According to Harnad's definition [ 53 ], categorical perception is defined by ‘within-category compression and between-category separation’. In a companion paper in preparation, we will present additional evidence that the conscious experience of our morphs follows Harnad's definition of categorical perception [ 53 ]…
← invasive animal neurophysiology
the multi-compartment pyramidal neuron morphology used to generate the human macroscale dipole was taken from cat visual cortex modelling and then adjusted to human anatomy
The morphology of the pyramidal neurons was modelled based on cat visual cortex pyramidal neurons (Bush and Sejnowski 1993 ), and adjusted in accordance with anatomical findings in the human brain
← somatosensory neuroscience
the whole cortical column model and its exogenous input sequence, originally built for primary somatosensory cortex, were imported to interpret auditory evoked fields
Although the cortical column modelled in HNN was originally generated to account for the anatomy and behavior of primary somatosensory cortex (Jones et al. 2007 , 2009 ), it is based on canonical features shared between different neocortical circuits and hence can be applied to interpret signals in other cortical areas
← somatosensory neuroscience
the cortical column modelled in HNN, originally generated to account for the anatomy and behavior of primary somatosensory cortex, applied to interpret signals in other cortical areas
Although the cortical column modelled in HNN was originally generated to account for the anatomy and behavior of primary somatosensory cortex (Jones et al. 2007 , 2009 ), it is based on canonical features shared between different neocortical circuits and hence can be applied to interpret signals in other cortical…
← animal laminar electrophysiology
the feedforward and feedback pathway anatomy that fixes most of the model's parameters
It is important to note that, since HNN is a large-scale model with thousands of differential equations and parameters, we cannot claim that any given waveform has a unique way in which to model it. With large numbers of parameters, many of which interact and trade off, HNN is primarily a hypothesis testing tool as it…
← cat visual cortex
the original canonical circuit description, and the pyramidal cell morphology
An early description of a fundamental anatomical circuit of sensory processing was based on cat visual cortex (Gilbert 1983 ; Gilbert and Wiesel 1989 ) and states that excitatory cells in layer IV of the neocortex receive thalamic inputs and project to superficial layers, which in turn project to deeper layers. This…
← 1950s auditory psychophysics
the two rival explanations of contralateral dominance, used here as the parameters to adjust
One explanation for contralateral dominance is that, while auditory processing is not as lateralized as, for example, somatosensory processing, those pathways between ear and cortex which cross over nevertheless appear dominant, with greater numbers of fibers and faster transmission speeds (Rosenzweig 1951 ; Kimura…
← econometrics / time-series causality analysis
The Granger-causality framework for time series is taken over, as event related causality built on multivariate autoregressive models, to estimate the direction and timing of neural propagation between cortical recording sites.
we evaluated changes in the propagation of high gamma activity using a recently developed technique – event related causality (ERC), based on the concept of Granger causality, to measure the timing, magnitude and directionality of task-related changes in neural propagation across cortical networks activated during…
← bayesian statistics
The predictive coding account the paper adopts treats the cortex itself as a hierarchical generative Bayesian statistical model, with top-down predictions and bottom-up prediction error.
In this model, the cortex is considered a form of hierarchical generative Bayesian statistical model.
← spatial navigation research
Muller's random-foraging strategy of clamping behavior and randomising an irrelevant variable, reused with speed in place of direction
In 1987, Muller and colleagues introduced the “random foraging” task, in which rats search continuously in all directions and locations to find food scattered throughout their environment ( Muller et al., 1987 ). Their aim was to “clamp” behavior (as foraging) and vary direction randomly to determine whether a spatial…
← statistical modelling
nested-model deviance testing, used to ask what each covariate class adds rather than whether a fit is good
To simultaneously and quantitatively examine the extent to which each neuron was influenced by location, time, and distance, we fit the spiking of each neuron to a generalized linear model (GLM) that included treadmill time, treadmill distance, spatial position (x and y room coordinates), treadmill speed, and spike…
← memory theory
the requirement that episodic memory be temporally organised, which is what makes a time-based template worth looking for
However, other neurons, and many of the same neurons that were active on the treadmill, had place fields elsewhere on the maze (see Movie S1 and Figure S3 ), indicating that during other components of the task, where locations on the maze were important to task success, space was a strong influence over firing…
← exercise physiology apparatus
a commercial treadmill, set into a maze specifically to hold place constant while motion continues
During treadmill running, the rats’ heads were consistently facing forward, and 75% of the time spent on the treadmill could be accounted for by an area with a radius of approximately 3.3 cm (average area: 35 cm 2 ; standard deviation: 15.9 cm 2 ; range: 12 to 59 cm 2 ). This indicates that the location of the rats’…
← human neuropsychology
the single-patient dissociation in D.F., which grounded the How account of the whole dorsal stream
Later, a patient with agnosia (D.F.), who has a large bilateral lesion of the occipitotemporal cortex and a small left-sided lesion of the occipitoparietal cortex ( FIG. 1b ) 4 , 5 , was found to have impaired perception of objects but intact ability to reach to objects, including shaping her grasping hand to reflect…
← resting-state fmri
functional connectivity in humans, used to corroborate a circuit established by tract tracing in monkeys
Strong correlations were also observed between time courses of fMRI responses in regions that constitute the parieto–medial temporal pathway — that is, the IPL, PCC and RSC — and the parahippocampal cortex ( FIG. 3 ; see REF. 53 for similar results in monkey and see REF. 54 for related results in human connectivity).
← machine learning
a linear support vector classifier with cross-validation and searchlight feature selection, used to ask whether a region distinguishes stimuli rather than whether it activates more
The purpose of feature selection is to reduce the set of features (in this case, voxels) in a dataset to those most likely to carry relevant information. This is effectively the same as removing voxels most likely to carry noise and is a way of increasing the signal-to-noise ratio.
← psychoacoustics
the repeated-noise paradigm, in which a silently recurring random exemplar reveals template learning through improved repetition detection
However, without this being mentioned to subjects, there was in fact a third type of trials: one particular exemplar of repeated noise was presented over several trials, randomly interspersed throughout an experimental block. These trials (reference repeated noise, RefRN) were thus initially drawn from the same…
← visual working memory research
multivoxel pattern analysis of the delay period, imported to ask whether auditory delay activity is content-specific
Using standard univariate (GLM) analysis, no difference in activity during the maintenance period was found for retention of a low versus a high tone. We used MVPA to test whether patterns of activity during the maintenance period could distinguish between low and high tones.
← attention research
the retro-cue, whose protective effect is used to explain why two studies of the same question disagree
Behavioral studies ( Matsukura et al., 2007 ; Pertzov et al., 2013 ) show that, without any cue, items maintained in memory tend to be forgotten rapidly, but a selective retro-cue leads to protection of the cued item from temporal decay during the maintenance period. It is also known that maintaining multiple items…
← somatosensory cortex and the neuropathic pain literature
the same circuit account and its causal test - IN THE SOMATOSENSORY CORTEX, INCREASED VIP ACTIVITY FACILITATES INCREASED PN ACTIVITY IN A MOUSE MODEL OF NEUROPATHIC PAIN
Similarly, our proposed role of VIPs as the enablers of A1 plasticity after NIHL is consistent with previous reports showing that VIPs enable cortical plasticity across the sensory cortices 68 , 77 , 80 , 81 , 83 – 85 . In the visual cortex, synaptic transmission from VIPs to SOMs is necessary and sufficient for the…
← network dynamics theory
the INHIBITION-STABILIZED NETWORK (ISN) REGIME, which the model is placed in by THE ASSUMPTION THAT CORTICAL INHIBITION IS NEEDED TO PREVENT PATHOLOGIC ACTIVITY
The computational model assumes that after NIHL, the network must balance recovery and stabilization. The assumption that cortical inhibition is needed to prevent pathologic activity places the model in the inhibition-stabilized network (ISN) regime
← artificial neural network / connectionist modelling
Hinton plots, a display invented for showing the weights of hidden units in neural networks, are repurposed to compare relative word frequencies across four species' literatures
panels. A more direct method for comparing terms across species is to plot the relative frequency of each term using Hinton plots, which were developed for visualizing weights of hidden units in neural networks ( Hinton and Shallice, 1991 ).
← computational text mining / corpus linguistics
an R text-mining library is used on paper abstracts to build word-by-count matrices, turning neuroanatomical nomenclature into a corpus-statistics problem
species-specific words (monkey, rat, mouse, etc.). The remaining text was then processed in R using the text-mining library (‘tm’) to create matrices of words
← bibliometrics
word-frequency meta-analysis over ten thousand abstracts per species, used to measure a vocabulary rather than to review a field
This approach revealed that anatomic terms were the most diverse, with 22 terms needed to account for all four species. By contrast, disease-related terms were least diverse, with just 12 terms needed to account for the ten most common terms across species.
← survey methodology
a crowdsourced questionnaire with confidence ratings, applied to practitioners' own terminology
We recently conducted a crowdsourcing effort to assess usage of anatomic terms for the rodent prefrontal cortex. We reached out directly via email to several leading human, monkey, and rodent PFC researchers and also requested via social media for anyone with an informed opinion on rodent PFC to fill out a survey on…
← comparative morphology
curvature measurement of the corpus callosum, used to derive a cross-species mapping of names
By measuring the curvature of the primate callosum and applying it to points in space representing the three main parts of the rodent medial PFC, we found that the three rodent areas rotate to the locations associated with the three major functional zones of the primate ACC: the subgenual region (sACC), the pregenual…
← primate anatomy
the tripartite cingulate scheme, offered as the target vocabulary for the rodent areas
By measuring the curvature of the primate callosum and applying it to points in space representing the three main parts of the rodent medial PFC, we found that the three rodent areas rotate to the locations associated with the three major functional zones of the primate ACC: the subgenual region (sACC), the pregenual…
← information theory
the data-processing intuition that any step can only add distortion, imported as the thing to be explained away
Any signal processing can only induce distortion ( Cover and Thomas, 1991 ). In particular, the propagation of spikes via synaptic transmission can only add noise in the form of lost spikes, added background activity, or spike time jitter, requiring a neuronal mechanism to minimize and compensate for added noise.
← systems identification
a spike distance metric that involves convolving spike trains with kernels of gradually increasing temporal support, which does not depend on any reconstruction filter
One approach is to analyze spike trains from the perspective of a downstream target. Here, we operationally defined temporal coding as a reliability profile that peaks at a timescale shorter than the maximal tested timescale, but in fact, we placed rate/temporal coding on a continuous scale. This approach, which does…
← spike-train metrics
convolution kernels of increasing temporal support, used to place rate and temporal coding on one continuous scale
One approach is to analyze spike trains from the perspective of a downstream target. Here, we operationally defined temporal coding as a reliability profile that peaks at a timescale shorter than the maximal tested timescale, but in fact, we placed rate/temporal coding on a continuous scale. This approach, which does…
← dendritic physiology
nonlinear summation of coincident inputs, used to explain how the receiving cell can be more precise than its drivers
We found that neuronal response properties are qualitatively different when neurons are driven directly via photocurrents, compared with synaptic inputs. The direct optogenetic activation is largely somatic, whereas excitatory synaptic activation is largely mediated via synapses on the dendrites. Dendrites of PV cells…
← mouse genetics
Cre driver lines crossed to a reporter, so that a cell's type is known before it is recorded rather than inferred after
The recent development of inhibitory-cell-type-specific transgenic mouse lines ( Taniguchi et al. 2011 ) opens a new window for in vivo identification of inhibitory neurons.
← visual cortex physiology
imaging-guided targeted recording of identified interneuron types, and the expectation that PV cells are less selective
In auditory cortex, however, functional properties of genetically identified inhibitory neurons are poorly characterized. By two-photon imaging-guided recordings, we specifically targeted 2 major types of cortical inhibitory neuron, parvalbumin (PV) and somatostatin (SOM) expressing neurons, in superficial layers of…
← guinea pig and cat auditory physiology
the tonotopic laminar organisation of the central nucleus, imported as the design principle for a human electrode array
Our intention was to insert the array 45° off the sagittal plane perpendicular to the IC surface and into the ICC to position the sites within different anatomical layers ( Geniec and Morest, 1971 ), which supposedly correspond to different frequency laminas based on animal studies
← cochlear implant engineering
pulse rates and pulse widths fixed at the point where greater total charge stopped lowering thresholds and shorter pulse widths and slower pulse rates raised them
Briefly, 250 pps was high enough to avoid noticeable rate pitch effects (i.e., increasing rates up to 2400 pps did not noticeably increase the pitch from that at 250 pps) and the lowest rate available for daily stimulation to minimize adaptive effects. These parameters also achieved the largest drop in thresholds in…
← human anatomical collections
fixed and stained midbrain sections, used as the reference against which each patient's fused scan is read
For identification of the array location within different midbrain structures, 1 mm slices of the fused images were compared with fixed human brain slices of similar dimension that were taken from the anatomical brain collection at the Department of Neuroanatomy in Hannover Medical University ( Kretschmann and…
← psychophysics
the patient scales the perceived pitch of each stimulated site on an environmental scale, selecting the environmental sound that most resembles it
Each site was electrically stimulated with a 3-s-duration pulse train at C level, and the patient was asked to scale the perceived pitch based on our environmental scale (0–5) presented in Figure 5 . The patients were instructed to select an environmental sound on our pitch scale that most resembled the pitch level of…
← visual neuroscience
contrast gain control and the normalization framework, including the expectation that it is hierarchical
In both species, however, the data suggest a hierarchy of contrast adaptation, wherein subcortical structures exhibit contrast gain control but in cortex this becomes more consistent across neurons (in ferrets) or more temporally stable (in ferrets and mice). In the visual system, a hierarchy of contrast normalization…
← systems identification
the linear-nonlinear cascade with a contrast-dependent output nonlinearity, extended with an adaptation time constant
In the CNIC, time constants were very fast (median τ CNIC = 28 ms), indicating that substantial adaptation occurred during the first chord (duration 25 ms) after each spectro-temporal contrast transition (Fig. 6b ). For many CNIC units, the inclusion of an adaptation time constant did not improve predictions over the…
← psychoacoustics
the just noticeable difference, converted into a percentage compensation by the same formula used for neuronal gain
All participants showed this increase in sensitivity ( t (7) = 5.2, p = 0.003, n = 8), as measured by the just noticeable difference (JND, the dB difference between the 25% and 75% points on a fitted psychometric curve; Fig. 1c ). The JND increased by a mean of 38.8% between low- and high-contrast conditions (a…
← signal detection theory
the neurometric model that turns simulated spike counts into a psychometric curve
The strength of perceptual contrast adaptation predicted by the model (mean predicted contrast adaptation: awake CNIC: 19.3%; anesthetized CNIC: 20.2%; MGBv: 17.9%; A1: 21.4%) closely resembled that measured in human participants performing the contrast-dependent sound level discrimination task (28.8%, n = 8…
← human psychoacoustics
the critical band, imported as the functional interpretation of an anatomical lamina, with the rat count estimated from basilar membrane length
The number of critical bands in the rat is not known, but a rough estimate can be based on two assumptions: (1) the basilar membranes of mammals are scale models of each other and critical bands cover equal distances on the basilar membrane ( Greenwood, 1990 ); and (2) one critical band is thought to cover ∼1 mm…
← auditory prosthetics
the clinical motivation - midbrain implants in trials need to know the spectral layout they are stimulating
Furthermore, understanding this spectral coding will help to further develop promising new auditory prosthetic devices that use electrodes implanted in the IC and are now in clinical trials
← multivariate statistics
principal components analysis and the Kaiser criterion, used to turn thousands of correlated frequency-electrode measurements into a small orthogonal basis in which event-to-event similarity is preserved
In this way, each component reflects a linear combination of the power in each frequency band across all recording electrodes, such that the pairwise neural similarities between events are preserved.
← connectionist modelling
a 20-neuron simulated network, used not to model the brain but to derive what each competing account would predict for the lag profile
Pattern of activations for a simulated 20-neuron neural network as a 15-item list is studied.
← signal processing
the Hilbert transform on band-passed signals, with power computed across the whole session before segmentation specifically to avoid edge artifacts
To reduce edge artifacts, we computed power at each frequency for the entire recording session before parsing the recordings into experimental events.
← psychophysics / behavioural psychoacoustics
The two-alternative forced-choice detection procedure and threshold-shift logic of human masking experiments is carried over to single-unit spike counts as a neurometric, so that neural thresholds can be compared directly with psychometric ones.
We presented our stimuli and analyzed our data with methods analogous to those used during behavioral detection experiments to best understand the neural responses that could underlie the perceptual phenomenon.
← human psychoacoustics
the masked-versus-unmasked threshold comparison, reproduced in the neurometric so the two can be put side by side
Our neurometric comparison used Noise-Alone-evoked firing and spontaneous firing as the backgrounds against which each threshold was determined to match perceptual measures. In psychophysical detection, listeners choose between alternatives of a masker with and without a tone, to yield a masked detection threshold. A…
← signal detection neurometrics
the encoding time window as an explicit parameter, and the requirement to choose one
Neurometric analysis requires the choosing of an appropriate encoding time window, defined as the window containing the response patterns contributing to the signal to be detected ( Panzeri et al. 2010 ). For these neurometric analyses, we employed two windows to test different aspects of masking. First, a brief…
← population coding theory
population coding, which assumes that all active neurons contribute to perception, against the lower envelope principle, which assumes that perception is driven by the most sensitive neurons
A strength and limitation of the population neurometric used in the present study is that it pools information across all cells to make a decision for or against tone detection. In general, population coding assumes that all active neurons contribute to perception, whereas the lower envelope principle assumes that…
← bat inferior colliculus physiology
the relative-timing-of-inhibition account of masking
Mechanistically, forward masking is considered to involve a combination of synaptic depression, afterhyperpolarization, and inhibition ( Brosch and Schreiner 1997 ; Wehr and Zador 2005 ). A study of forward and backward masking in the bat inferior colliculus indicates that mechanisms involving the relative timing of…
← psychophysiology
pupillometry as a continuous index of autonomic state, imported to index cortical membrane potential rather than emotion
We primarily focus on pupil diameter as a measure of state, owing to its ease of measurement, non-invasive nature, and ability to continuously and sensitively track state changes, whether or not they accompany overt walking, whisking, or other movements
← hippocampal electrophysiology
sharp-wave ripple rate as an independent state variable, used to validate the pupil rather than as the object of study
The pupil diameter exhibited a strong inverse relationship to the rate of occurrence of fast ripples ( Figs. 1c–f , S1 ), with a peak coherence of 0.78 ± 0.07 (n=6 cells from N=6 animals) at low frequencies (<0.05 Hz) and a significant coherence at all frequencies up to 1 Hz ( Figs. 1e ). Theta activity was largely…
← signal detection theory
response latency on hit trials plotted against pupil diameter, showing short latency licks and a large decrease in variability of lick latency at intermediate diameters
Plotting response latency on hit trials versus pupil diameter, for an example session, reveals that intermediate pupil diameters are associated with short latency licks and a large decrease in variability of lick latency. e, Group data demonstrating that lick latency on hit trials is shortest for intermediate pupil…
← gain modelling
responses sorted by state against responses averaged over all states, where no effect would be a diagonal of slope one
If the state changes reflected by pupil diameter had no effect, this relationship would be a diagonal line with slope of 1. Variations in pupil diameter exhibited a consistent change in the slope of this relationship, with the highest slope occurring at intermediate pupil diameters ( Fig. 5d–h ) for both ACtx and MG…
← protein engineering
somatodendritic targeting motifs from ion channel trafficking, screened as a panel and recombined into a hybrid
To reduce the excitatory effect of GtACR2, we screened a panel of somatodendritic targeting motifs to reduce the trafficking of GtACR2 to the axon and presynaptic terminals. We created a hybrid motif (Kv2.1C-linker-TlcnC) that is most effective in concentrating GtACR2 in the somatodendritic domain. Activation of…
← synaptic pharmacology
receptor antagonists and a sodium channel blocker, used to identify what the tool's side effect actually is
Activation of GtACR2 with a short light pulse (0.5–10 ms) generated inward currents in all recorded GtACR2 – neurons that were voltage clamped at the reversal potential for GABAergic inhibition (−60 mV). The onsets of these inward currents followed the onset of the blue light by 3.19 ± 0.26 ms (mean ± s.e.m., n = 25)…
← developmental physiology
the difference between the membrane potential and the reversal potential for chloride, BOTH OF WHICH CAN VARY in different neuronal types and subcellular compartments
Therefore, it is also crucial to thoroughly characterize light-gated chloride channels, as their effect depends on the difference between the membrane potential and the reversal potential for chloride, both of which can vary in different neuronal types and subcellular compartments
← microbial rhodopsin biology
the algal anion channelrhodopsins themselves, adopted for sensitivity and conductance
The widely used light-driven inward chloride pumps and outward proton pumps, such as Natronomonas pharaonis halorhodopsin (NpHR) and Halorubrum sodomense archaerhodopsin (Arch), can hyperpolarize membrane potentials, independent of the electrochemical gradients, to inhibit action potentials with millisecond precision…
← machine learning
A linear SVM classifier (via the scikit-learn python package) is imported as a population read-out model for neural activity, and justified as an operation biological neurons could plausibly implement.
A linear SVM computes a simple thresholded weighted sum of inputs, an operation that is plausibly implementable by actual biological neurons; high linear classifier performance has been suggested as an indicator that the neural representation is such that it can be easily readout by downstream neurons 62 .
← primate parietal physiology
looming responsiveness of multimodal neurons, carried into the mouse as the interpretive frame for the cue
Apart from one neuron (onset 120 ms after the texture stop tone) the others displayed onset times well before the translation stage came to rest (onset 580 ± 65 ms before texture stop tone, n = 18 neurons). This indicates that the Catch-trial responses were not due to the stop auditory tone and could potentially…
← machine learning
a linear support vector machine used as a readout model on single-trial population activity
As a complement to the ideal observer ROC analysis, we trained a linear support vector machine (SVM) classifier to decode texture graininess and texture omission from single-trial population activity, on a frame by frame basis. This simple readout model could effectively decode texture graininess and texture omission…
← associative learning theory
the paired versus unpaired contingency design, which holds the stimuli constant and varies only what they predict
place cell remapping was more pronounced in rats that primarily learned to fear the training environment (context group) compared with rats that primarily learned to fear the auditory CS (cued group), even though the stimuli (CS, US, and training box) in both tasks were the same
← adaptive systems theory
the stability-plasticity dilemma, imported as the problem the hippocampus must be solving
If it is true that place cell remapping allows the hippocampus to represent different states of a single environment, then the hippocampus must solve an intriguing stability-plasticity problem ( Grossberg, 1988 ), namely, place cells must somehow decide when the state of a given environment is stable versus when it…
← image analysis
pixelwise correlation between two rate maps as the measure of whether a representation changed
To further quantify the remapping of place cells caused by fear acquisition, we calculated two correlation indices for each place cell—one for the training ( r T ) and one for the control box ( r C )—by computing the pixel-by-pixel correlation between preconditioning and postconditioning place maps (see Materials and…
← visual cortex research
the unbiased local pooling principle, carried across modalities as a prediction that reverses because auditory cortex is columnar where mouse V1 is not
If this principle generalizes across sensory modalities, PV+ neurons in mouse auditory cortex should be well tuned for frequency, because it has tonotopically organized frequency columns.
← psychophysics of loudness coding
the monotonicity index and rate-level function decomposition, used to give intensity tuning a single number
Monotonicity index (MI) characterizes the strength of a cell's intensity tuning. We defined MI as the neuron's response at maximum intensity (90 dB) divided by its maximum response ( Sutter and Schreiner, 1995 ; de la Rocha et al., 2008 ; Watkins and Barbour, 2011 ). An MI of 1 indicates no intensity tuning; an MI…
← cochlear anatomy
a frequency model built from AN innervation by cochlear origin, imported as an external criterion against which cell positions are predicted
This model is based on the distribution of AN innervation in the CN with respect to cochlear origin, and makes no assumptions about nor imposes directionality to frequency organization throughout the volume of the nucleus.
← psychoacoustics of the outer ear
the pinna transfer function and the frequency range of spectral notches, used to explain an anatomical cell-count gradient
With the mouse ear, spectral notches are largely observed in the >20 kHz range ( Lauer et al., 2011 ), which is where our vertical cell counts are the lowest. Furthermore, the transfer function of the mouse ear shows overall gains in the 10 – 20 kHz range ( Lauer et al., 2011 ), where our cell counts are higher.
← clinical psychiatry
the tripartite positive/negative/cognitive symptom division, imported as a way of choosing which rodent assays to run
To distinguish PFC-dependent behaviors which require intact PVI signaling from those that do not, we compared PVI-selective interference with non-cell-type-selective perturbations of the same circuitry in behavioral assays that were chosen to detect alterations that map onto symptom categories (positive, negative…
← molecular microbiology
tetanus toxin light chain, used as a genetically targetable silencer of transmitter release
As Cre-recombinase is required to flip the reading frame into the correct orientation, transcription of TeLC can only occur in PVIs 26 . Once expressed, TeLC efficiently stops transmitter release by cleaving VAMP2, a protein required for synaptic vesicle docking
← pharmacology
amphetamine-induced locomotion as a behavioural proxy for subcortical dopamine tone
It is thought that both positive symptoms and increased amphetamine sensitivity are due to enhanced subcortical dopaminergic tone, which in turn correlates with and might be secondary to PFC dysfunction in schizophrenia
← dynamical systems
attractor networks, in which strong recurrent excitation and lateral inhibition produce both a stable memory state and winner-take-all competition
A class of models called attractor networks can perform these functions through strong recurrent synaptic interactions ( Wang, 2008 ). In the attractor network framework, strong synaptic connections among neurons can provide reverberatory excitation, potentially mediated by slow NMDA receptors ( Wang, 1999 ), that…
← balanced-network theory
pathway-specific excitation-inhibition balance, used here to produce discrete flow between stages without a gate
An important feature of our distributed circuit model is the pathway-specific E/I balance in the feedforward projection from selection to action cells. This E/I balance regulates a cascade of activations across functional cell types and can be characterized as discrete flow, since response preparation in action cells…
← efficient coding
the idea that adapting to context increases coding efficiency under limited resources, used as the reason adaptation should exist at all
Whereas SSA has also been found in sub-cortical structures e.g. in the auditory midbrain ( Malmierca et al., 2009 ; Zhao et al., 2011 ; Thomas et al., 2012 ) and the auditory thalamus ( Kraus et al., 1994 ; Anderson et al., 2009 ; Antunes et al., 2010 ; Bauerle et al., 2011 ), it is weak in the lemniscal areas of the…
← circuit modelling
a mutually coupled excitatory-inhibitory population model, built specifically to reconcile equal adaptation in both interneuron types with unequal effects on the excitatory cells
As a proof-of-principle that would account for our findings that PVs and SOMs exhibit similar magnitude of SSA, yet have a differential effect on SSA in putative excitatory neurons, we constructed a simplified model of mutually coupled inhibitory–excitatory neuronal populations
← human speech neuroscience
the asymmetry in integration windows between the left and right superior temporal gyrus, imported as the target a mouse circuit should explain
Human studies have shown that the left superior temporal gyrus (STG) is more capable of integrating information over a shorter timescale and plays a greater role in speech perception and phonological processing than the right [ 1 – 3 ]. On the other hand, the right STG has longer integration windows to potentially…
← statistical modelling of spike trains
the DG model, a spiking generative model that makes binarized spike trains by thresholding a latent Gaussian series with a given correlation structure
The DG model is a spiking generative model that can capture correlation structures in spiking neural data [ 46 ]. Sample (binarized) spike trains X ( t ) were generated by thresholding samples of a latent multivariate Gaussian time series V ( t ) X ( t ) = 1 iff V ( t ) > 0 with V ∼ N ( γ , Σ ) with Σ ( t , t ) = 1…
← linear dynamical systems
the first-order approximation in which positive feedback lengthens the effective time constant of a decaying population
In the first-order approximation of a system, the causal link between recurrent anatomy and time constant is based on the fact that excitatory feedback increases the time constant, therefore it provides an approximation of the dynamics by measuring how quickly the correlation in the neural activity decays over time…
← mouse vocal behaviour
syllable and intersyllabic durations, used as the yardstick the two measured time constants are compared against
Mouse vocalizations are composed of syllables (i.e., a sound unit separated from other sound units by silence [ 36 ]), which themselves contain 1 or several pitch trajectories. The duration of individual pitch trajectories within a syllable emitted by adult male mice can range from 30 to 90 ms [ 37 , 38 ]. This range…
← monkey electrophysiology
the dissociation between repetition suppression and sample-matched enhancement, imported as the template for what to look for in human hippocampus
This revealed that in the perirhinal cortex some neurons are suppressed by any picture repetition, regardless of relevance, whereas others are enhanced, but only when a picture matches the sample
← machine learning
linear discriminant analysis after principal component reduction, used to ask whether the task instruction is recoverable from a single trial
We used a statistical learning approach [ 34 ] to quantify whether the information from IFPs available in single trials was sufficient to distinguish whether it is memory maintenance (match task) or simulation of a specific future event (switch task).
← laser optics / photonics
The simple astigmatic Gaussian beam model, a solution of the paraxial Helmholtz equation from laser-beam physics, is imported to predict coupling efficiency and set the optical pathway lengths of the implantable neural device.
Like the Gaussian beam model, the SAG model is a solution of the paraxial Helmholtz equation.
← human psychoacoustics
the raised-sine envelope, imported because a listener's threshold is lower for it than for a sinusoid
The raised sine AM sound contains more spectral sidebands than SAM ( Bernstein et al., 2009 ) as does any sound with a rapid rise time.
← binaural physiology of larger mammals
CP as an index of alignment, where 0 means the ITD curves are aligned near their peaks and 0.5 near their troughs
CP is the index of the alignment: A CP of 0 indicates that the ITD curves are aligned near their peaks, while a CP of 0.5 indicates that the ITD curves are aligned near their troughs
← machine learning / text classification
a Bernoulli Naive Bayes classifier of McCallum and Nigam 1998, used to READ OUT THE SPIKE TRAINS from individual neurons and CATEGORIZE THE SOUND SHAPE
A Bernoulli Naive Bayes classifier ( McCallum and Nigam, 1998 ) is used to read out the spike trains from individual neurons to categorize the sound shape.
← psychophysics / signal detection theory
the sensitivity index d-prime, a measure of behavioural discriminability, is repurposed to normalize a spike-train distance so that neural discrimination is expressed on a behavioural scale
The distance metric was normalized by trial variances to compute a sensitivity index or discrimination index as commonly used to measure behavioral discriminability
← visual neuroscience
the functional hierarchy of successive stages with progressively larger receptive fields, carried from space into the time axis
Functional hierarchies in the visual cortices support the concept that classification of visual objects requires successive cortical stages of processing including a progressive increase in classical receptive field size. The present study is significant as it supports the idea that a similar progression exists in…
← spike-train metrics
an exponential-kernel spike distance, normalized by trial variance so that it reads as a sensitivity index
The exponential time constant, τ, determines the temporal resolution or integration time of the distance metric. For large values of τ, the signals being compared contain mostly slow fluctuations in the spike rate ( Fig. 3 E , F ). For small τ, the spike distance metric is sensitive to the precise timing of spikes. We…
← psychophysics
a D-prime of 1 corresponds to about 70% accuracy, WHICH IS TYPICALLY CONSIDERED A CRITICAL LIMIT FOR DISCRIMINATING A SIGNAL BEHAVIORALLY
Here, a D′ = 1 corresponds ∼70% accuracy, which is typically considered a critical limit for discriminating a signal behaviorally ( von Trapp et al., 2016 ).
← machine learning
a Bernoulli naive Bayes classifier reading spike trains as bit patterns, with its independence assumption declared and used deliberately
By design, the naive Bayes classifier treats responses bins from different neurons as if they are independent. This property allows the classifier to take advantage of any independent and nonredundant responses within the population to build more robust classification.
← transgenic mouse genetics
a GFP line used not as the object of study but as a check on an electrophysiological classification
Since the majority of FS interneurons are PV+ ( Kawaguchi and Kondo 2002 ) and G42 mice express the EGFP transgene in (PV+) cells, we compared the properties of GFP+ interneurons recorded from G42 mice with FS cells recorded in SW mice of the same age. We found that the intrinsic membrane properties and AP properties…
← cable theory
the expectation that a synaptic potential's time course follows the membrane time constant of the cell receiving it
At rest, the short duration EPSPs are consistent with predominantly AMPA receptor–mediated current and correlated with FS cell membrane time constants throughout development.
← somatosensory physiology
the whisking-versus-quiet suppression in barrel cortex, used as the cross-modal parallel for the same effect
Synaptic depression has also been implicated in the barrel cortex, where suppression has been observed during whisking (“engaged”) compared with quiet wakefulness (“passive”), consistent with the present findings
← synaptic physiology
short-term synaptic depression and the inverse relation between release probability and presynaptic rate, imported as the circuit explanation
Synaptic depression of the thalamocortical inputs 15 , 35 could explain how the relative enhancement of the thalamic spontaneous rate in the engaged condition might lead to suppression of the cortical evoked response, without changing the cortical spontaneous activity.
← developmental biology
the lifespan trajectory as a unit of analysis, rather than a comparison between two ages
To best conceptualize these inherent lifecourse dynamics, we have documented the distribution of 7 different markers of GABAergic inhibitory interneurons on healthy Long-Evans rats from 9 days (P9) at five time point during the rats' life until advanced maturity at 25 months (P750, equivalent to ~75 human years based…
← computational modelling
turning the measured trajectories into a simple model of inhibitory signalling over life
With this evidence, we show how understanding these trajectories of cell counts may be factored into a simple model to quantify changes in inhibitory signaling across the course of life, which may be applied as a framework for creating more advanced simulations of interneuronal implication in normal cerebral…
← multivariate pattern analysis
the cortical DM calculated for each ROI compared to the group perceptual DM, so that a high correlation indicates the representational geometry of the auditory stimuli in the ROI corresponds to the geometry of the stimuli in perceptual space
To relate neural and perceptual representations of the auditory frequencies, we compared the cortical DM calculated for each ROI to the group perceptual DM. We computed the Spearman correlation between the perceptual DM and each participant’s cortical DMs. A high correlation in these analyses would indicate that the…
← psychophysics
pairwise similarity ratings, collected outside the scanner and turned into a dissimilarity matrix
Admittedly, our approach can be substantially improved in future studies. For instance, we compared the cortical dissimilarity measures to the perceptual dissimilarity judgments tested offline and averaged over subjects. We took this approach because the task performed during the discrimination scans, which was…
← tactile texture perception
the 100 to 300 Hz range as the band where the two senses overlap, used to predict where parietal responses should stop
The co-occurrence of auditory and somatosensory signals that are highly specific in the frequency domain may build audio-tactile associations in frequency-processing circuits through an extensive history of co-activation. In this framework, the auditory responses in parietal cortex could reflect predictive coding…
← primate single-unit physiology
temporal coding of vibration frequency in somatosensory cortex, named as the mechanism that would explain the fMRI result and has not been shown
In non-human primates, neurons in primary somatosensory cortex can signal vibration frequencies above 100 Hz in their spike timing ( Harvey et al. 2013 ), but evidence for explicit frequency tuning in somatosensory cortex remains elusive. Whether auditory information is similarly carried in somatosensory cortex using…
← information theory
mutual information and its decomposition into marginal and conditional entropy, used both as the measure and as the control on it
Finally, we received further confirmation that our results stem from a developing relationship between successive time segments rather than from changes in the statistics of the firing rates by separately calculating the two components of the MI: the marginal entropy and the conditional entropy ( 31 ) Marginal entropy…
← rodent hippocampal physiology
the paradigms requiring memory for temporal order, against which this free-viewing design is explicitly contrasted
Moreover, most animal studies use paradigms in which learning takes many trials, and the animals typically are overtrained, but human memory can form following a single experience ( 1 – 4 ). Here, the neuronal changes already were seen during the second viewing, namely after only one viewing, as happens in real life…
← clinical neurology / bedside assessment of brain-damaged patients
the summed multi-test scoring logic of the Glasgow Coma Scale, imported to grade consciousness across animal species
the integration of scores across the various indicators of consciousness can be used as a graded criterion for consciousness, in a similar vein as when unresponsive, brain-damaged patients are subjected to various neurological tests and their scores are summed up to determine the overall grade on the Glasgow Coma…
← philosophy / logic of inference
abductive reasoning (inference to the best explanation) adopted as the method for choosing between competing consciousness theories
Again, this approach follows the logic of abductive reasoning, which compares hypotheses and infers the better model based on simplicity, effectiveness and the available evidence (Josephson and Josephson, 1996 ).
← clinical neurology
the Glasgow Coma Scale as the model for an integrated, graded score built from several observations rather than one test
The integration of scores on the various indicators yields an overall, graded criterion for consciousness, somewhat comparable to the Glasgow Coma Scale for unresponsive patients.
← physics
the rule that a phenomenon may be attributed to a system only where the system displays manifest properties of it, argued through magnetism in iron against plastic
As with all phenomena throughout nature, a particular phenomenon X (e.g., magnetism or frozenness) can only be claimed to occur in a system if the system exhibits manifest properties indicating that X is occurring in that system. For instance, iron but not plastic can be said to have magnetic properties because it…
← animal learning theory
goal-directed behavior as an operationalised construct, imported because volition could not be quantified
While it has not been uncommon in the past to associate consciousness with volition and voluntary decision-making (Crick and Koch, 2003 ), these latter two concepts have been difficult to test or quantify in practice, whereas goal-directed behavior (see below) is a well-defined concept that has been operationalized in…
← ethology
prolonged observation across varying circumstances, proposed as the test for machines in place of a single interrogation
The rationale is that the evidence for consciousness will optimally accumulate across the study of multiple behaviors (taxing goal-directed behavior, episodic memory, etc.), which should be maintained under varying environmental circumstances (e.g., with novelty, detours) under which stereotypical, pre-programmed…
← dynamical systems theory
a full bifurcation diagram computed for fixed connectivity, then used as the map on which learning is a trajectory
Using the bifurcation diagram derived for fixed connectivity, we study analytically the temporal evolution and the steady state of the learned recurrent architecture as a function of parameters characterizing the external inputs. Slow changing stimuli lead to PA, while fast changing stimuli lead to SA. Our network…
← synaptic physiology
homeostatic scaling, generalized so that its speed depends on how far the rate is from target
As explained in Zenke and Gerstner ( 2017 ) and Zenke et al. ( 2017 ), in order to prevent the runaway of the synaptic weights produced by Hebbian plasticity, the timescale of any compensatory mechanism should be of the same order or faster than the Hebbian timescale. For generalized homeostatic plasticity, the…
← machine learning
the supervised/unsupervised division, imported as the axis along which sequence-learning models are classified
The models investigated can be roughly divided in two categories: models with supervised and unsupervised plasticity rules. In models with supervised plasticity rules, the synapses are updated according the activity of the network and an error signal that carries information about the difference between the current…
← population modelling
the Wilson-Cowan rate description, chosen because it can be solved rather than only simulated
We use a rate model to describe the activity of populations of neurons (Wilson and Cowan, 1972 ). The connectivity in this model represents the average of the synaptic connections between populations of neurons, allowing to investigate at a mesoscopic level the learning mechanisms of PA and SA. This model has the…
← primate parietal physiology
PPC cells that encode the stimulus in a CONTRAST-DEPENDENT manner and the choice in a CONTRAST-INDEPENDENT manner, quantified by the slope of the selectivity index as a function of contrast
Interestingly, some PPC cells encoded the stimulus in a contrast-dependent manner, but also encoded the choice in a contrast-independent manner (Supplementary Fig. 5c ). We quantified the contrast-dependence of the selectivity index for each neuron by measuring its slope as a function of contrast (Supplementary Fig…
← statistical modelling
LINEAR MODELS THAT CONSIDER THE STIMULUS, TASK CONTEXT, AND LICKING TOGETHER, fitted against three simpler partial models - stimulus-only, motor-only, and stimulus plus engagement
Linear models that consider the stimulus, task context, and licking together can explain some of the variance in calcium responses. But could even simpler models be sufficient? For each cell, we trained three additional partial models: a stimulus-only model, a motor-only model, and a stimulus + engagement model that…
← signal detection theory
an ROC-based selectivity index running from minus one to one, applied to trial types rather than to a decision variable
V1 neurons were strongly stimulus-selective, with the majority (74.3% ± 5.2% of cells, Fig. 8a , top) of neurons lying within the first and third quadrants (Fig. 7g ). By contrast, the majority (66.8% ± 13.0% of cells, Fig. 8a , bottom) of PPC neurons were found in the fourth quadrant, indicating a preference for the…
← computational neuroscience
gating and gain modulation as the functions a disinhibitory motif could serve
A unique mode of inhibitory control may be provided by inhibitory neurons that specifically suppress the firing of other inhibitory neurons. Such disinhibition could lead to the selective amplification of local processing and serve the important computational functions of gating and gain modulation
← model selection statistics
Bayesian information criterion used to choose between additive, divisive and combined descriptions of a tuning-curve change
This model resulted in only marginal improvement relative to the divisive model for the inhibited group (Bayesian information criterion 34 for the combined, divisive gain and baseline shift models: −399.6, −398.3 and −354.7) and the baseline shift model for the delayed activated group (Bayesian information criterion…
← information theory
THE DATA PROCESSING INEQUALITY, used to rule out a model of cortical coding outright - THE EXTENSIVE INFORMATION MODEL ATTRIBUTES MORE INFORMATION TO THE CORTEX THAN TO THE SENSORS, AND THIS IS PROHIBITED
However, we presented theoretical arguments in favor of limited information. First, if cortical populations have extensive information then the brain would need to throw away almost all of it to explain behavioral performance. Second, since cortical populations are much larger than the sensory population but not much…
← statistical model selection
the Akaike Information Criterion, used to choose between five predictors of the same measurements - and OUR DATA WAS STRONG ENOUGH TO SIGNIFICANTLY DIFFERENTIATE BETWEEN THE MODELS
In contrast, the prediction of suboptimal decoding ( Eq. 2 ) was poorly matched to data across all areas ( Figure 7C , middle panel). The best linear combination of predictors using the regression weights above could provide a better explanation than either predictor alone, but the improvement over the parameter-free…
← behavioural attention research
the inattentional blindness paradigm of Mack and Rock, adapted so that awareness can be manipulated without trial-by-trial report
However, one drawback with the inattention paradigm is that it only includes 3 of the possible 4 combinations of visual awareness and task-relevance; i.e., the unaware, task-relevant condition, which is common in other awareness paradigms, is absent in the inattentional blindness paradigm. This missing condition, in…
← philosophy of mind
the refrigerator light illusion described by Block, used as a neural counterpart to illustrate the problem of conflating post-perceptual processing with conscious perception
To illustrate the problem of conflating neural correlates of post-perceptual processing with correlates of conscious perception, it is useful to consider “the refrigerator door problem” (a neural counterpart to the “refrigerator light illusion” described by Block, 2001 ). Imagine you have no access to the internal…
← signal detection
a liberal-criterion detection post-test, used purely as an exclusion rule on subjects rather than as a measure
Because the behavioral experiment revealed detection rates greater than zero for the 16.67 ms color stimuli in some subjects, an additional behavioral post-test was conducted after each EEG session. In this post-test, color stimuli (4-red-lines), shape stimuli (squares), and control stimuli (random arrays) were…
← mass univariate statistics
cluster mass permutation testing across electrodes and time, used to check each condition separately rather than only the interaction
Cluster mass permutation tests for each condition revealed a different pattern of effects from that of the shape-elicited P3b. In this case, color-elicited P3b amplitudes were significant for all conditions except the unaware, task-irrelevant condition. The P3b in the unaware, task-relevant condition (1.31 μV, SD =…
← visual working memory research
the delayed match-to-sample paradigm and the match enhancement/suppression indices, carried across to audition where the tasks proved far harder to train
It typically takes longer to train NHPs to learn an auditory discrimination or memory task than to learn a similar task using visual stimuli ( D'Amato and Salmon 1984 ; Fritz et al., 2005 ; Hashiya and Kojima 2001 ).
← primate field ethology
call-sequence comprehension in the wild, used as evidence that primates possess auditory memory before any laboratory task is invoked
For example, if a Campbell's monkey makes an alarm call for an eagle, Diana monkeys will also produce alarm calls signaling eagles, however, if a boom vocalization occurs before the alarm call of the Campbell monkey the Diana monkeys ignores the warning ( Zuberbuhler 2002 ). The boom vocalization changes the meaning…
← cat auditory neurophysiology
reversible cooling deactivation, and the dorsal/ventral dissociation it produced, imported as both method and expected result pattern
For example, Lomber & Malhotra (2008) dissociated the function of auditory cortical regions when they showed that inactivation of the anterior auditory field, AAF, in cats impaired auditory pattern discrimination, while lesions of area DP, a hypothesized dorsal stream region, impaired sound localization ( Lomber and…
← computational neuroscience
the firing-rate equation, used to give each network unit a membrane-like time constant
Due to the capacitance and resistance of the neural cell membrane, the membrane potential and hence the firing rate is approximately a low-pass filtered version of the synaptic current. A common simple dynamic model of neurons that captures this phenomenon is the differential equation ( Eq 7 ) known as the firing-rate…
← statistics
L1 regularisation, which here does structural work by pruning the network to 2-8 effective units
To overcome overfitting, the weights were regularized using an L1-norm (LASSO regularization).
← auditory psychophysics
the cochleagram as a standard front end, so that all compared models see the same transformed input
The models receive the input as a cochleagram, a spectrogram-like transformation of the sound waveform. The cochleagram approximates the spectral filtering performed by the auditory periphery
← machine learning
a linear Support Vector Machine, explicitly labelled a standard machine-learning technique, is imported as the decoder for single-trial neural population activity
We then used a standard machine learning technique, the linear Support Vector Machine (SVM) 30 , to train one classifier for choice and a second for modality.
← object recognition in inferotemporal cortex
tolerance, and the reading that a linear decoder working under many conditions shows a representation has been untangled
Neurons in monkey inferotemporal cortex (IT) are likewise tolerant: many neurons have a preferred stimulus identity that is stable, though modulated, across many retinal positions 29 . Indeed, our task configuration is reminiscent of that used to study object recognition – just as a given object can be viewed from two…
← machine learning
a linear support vector machine used as the decoder, and bootstrap aggregation to combine a thousand trained classifiers
We used a novel test, PAIRS, to demonstrate that task parameters and time-varying response features are distributed randomly across neurons. This configuration does not pose a problem for decoding: a linear SVM could accurately estimate the modality of the stimulus and the rat’s choice based on single-trial responses…
← theoretical neuroscience
the prediction that random mixtures let arbitrary groups of neurons be linearly combined, imported as the hypothesis to be tested rather than assumed
An alternative hypothesis is that neurons reflect random combinations of parameters, leading to neural populations in which neurons’ responses defy categorization. Theoretical work suggests a major advantage for category free populations: when parameters are distributed randomly across neurons, an arbitrary group of…
← spatial statistics
nearest-neighbor angles compared against randomly oriented vectors, turned into a clustering test for neural response profiles
We used these nearest-neighbor angles to compute a statistic indicating whether the population had an excess of small nearest-neighbor angles. We term this statistic “PAIRS”: Projection Angle Index of Response Similarity (Online Methods).
← cognitive psychology
Baddeley's four-subsystem model of working memory, imported as the framework for describing what is held and manipulated
Recent models propose four subsystems of working memory, a “central executive,” responsible for controlling and coordinating information through “slave” systems called the visual-spatial sketchpad for manipulation of visual objects, the phonological loop for verbal rehearsal, and the latest addition, an episodic…
← statistical physics
attractor dynamics, used to describe how a recurrent network holds a state
Reverberatory networks, when left unperturbed, will settle into an attractor state defined by a stereotyped pattern of activity within the network ( Hopfield, 1982 ). Attractor models may undergo spontaneous oscillations, although network instantiations have also been shown to be capable of mediating sustained…
← clinical neurology
the neglect syndrome, the signature deficit after parietal damage and the original evidence for parietal function
Perhaps the signature effect of PPC damage is the neglect syndrome, typically occurring after a lesion in the right hemisphere. Disturbances include the inability to detect an object in the contralateral (left) visual hemifield (egocentric neglect) or to perceive the left side of objects, regardless of where they…
← invasive electrophysiology
the electrode depth-penetration technique, reimplemented as cylinders driven normal to a modelled tissue surface so that fMRI voxels can be sampled along depth the way an electrode track samples laminae
We use these cylinders to probe the variation of response difference (Figure 3 E) or centroid frequency (Figure 4 E) with depth in the tissue, a hemodynamic analog to making electrode penetrations into the tissue.
← cortical surface-based fmri analysis
surface reconstruction and depth sampling, imported from cortex to a small subcortical nucleus
The success of these surface-based analysis methods will enable more detailed non-invasive explorations of the functional architecture of other subcortical human auditory structures that have complex, laminar organization.
← invasive electrophysiology
the electrode penetration itself, reimplemented as a virtual penetration through a hemodynamic volume
Thus, the notion of using tissue depth as a reference frame was proven to work fairly well, despite the patchy character of the data.
← rodent hippocampal physiology
place cells as the comparison case for selectivity, fast learning, non-topographic organisation and firing without sensory input
In addition, concept cells share many features with place cells in the rodent hippocampus (Quian Quiroga, 2012a ). Place cells increase their firing rate when the animal crosses a specific location in an environment (O’keefe & Nadel, 1978 ). They are selective, firing strongly to a particular place field, and they…
← monkey inferotemporal physiology
repetition suppression, imported as the expected shape of the response-versus-trial curve
The screening data used in the study of Pedreira and colleagues had only six presentations of the stimuli. Although a response modulation with stimulus repetition was evident, the stability of these representations over several trials could not be addressed, as it was hard to see a steady state in the response…
← machine learning
the analysis of the recorded population was designed from machine-learning theory about how learning principles operate in neuronal circuits
Motivated by recent theoretical advances in understanding how machine learning principles play out in the functioning of neuronal circuits
← machine learning
the coding strategy of support vector machines is used as the interpretive frame for what mixed selectivity is doing
This analysis revealed that the observed mixed selectivity can be naturally understood as a signature of the information encoding strategy of state-of-the-art classifiers like support vector machines
← machine learning
the perceptron learning rule is imported as the supervised procedure by which a readout neuron's weights would be adjusted
just as it allows them to implement arbitrary binary classifications by modifying the weights of a readout neuron (using, for instance, a supervised procedure like the perceptron learning rule [ 23 ]).
← machine learning
the kernel-machine insight that projecting into a high-dimensional space lets a linear classifier implement more functions, imported as the interpretation of PFC tuning
Moreover, mixed selectivity offers a significant computational advantage over specialized responses in terms of the repertoire of input-output functions implementable by readout neurons. This advantage originates from the highly diverse non-linear selectivity to mixtures of task-relevant variables, a signature of…
← statistical learning theory
counting implementable dichotomies as a measure of representational capacity, used here as the dimensionality estimator
Our method relies on the observation that the number of binary classifications that can be implemented by a linear classifier grows exponentially with the number of dimensions of the neural representations of the patterns of activities to be classified ( Supplementary Methods M.1 ). Hence dimensionality can be…
← premotor cortex physiology
the observation that firing rates are less variable on faster-reaction-time trials, used as the analogy for variability driving the error-trial collapse
A theoretical argument ( Supplementary Section S.18 ) shows that neurons with a strong non-linear mixed selectivity are more sensitive than pure selectivity neurons to the task irrelevant sources of variability. Non-linear mixed selectivity is most useful but also most fragile.
← meta-analysis of published coordinates
activation likelihood estimation against a null of random spatial association, used here to characterise each cluster rather than to test a hypothesis
This was computed by creating activation likelihood estimation (ALE) maps for each of the clusters, which compared the ALE scores to a null‐distribution reflecting random spatial associations between experiments with a fixed within‐experiment distribution of foci, yielding a P ‐value based on the proportion of equal…
← database curation
behavioral domain, paradigm class and subject population coded alongside the stereotactic coordinates of every archived study
BrainMap archives functional neuroimaging studies by coding statistically significant results, in the form of stereotactic coordinates, with associated meta‐data such as behavioral domain, paradigm class, and subject population
← unsupervised machine learning
clustering that separates the voxels in the ROI into k clusters by minimizing the variance within clusters and maximizing the variance between clusters
K ‐means clustering is a non‐hierarchical clustering method that uses an iterative algorithm to separate the voxels in the ROI into k non‐overlapping clusters [Forgy, 1965 ; Hartigan and Wong, 1979 ], by minimizing the variance within clusters and maximizing the variance between clusters. To do this, the algorithm…
← rodent neuroanatomy
the dorsal to ventral axis and its hot and cold processing division, mapped onto the human posterior to anterior axis
Furthermore, they speculated that the ventral (anterior in humans) portion was more engaged in limbic processes (i.e., “hot” processing), and the dorsal (posterior in humans) was preferentially activated during tasks such as spatial navigation, or learned associations (i.e., “cold” processes).
← statistics and machine learning
the EM algorithm for mixtures of Gaussians, modified so that uninformative dimensions are disenfranchised rather than weighted
To solve this problem, we designed a novel method, the “masked EM algorithm” 30 . This algorithm fits the data as a mixture of Gaussians, but with each feature vector replaced by a virtual ensemble in which features with masks near zero are replaced by a noise distribution (see Methods). Channels with low mask values…
← image processing
the flood fill, used to grow a spike as a connected component in space and time
Specifically, spikes are detected as spatiotemporally connected components, in which the filtered signal exceeds a “weak threshold” θ w for every point, and in which at least one point exceeds a “strong threshold”
← cluster validation
the Fowlkes-Mallows index, used here to score agreement between two human operators rather than between two clusterings
We separately assessed consistency on spikes that all operators had identified be in “good” clusters, on spikes that at least one operator had identified to be in a good cluster, and on all remaining spikes. Similarity was assessed with the Fowlkes-Mallows index 31 , which gives a score between 1 for complete…
← connectomics
the precedent that automatic methods in data-intensive science run under human supervision
A similar situation arises in many fields of data-intensive science: in electron microscopic connectomics, for example, automatic methods can only be used under the supervision of human operators
← transgenic mouse engineering
a bacterial artificial chromosome reporter line used to make an uncountable population countable
There are no antibodies to the 5HT3a receptor available, precluding the use of IHC to determine the size of the 5HT3aR-expressing interneuron population and estimate its contribution to the total interneuron family. The availability of a GFP mouse line that reliably reports the presence of 5HT3a receptors allowed us…
← developmental fate mapping
derivation from different areas during development, offered as a feature arguing for a true delineation between two marker-defined Martinotti subtypes
Another feature arguing for a true delineation between SOM+/CR− and SOM+/CR+ Martinotti cells is evidence suggesting that they are derived from different areas during development, with the SOM+/CR+ population mainly arising from the dorsal Nkx6-2-positive region of the MGE
← human event-related potential research
the entire oddball paradigm and the deviant-minus-standard subtraction logic, carried into rodent local field potentials with the polarity requirement dropped
MMN is quantified by arithmetically subtracting ERPs to the standard tone from ERPs to the deviant tone.
← human erp research
the MMN-then-P3a sequence, imported as the prediction the animal data would have to match if the hippocampal response were merely downstream
This would be analogous to a MMN-P3a sequence in humans that is only observable in full (i.e., also including P3a) when deviant tones of high magnitude attract involuntary switches of attention [1] , [4] .
← philosophy
Bergson's philosophical account of time perception is imported as the interpretive model for why duration is never coded on its own but always alongside another stimulus attribute
These non-independent processes for the coding of time in the working brain support Henri Bergson’s theory about the perception of time (Bergson, 1889).
← clinical lesion neurology
the tripartite classification of acalculia, carried forward as the frame in which imaging results are read
Observed acalculia was thus classified in three main categories ( Berger, 1926 ; Hécaen et al., 1961 ; Hécaen and Angelergues, 1961 ): (1) “primary acalculia” (“anarithmethia”), the disturbance of core math functions, resulting from lesions of the left parietal areas; (2) secondary acalculia, determined by language…
← the reading literature
neuronal recycling - an area engaged for one purpose being progressively taken over for arithmetic during education
Unlike for the IPS, the right PSPL is not considered to be specific to quantity-based processing, but to mechanisms of visuo-spatial attention, which might be progressively engaged or “recycled” in these tasks during arithmetic education
← intracellular physiology
cotuned excitation and inhibition, and the timing and gain differences between them, imported as the model's structure
Intracellular studies have revealed the importance of cotuned excitatory and inhibitory inputs to neurons in auditory cortex, but typical spectrotemporal receptive field models of neuronal processing cannot account for this overlapping tuning. Here, we apply a new nonlinear modeling framework to extracellular data…
← speech technology
a sentence database, used as the natural stimulus set
We recorded the responses of isolated A1 neurons to segments of continuous speech. Speech samples were taken from the Texas Instruments/Massachusetts Institute of Technology (TIMIT) database ( Garofolo 1988 ). Stimuli were sentences (3–4 s) sampled each from a different speaker and balanced across sex. The digital…
← systems identification
the linear receptive field itself, and the maximum likelihood machinery used to fit it
as the standard first-order description of the stimulus selectivity of an auditory neuron, the linear spectrotemporal receptive field (STRF) offers an intuition for how the neuron responds to complex stimuli. Sounds that most closely match the STRF (in both frequency and relative timing) will drive the strongest…
← information-theoretic feature search
spike-triggered covariance and maximally informative dimension analysis, which identify additional stimulus features that contribute to the computation underlying the neuronal response
Two main approaches have been taken to model nonlinear aspects of A1 neuron responses. One approach has been to identify additional stimulus features (in addition to the linear STRF) that contribute to the computation underlying the neuronal response, for example using spike-triggered covariance (STC; Sen et al. 2000…
← invertebrate neuroethology
corollary discharge as a framework, imported from systems where the motor copy is a single identified neuron
Notably, whereas the gain of stimulus-evoked responses in visual cortical pyramidal cells increases with locomotion 5 , 25 , perhaps to compensate for increased visual flow, auditory cortical responses to tones decreased during movement. This suppressive effect, which resembles corollary discharge signals described in…
← optogenetics
terminal stimulation used to bypass a pathway rather than to activate a region, isolating where an effect arises
Whereas acoustic stimulation activates the auditory system from the periphery to the cortex, this optogenetic approach allowed us to effectively bypass the ascending auditory pathway prior to the thalamocortical projection and to thus isolate the component of motor-related suppression that occurs within the auditory…
← single-neuron biophysics
the divisive/subtractive decomposition, carried from cable theory into claims about interneuron classes in intact cortex
One common, conceptually straightforward framework models the effects of synaptic inhibition as a linear transformation with a divisive (scaling) and a subtractive (shifting) component ( Chance and Abbott, 2000 ; Doiron et al., 2001 ; Mitchell and Silver, 2003 ; Prescott and De Koninck, 2003 ; Hao et al., 2009 ). In…
← network modelling
a minimal threshold-nonlinear network used to show that the transformation between the two is possible in principle
A simple network model shows that threshold nonlinearities can interact with network activity to transform subtractive inhibition of neurons into divisive inhibition of networks, or vice versa. Varying threshold and the strength of suppression of a model neuron could determine whether the effect of inhibition appeared…
← classical genetics
hybrid vigor, applied so that the first-generation offspring keep one transgenic allele from the C57 parent while losing the recessive traits of both
Because of genetic tools, mice are increasingly used for neuroscience experiments that were traditionally performed using rats. However, mice are smaller and “less intelligent” than rats, limiting the size of neural implants and the complexity of performed behaviors. Here, we show that these problems are exacerbated…
← clinical phenotyping
the comparison with rats, where MICE ARE SMALLER AND LESS INTELLIGENT, LIMITING THE SIZE OF NEURAL IMPLANTS AND THE COMPLEXITY OF PERFORMED BEHAVIORS
Because of genetic tools, mice are increasingly used for neuroscience experiments that were traditionally performed using rats. However, mice are smaller and “less intelligent” than rats, limiting the size of neural implants and the complexity of performed behaviors. Here, we show that these problems are exacerbated…
← animal welfare
the 3Rs argument, derived here from the behavioral result rather than asserted separately
The hybrid vigor and the enhanced behavioral capabilities may yield more trials in every experimental session, shorter learning periods, and higher accuracy in complex tasks. By increasing yield and accuracy, the usage of HYB may allow uncovering unexplored neuronal mechanisms. Enhanced behavior also has ethical…
← computational biophysics
the model prediction that somatic inward currents are balanced by outward return currents visible as positive spikes
During an action potential, the recorded waveforms depend on neuronal morphology, spike initiation site, and the relative position of the electrodes and the subcellular compartments 3 – 7 . Extracellular potentials recorded next to different compartments are expected to exhibit distinct polarities 8 – 10 . However…
← in vitro slice physiology
the backpropagation and axonal accounts of non-negative spikes, brought into the intact freely-moving brain to be tested
Taken together, the experimental findings and computational models support three hypotheses for the source of non-negative extracellular potentials during action potentials: axonal forward propagation, dendritic backpropagation, and return currents. Thus, the compartmental origin of non-negative extracellular…
← hippocampal place coding
place fields, phase precession and ripple locking, used as the functional proof that these units are real neurons
Positive phases of non-negative spikes occur in synchrony or just before wider same-unit negative spikes. Narrow positive spikes occur in isolation in the white matter. Isolated biphasic spikes are narrower than negative spikes, occurring right after spikes of verified inhibitory units. In CA1, units with dominant…
← clinical neurology
the prospect of measuring axonal conduction velocity in the intact brain, for disorders with axonal pathology
The analysis of P- and B-spikes may have direct implications for studying neural diseases. Presently, measurements of axonal propagation velocity are carried out ex vivo 49 , 64 , 87 – 89 or under anesthesia 90 . Future studies may measure axonal propagation velocity in the intact brain directly by computing time lags…
← nineteenth-century histology
Ramon y Cajal's and Lorente de No's cell descriptions, most of which were then ignored or collapsed into one name
Although the identity of the basket cell has not been questioned, the many other cell types described by Ramon y Cajal (1893) and Lorente de No (1934) have either been ignored and all non-pyramidal cells called basket cells, or non-pyramidal cells were named by the laminar location of their soma, or some other simple…
← immunocytochemistry
molecular markers as class criteria - adopted, and then shown to be insufficient on their own
With the cited evidence we hope to convince our readers that some frequently used criteria about the identity of interneurones are unsustainable. (i) Somatic location in a layer does not identify an interneurone class, as the same class may have somata in several layers and all layers contain several distinct classes…
← isocortical anatomy
the homologous cell classes, and the axo-axonic cell which was discovered there first
Most of the GABAergic cell types defined in the CA1 area have homologues in the isocortex, which is particularly apparent in the supragranular layers. For example, the somata of supragranular pyramidal cells are innervated by basket cells immunopositive for PV, or CCK, or CCK and VGLUT3 ( Kawaguchi & Kubota, 1997…
← in vivo electrophysiology
oscillation-phase firing, imported as the fourth axis of the definition rather than as a result
Probably all neurones of the cortex can be defined, recognized and compared on the comprehensive application of the following measures: (i) brain area- and cell domain-specific distribution of input and output synapses, (ii) expression of proteins involved in cell signalling, (iii) intrinsic membrane properties…
← primate prefrontal physiology
delay-period persistent firing as the expected mechanism, imported and then not found in the rodent homologue
The primate dorsolateral prefrontal cortex is functionally analogous to, but anatomically distinct from, the rodent prelimbic region of the mPFC
← machine learning
a maximum margin linear classifier with cross-validation, used to read location from distributed population rates
Given the inhomogeneous and distributed nature of the representation of spatial information among recorded mPFC units, a maximum margin linear classifier 22 was used to decode sample goal location from binned population firing rate vectors and to quantify the strength and reliability of the neural representation
← linear systems theory
the move that OPENS THE LOOP - EFFECTIVELY DESCRIBING A FEEDBACK SYSTEM AS A FEEDFORWARD SYSTEM USING AN ARITHMETIC DECOMPOSITION, which ALLOWS RECONSTRUCTING HIDDEN ELEMENTS, NAMELY THE STCs, FROM THE CCH USING NUMERICAL METHODS
The last expression has the conceptual benefit of opening the loop, effectively describing a feedback system (Fig. 2a ) as a feedforward system using an arithmetic decomposition (Fig. 2e ). Moreover, understanding that the CCH is a sum of three elements allows reconstructing hidden elements, namely the STCs, from the…
← signal processing, via the impulse-response idea
the spike transmission curve defined as an impulse response, so that THE CCH IS IDENTICAL TO THE CONVOLUTION BETWEEN THE ACH OF NEURON 1 AND THE STC
Thus, a CCH can be described as a sum of three elements: (1) the convolution between the ACH of neuron 1 and the impulse response from neuron 1 to neuron 2; (2) the convolution between the ACH of neuron 2 and the impulse response from neuron 2 to neuron 1; and (3) the cross-correlation between the background spike…
← optical engineering / fiber photonics
for a uniform planar (Lambertian) light source and a straight cleaved optical fiber having a numerical aperture, the maximum coupling efficiency of Hudson 1974
For a uniform planar (Lambertian) light source of area A s and a straight (cleaved) optical fiber of cross-sectional area A f having a numerical aperture NA in , the maximum coupling efficiency is ( Hudson 1974 )
← fiber optics
reflective losses, quantified by the Fresnel equations at each interface, and skew rays - two factors with opposing practical implications, both ignored in the standard coupling formula
Two factors, which have opposing practical implications, were ignored in the foregoing: 1 ) reflective losses; and 2 ) skew rays. Since there are inevitable differences between the RIs of the source, coupling medium, and fiber core, there is attenuation due to reflection at each interface. This is quantified by the…
← tissue optics
a 1/d scattering model fitted to power measured through a block of brain, giving a scattering coefficient per wavelength
The mean (± SE) scattering coefficients depended on wavelength and were ( Fig. 3 A , bottom left ): blue light, 7.18 ± 0.17; orange, 4.37 ± 0.15; and red, 3.44 ± 0.05. For blue light, the current value is smaller than previously reported values (10.3 for the rat brain; Aravanis et al. 2007 ). The mismatch could be…
← solid-state lighting
red laser diodes driven by similar currents, yielding light at the fiber tip that subtended a similar illuminated volume of brain tissue
The volume of the illuminated brain tissue [at an intensity of >1 mW/mm 2 , the documented threshold for stimulating channelrhodopsin2 (ChR2); Aravanis et al. 2007 ; Boyden et al. 2005 ] was ∼0.001 mm 3 , formed by a truncated cone with 180-μm height and 150-μm base diameter ( Figs. 1 B and 3 ). Red laser diodes…
← microelectromechanical systems
waveguides embedded in the probe shank, named as the route to scaling the number of sources
Because the diode-probe arrays require only electrical connections, they can be used wirelessly ( Wentz et al. 2011 ), enabling recording and stimulation experiments with, for instance, freely moving birds and/or long-term naturalistic experiments with larger animals while permitting precise, large-scale…
← control engineering
closed-loop triggering - the recorded signal decides when the stimulus happens
To demonstrate physiological closed-loop control in a freely moving animal, we used the activity of a well-isolated neuron recorded on one shank of a diode probe implanted in the CA1 pyramidal layer to trigger optical stimulation on multiple other shanks ( Fig. 7 A ). Comparison of the cross-correlation histograms…
← optogenetics
cell-type-specific activation and silencing, used here to convert a correlative question into an interventional one
Testing of these models has been hampered by the correlative nature of most in vivo studies. On the other hand, interpretation of in vitro studies is constrained because many applied drugs are not selective for specific neuron types and can affect both SPW and ripple generation mechanisms, thus limiting separation…
← control engineering
closed-loop feedback: detect the event in real time and perturb it while it is happening
In support of a critical role of pyramidal neurons, local PYR silencing terminated the ripple events. Ripple-contingent illumination in CaMKII::Arch mice for 20–50 ms resulted in localized suppression of PYR spiking and ripple power
← signal processing
spike-train coherence between spatially separated sites as the test of a common timing source
To increase the power of detecting second order relations between spike trains, we agglomerated the spikes of all PYR recorded on the same shank (median, 6 PYR; range, 1–33) into “summed PYR” activity and all INT spikes into “summed INT” (median, 2 INT; range, 1–9) and quantified the coherence between the resulting…
← nonparametric statistics
rank-order templates with permutation-based significance, used so that sequence order can be tested without assuming timing distributions
To this end, we rank ordered the spikes of all pyramidal cells and interneurons that occurred in a given event ( Fig. 4 A ), and determined the consistency of multineuronal spiking across events ( Fig. 4 B ); because induced ripples were focal (one site was illuminated at a time; Fig. 2 Ac ), this analysis was done on…
← optogenetics
direct local activation used specifically to bypass the upstream input whose contribution is in question
We tested the “local-circuit” hypothesis by comparing the probability of participation and sequential firing of CA1 neurons during theta oscillations, natural spontaneous ripple events, and “synthetic” ripples induced by local optogenetic activation of pyramidal neurons.
← the joint peristimulus time histogram, from paired-recording analysis
JOINT PERI-EVENT CANONICAL CORRELATION (jPECC) ANALYSIS, A NOVEL EXTENSION OF THE “joint Peristimulus Time Histogram” METHOD MODIFIED TO DETECT CORRELATIONS IN A “communication subspace” BETWEEN TWO POPULATIONS
Choice signals emerged with similar timing across choice-encoding regions ( Figure 4c-d ). To examine timing, we performed two analyses. First, we trained a decoder to predict the subject’s choice from recorded population activity, after first subtracting the prediction of population activity from the Vision and…
← single-neuron choice probability analysis
a version of CHOICE PROBABILITY ANALYSIS FOR TASKS WITH MANY STIMULUS CONDITIONS, CALLED COMBINED-CONDITIONS CHOICE PROBABILITY, which QUANTIFIES THE PROBABILITY THAT A NEURON'S SPIKE COUNT WILL BE GREATER ON TRIALS WITH ONE CHOICE THAN TRIALS OF ANOTHER, FOR MATCHED STIMULUS CONDITIONS
To further confirm these conclusions, we developed a version of choice probability analysis for tasks with many stimulus conditions, called “combined-conditions choice probability” ( Methods ). This statistic quantifies the probability that a neuron’s spike count will be greater on trials with one choice than trials…
← machine learning / cross-validation practice
a train-test split applied simultaneously along two axes - cells and time - to define which variance counts as signal rather than relying on a noise model
We divided the recorded neurons into two spatially segregated sets, and divided the recorded timepoints into two equal halves (training and test; Fig. 1I ). The training timepoints were used to find the dimensions in each cell set’s activity that maximally covary with each other. These dimensions are termed Shared…
← computer vision
motion energy and its principal components, used to turn a video of a face into a thousand-dimensional behavioural regressor without deciding in advance which movements matter
We extracted a 1,000-dimensional summary of the motor actions visible on the mouse’s face by applying principal component analysis to the spatial distribution of facial motion at each moment in time ( 36 ).
← multivariate statistics
reduced rank regression, used to ask how few behavioural dimensions suffice rather than how much total variance behaviour explains
This multidimensional behavior measure predicted approximately twice as much variance as the three arousal variables ( Fig. 2D-J , Movie S3 ).
← rodent hippocampal physiology
the place cell, transferred twice - literally to human virtual navigation, and metaphorically to concept coding in a cognitive multidimensional space
The invariant responses to individual persons and landmarks observed in the human MTL may be compared to the striking place fields in rodents, which appear to encode particular locations in the animal’s environment
← rodent optogenetics
reactivation of a fear memory by stimulating specific hippocampal neurons, held up as the model for a causal human approach
Since the pioneering observations of Wilder Penfield, focal electrical stimulation of MTL circuits has been shown to evoke old memories or the feeling of déjà
← visual neuroscience
retinotopy as the template for what a sensory map is and why it matters
Moreover, quantitative maps provide predictive tools to determine the optimal stimulus for a particular neuron based on its location in the tissue. Using this information investigators can 1) relate anatomical, biophysical, and pharmacological characteristics of a neuron to sensory processing based on stimulus…
← electrophysiology of cortical rhythms
the band names theta, alpha and gamma, applied to the STIMULUS as well as to the brain - the stimulus type with a modulation rate in theta band range is called a theta sound
We refer to the stimulus type with a modulation rate in theta band range (4–7 Hz) as a theta (θ) sound, the stimulus type with modulation rate in the alpha band range (8–12 Hz) as an alpha ( α ) sound, and the stimulus type with modulation rate in the gamma band range (30–45 Hz) as a gamma (γ) sound.
← information theory
mutual information between the phase series and the acoustic structure, used to separate tracking from mere entrainment
The results of the mutual information analyses demonstrate that phase patterns in the theta and gamma bands track the temporal structure of the stimuli, as quantified by the cochlear-scaled correlation. The robust phase coherence observed in the theta band for θ sounds and that in the gamma band for γ sounds is indeed…
← speech intelligibility research
cochlear-scaled entropy, turned into an index called cochlear-scaled correlation that marks the acoustic edges of the stimulus
To quantify the acoustic edges and extract the temporal structure of the stimuli, inspired by the concept of cochlear-scaled entropy [ 112 ], we created an index, cochlear-scaled correlation. We first used a Gammatone filterbank of 64 banks, ranging from 50 Hz to 22,050 Hz, to decompose the sounds and extracted the…
← the spatial study of cortical specialisation
segregation of function, carried from the spatial domain into the time domain
This design, however, builds in a hole in processing, a segregation of function between low and high processing rates—perhaps optimized for sensory sampling—by an intermediate rate, perhaps optimized for allocating attentional and memory resources and functionally inhibiting task- or stimulus-irrelevant actions…
← pharmacology
the additive-model test for drug synergy, applied to a drug and a physical exposure
To reveal potential interactions of caffeine and UMTS MP exposure in RT and oscillatory measures we focused on the exposure block and we used the additive analysis model with the following formula, as applied elsewhere 42 , 43 , 44 : Hereafter, “[Caffeine − Control] + [UMTS − Control]” and “Combined − Control” are…
← analytical chemistry
HPLC assay of saliva, used to verify that the pharmacological manipulation actually took effect
Saliva samples were taken at the beginning and the end of each recording session and caffeine concentrations were determined by high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).
← hippocampal development
the hub-cell idea - a precocious early population that scaffolds an immature network - imported and then found not to fit
Consistent with this idea, the hippocampal network contains long range projecting SST cells that are present by P5 and particularly effective in supporting immature network synchronization ( Bonifazi et al., 2009 ; Picardo et al., 2011 ). These ‘hub’ SST interneurons in the hippocampus precociously exhibit mature…
← virology
monosynaptic rabies tracing with pseudotyped glycoprotein-deleted virus, used to read first-order inputs at two ages
Because after P10 rabies glycoprotein levels from the Rosa-locus are insufficient to mediate synaptic transfer, we modified our approach to examine later developmental time points. Post-P10, the conditional Rosa-TVA reporter line ( Seidler et al., 2008 ) was used to target RV-mCh infection into SST interneurons…
← auditory cortex development
the reported opposite developmental trajectories of somatostatin and parvalbumin thalamic drive
Previous work by Sanes and colleagues has shown that LTS-SST interneurons in the L4 of gerbil auditory cortex display a developmental decrease in thalamic evoked synaptic potentials, in contrast to the developmental increase in thalamic synaptic potentials evoked in FS-PV interneurons ( Takesian et al., 2013 ). Here…
← psychiatric genetics
the interpretation - that parvalbumin defects implicated in disease may originate in an earlier somatostatin dependency
Given that developmental insults to interneurons (PV interneurons in particular) are implicated as the underlying etiology of psychiatric disease ( Karayannis et al., 2014 ; Marin, 2012 ; Owen et al., 2013 ), our results likely have particular importance. Specifically, they reveal the unanticipated development…
← auditory psychophysics and speech research
artificial vowels with formant structure, imported as a more naturalistic stimulus class than pure tones
We chose artificial vowels as a more “naturalistic” class of stimuli than pure tones.
← cognitive psychology of memory
the self-reference effect, imported as the motivating prediction that personally relevant stimuli should recruit more neurons
One virtually infallible method of enhancing memory is simply to relate the to-be-remembered information to one's self.
← rodent hippocampal electrophysiology
the sparse-coding expectation, carried across from animal MTL recordings and used to frame what a human selective response means
In animals, selective sparse coding has also been observed in recordings from the MTL ( 15 , 16 ).
← clinical neuropsychology of temporal lobe epilepsy
famous faces and names as a probe of semantic memory integrity, reused here as a graded familiarity stimulus set
Furthermore, famous faces and names have long been used to query the integrity of recent and remote semantic memory in patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) ( 3 , 6 – 11 ).
← machine learning and bayesian statistics
predictive coding and iterative error minimisation, imported as the interpretive frame for an omitted-stimulus response
Theoretically, predictive coding suggests that the brain is constantly making efforts to ‘fit’ internal models in perceiving through inferring the incoming sensory input. The discrepancies between the actual sensory data and the predicted sensory data (‘error’) are used to refine the model in an iterative process…
← network science
scale-free topology and hub nodes, imported as the circuit explanation for rhythm following
We propose that, there is scale-free topology in the cortical network, which contains hub neurons in L2/3 and many low-degree loops with different lengths in L5 (Fig. 5 ; modified from the previous study 5 ). These low-degree loops enable the neural system to follow the external input rhythm, while hub neurons can…
← primate electrophysiology of reaching and saccades
the multiplicative gain-field mechanism for coordinate transformation, imported as the account of how a rodent map becomes motor output
Such a multiplicative mechanism is exactly what is needed to translate the allocentric entorhinal representation into goal-directed movements.
← human neuropsychology
the dorsal and ventral stream distinction and the deficits of parietal patients, used to motivate PPC's spatial role
The dorsal stream, which provides the PPC with its visual input, has been described as being critical for spatial perception, enabling the representation of the locations of objects in space
← the free energy principle / active inference
the Active Inference formalism used to cast global neuronal workspace dynamics as approximate Bayesian inference, yielding testable behavioural and neural predictions
Active Inference, a corollary of the free energy principle (FEP), is a first principles approach to modelling (approximately) Bayes optimal behaviour (Friston; 2010; Friston et al, 2016, 2017a).
← developmental imaging of pre-hearing spontaneous activity
the banding pattern used as independent support for the reversal - THIS REVERSAL IS IN LINE WITH THE BANDING PATTERNS OBSERVED WITH EPIFLUORESCENT CALCIUM IMAGING IN UNANESTHETIZED MICE BEFORE AND AT HEARING ONSET
Interestingly, our data are also compatible with two earlier two-photon calcium imaging studies ( Ito et al., 2014 ; Barnstedt et al., 2015 ). Ito et al. (2014) reported gradients in the medial regions of the dorsal IC, which ran from lateral (low-frequency) to medial (high-frequency), whereas Barnstedt et al. (2015)…
← machine learning
the teaching signal and self-supervised learning, imported to describe one modality correcting another with no external feedback
The visual signal appears to serve as a teaching signal for auditory modality, resulting in self-supervised learning of sensory representations.
← motor control research
the trial-by-trial adaptation-to-induced-error paradigm, imported as the expected timescale that sensory maps were assumed not to share
However, an important difference between motor adaptation and the current example of sensory adaptation is that in the former, direct feedback can be used as teaching signal. Moreover, the motor system is expected to be highly malleable and dynamic (for instance, due to muscle fatigue), and thus, subject to adjustment.
← semiconductor device engineering
monolithic on-silicon LED fabrication technology is carried over into implantable neural probes for systems neuroscience
The monolithically integrated μLED probes described in this work are expected to bridge the gap between the technological advances in semiconductors and advanced applications in systems neuroscience.
← bioheat transfer physics
the Pennes bioheat equation, with a blood-perfusion term, is imported to simulate brain tissue heating around the probe
Heat transfer physics in the brain with consideration of the μLED heat source and dissipation due to blood perfusion is governed by Penne’s equation
← semiconductor manufacturing
monolithic integration and lithographic patterning, applied so that light sources and electrodes share one substrate
We report a scalable method to monolithically integrate microscopic light emitting diodes (μLEDs) and recording sites onto silicon neural probes for optogenetic applications in neuroscience. Each μLED and recording site has dimensions similar to a pyramidal neuron soma, providing confined emission and…
← optics
etendue, used as the argument for abandoning waveguide coupling altogether
While LEDs are available at much lower cost and in various wavelengths as compared to laser diodes, the coupling efficiency between an integrated waveguide to the Lambertian emission profile of LEDs is severely limited by the principle of etendue
← heat transfer engineering
finite-element bio-heat modelling, used to set an operating envelope before any animal was implanted
To build a conservative model, we assumed that all electrical input power is converted into heat. In addition, we only analyzed the temperature increase caused by the most distal μLED (LED1 in Figure S2A ). As illustrated in Figure S2B , the thermal energy generated at the μLED is most effectively dissipated through…
← auditory physiology
the lemniscal and non-lemniscal property bundles, used here as a diagnostic for which pathway is operating
Lemniscal neurons are tonotopically organized ( Aitkin and Webster, 1972 ; Webster et al., 1992 ; Winer and Schreiner, 2011 ), narrowly tuned to a specific single frequency, and respond to repetitive tonal stimuli with fidelity. However, non-lemniscal neurons are not tonotopically organized, but are broadly frequency…
← behavioural pharmacology
muscimol, whose effect lasts more than 1 h and whose half-life is longer than that of lidocaine, chosen so the inactivation lasts long enough for the long-lasting auditory fear training
The MS was inactivated by an injection of muscimol (an agonist of GABA A receptors). Its effect lasts more than 1 h ( Martin and Ghez, 1999 ), and the half-life time of its effect is longer than that of lidocaine ( Martin and Ghez, 1999 ). Therefore, the inactivation of the MS with muscimol lasts long enough for the…
← associative learning
the trace conditioning paradigm, chosen because the hippocampus is required for it and not for the delay version
Auditory fear conditioning includes trace fear conditioning and delay fear conditioning. Fear conditioning is an associative learning task in which subjects are presented with a neutral CS (such as a tone) paired with an aversive US (footshock). The subject quickly learns that the CS predicts the US. As the predictive…
← systems physiology
the comparison of response latencies, from which it is inferred that the auditory information sent to the hippocampus comes from the non-lemniscal pathway, not the lemniscal one
Since the A1 latency was longer and the MS latency was shorter than the CA3 and CA1 latencies, it is most likely that auditory information sent to the hippocampus comes from the non-lemniscal pathway, not the lemniscal one.
← the physiology of cortical pyramidal neurons
the firing-type names REGULAR SPIKING AND BURSTING, ORIGINALLY DESCRIBED FOR CORTICAL PYRAMIDAL NEURONS - and the review states the limit of the loan itself: ANALOGOUS BUT NOT IDENTICAL TO THOSE CLASSICALLY OBSERVED IN PYRAMIDAL NEURONS
Regular spiking and bursting firing types were originally described for cortical pyramidal neurons (Connors et al., 1982 ), and it is important to note that the firing properties of RS or bursting SOM cells are analogous but not identical to those classically observed in pyramidal neurons.
← thalamic relay physiology
the rebound-burst mechanism - REBOUND SPIKES/BURSTS ARE MEDIATED BY T-TYPE CALCIUM CHANNELS, SIMILAR TO THOSE FOUND IN THALAMIC RELAY NEURONS, and LIKE RELAY NEURONS, L5 LTS CELLS CAN FIRE IN EITHER TONIC OR BURSTING MODE
These rebound spikes/bursts are mediated by T-type calcium channels, similar to those found in thalamic relay neurons (Goldberg et al., 2004 ; Ma et al., 2006 ). Like relay neurons, L5 LTS cells can fire in either tonic or bursting mode, depending on their membrane potential.
← signal detection theory
receiver operating characteristics used to split a perceptual judgement into two processes rather than score it as one
The results of that study highlight the importance of examining the separate processes underlying perception, using methods such as ROC analysis, rather than simply treating perception as a unitary phenomenon.
← visual working memory psychophysics
the continuous colour wheel, which separates precision from capacity where an accuracy score cannot
Further support for the notion that the hippocampus is involved in supporting high-resolution binding comes from a recent study conducted by WeiWei Zhang (in preparation; Society for Neuroscience Abstracts), in which we made use of a color wheel task developed by Zhang and Luck (2008) . On each trial, individuals were…
← somatosensory and olfactory coding
first spike latency as a code for stimulus identity, imported as the property to be explained
Whether the spike latency tuning is simply relayed along sensory ascending pathways or generated by local circuits remains unclear. Here, in vivo whole-cell recordings from rat auditory cortical neurons in layer 4 revealed that the onset latency of their aggregate thalamic input exhibited nearly flat tuning for sound…
← computational modelling
the integrate-and-fire neuron fed with measured conductances, used to obtain the spikes the recording method destroyed
Due to the use of QX-314 in the intrapipette solution to improve the recording quality, we were unable to examine the bona fide spike responses of the same neuron. Nonetheless, we derived the expected spike latency by using an integrate-and-fire neuron model, feeding the model with experimentally observed excitatory…
← network simulation
a four-layer thalamocortical network with background activity, used to ask whether input latency tuning is necessary at all
We next examined whether the latency tuning of thalamic inputs was necessary for the generation of cortical spike latency tuning. As shown in Figure 7 D , although outputs of individual thalamic neurons exhibited a clear latency tuning, the aggregate input to each pyramidal neuron had a flat latency tuning. This…
← psychophysics of timing
the requirement for an internal time reference, since the organism has no access to stimulus onset
Several sources of internal time reference have been proposed, including large-scale oscillations ( Hopfield, 1995 ), local field potentials ( Eggermont, 1998 ), and population onsets ( Stecker and Middlebrooks, 2003 ; Chase and Young, 2007 ). In our modeling study, we found that for any given tone stimulus, a large…
← human event-related potential research
the mismatch negativity and its 150 to 250 ms window, imported whole into an animal preparation
Specifically, the mismatch negativity (MMN) is a neurophysiological difference waveform peaking in the 150–250 ms window after stimulus onset. The MMN refers to the difference in evoked response to the standard and deviant stimulus. Importantly, the MMN is distinct from the N100 (occurring between 50 and 150 ms post…
← auditory oddball paradigms
the many-standards control block, which is what makes the adaptation and surprise components separable
A third block’s (many-standards control block) stimuli consisted of 10 equiprobable drifting gratings of different motion directions (same structure and stimuli as the initial tuning curve session); stimuli presented in this third condition served as controls that do not elicit adaptation effects of the standard…
← calcium imaging
ROIs kept only where stimulus-evoked activity ran 1.5 standard deviations above baseline for at least 400 consecutive milliseconds on at least 25% of trials, and in the trial average
ROIs that exhibited stimulus-evoked activity (300–1,500 ms) 1.5 standard deviations above baseline (− 200 to 0 ms) mean activity for at least 400 consecutive milliseconds for at least 25% of trials, and 1.5 standard deviations above baseline mean activity for at least 400 consecutive milliseconds in the trial average…
← clinical psychiatry
the mismatch negativity as a biomarker of sensory processing deficits, which is the stated reason for wanting a cellular account
Our results may provide insight to the mechanisms underlying the dysfunction of oddball-related sensory processing deficits in psychiatric disorders. One prominent mechanistic theory in schizophrenia research revolves around the role of N-methyl D-aspartate receptor (NMDAr)-dependent parvalbumin positive (PV+)…
← network science
the hub - a region of high network interaction - imported to interpret the claustrum and lateral entorhinal area
The insular and temporal areas along the lateral aspect of the cortex formed two distinct clusters and the broad and unique intracortical connections of the claustrum and lateral entorhinal area suggest they may serve as hubs, or regions of high network interaction ( Sporns, 2010 ).
← matrix clustering / community detection
reordering nodes so that dense groups fall along the diagonal, which converts a connectivity table into a set of named subnetworks
The clustering orders nodes into modules that maximize the connectivity and arrange highly interconnected nodes such that they are clustered along the matrix diagonal, facilitating visualization of grouped regions that can be considered subnetworks.
← primate visual neurophysiology
the random-dot-motion logic of a graded two-alternative discrimination, remade for frequency using clouds of tones
We trained rats to discriminate low and high frequency “cloud-of-tones” stimuli in a two alternative choice task
← psychophysics and signal detection
the ideal observer, applied to single neurons so that cortical and striatal selectivity can be compared on one scale
These observations indicate that neurones in the striatum preserve the information available to perform the ”cloud-of-tones” task.
← virology
a retrogradely transported herpes virus carrying Cre, which turns an anatomical projection into a genetically addressable cell class
In the first strategy, we targeted ChR2 specifically to corticostriatal neurones using a Herpes Simplex Virus-1 (HSV1) engineered to express Cre recombinase 19 , 20 , 21 ( Fig. 2a ). This virus, when injected into the auditory striatum, was transported retrogradely along the axons and drove Cre expression in…
← dynamical systems theory
initial conditions, trajectories and an energetic barrier used as the description of a motivational state
Our results suggest that the aversive thirst motivational state sets a landscape of “initial conditions,” spread across many brain regions, that determine subsequent sensory stimuli–evoked brainwide neural dynamics.
← invertebrate and larval whole-brain imaging
the low dimensionality and pervasiveness of brainwide cellular activity during behavior, established in Caenorhabditis elegans and larval zebrafish
Our results comport with the low dimensionality and pervasiveness of brainwide cellular activity during behavior in both Caenorhabditis elegans ( 39 ) and larval zebrafish
← dynamical systems theory and control theory
The fast-to-slow negative feedback loop is adopted as a circuit motif because control-theoretic arguments identify it as a building block giving both sensitivity and stability.
This choice is motivated by dynamical systems and control theoretical arguments indicating that negative feedback loops from fast to slow subsystems constitute dynamical building blocks for fast and stable responses to inputs
← machine learning
Regularized Least-Square Classifiers, explicitly described as a machine learning technique, are used to quantify how much stimulus information the neural signal carries.
Regularized Least-Square Classification is a machine learning technique that estimates the linear separability between patterns according to their class.
← operant conditioning / behavioural psychology
reward-contingent shaping, applied to a spinal reflex rather than to a voluntary action
The present study explores the possibility that appropriate descending input can also be used to improve the function of the injured spinal cord.
← human rehabilitation studies
evidence that far fewer trials suffice in people, used to argue the rat protocol's intensity is not a barrier
Furthermore, human data suggest that the thousands of trials per day obtained from rats are not essential and that conditioning can be achieved with three to five sessions per week of several hundred trials each
← human cognitive psychology
the verbal-versus-spatial pattern of human sex differences, used to motivate the rodent work
For example, women tend to outperform men on tasks that involve verbal or semantic rules and memories related to personal experience, whereas men perform better on tasks that require the manipulation of complex spatial information, such as the manipulation of shapes in space
← clinical psychiatry
the sex-skewed prevalence of specific disorders, used as the applied justification for the whole review
For example, alcoholism, autism and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) are much more common in men, whereas Alzheimer's disease, social phobias, eating disorders, post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and major depression are more common in women
← industrial process engineering, via standard operating procedures
the pipeline itself - STANDARD OPERATING PROCEDURES WITH INTEGRATED ENGINEERING TOOLS, applied to make 243 mice comparable to each other
Here we scaled calcium imaging, combining standard operating procedures with integrated engineering tools to address some of the challenges of this difficult technique, to create an unprecedented survey of 59,610 neurons in mouse visual cortex, across 243 mice, using a standard and well-studied but diverse set of…
← event-related potential electrophysiology
the lateralized readiness potential, an ERP measure of covert motor preparation, rebuilt in the haemodynamic signal and renamed the lateralized BOLD response
We therefore extracted the fMRI signal profile from the left and right motor cortices, and used it to derive an index of lateralized motor activation analogous to the LRP, the lateralized bold response (LBR; Fig. 5).
← theoretical physics
the concept of a stochastic phase transition, used to describe the sudden switch of the network into the ignited conscious state
The transition to the ignited state can be described, in theoretical physics terms, as a stochastic phase transition – a sudden change in neuronal dynamics whose occurrence depends in part on stimulus characteristics and in part on spontaneous fluctuations in activity (Dehaene and Changeux, 2005; Dehaene et al…
← artificial intelligence
the blackboard architecture - a shared data structure updated by many specialised modules - taken over as the global workspace of consciousness
However, capitalizing on the earlier concept of a blackboard 22 system in artificial intelligence (a common data structure shared and updated by many specialized modules), Baars (1989) proposed an homunculus-free psychological model where the current conscious content is represented within a distinct mental space…
← information theory / algorithmic complexity
the normalized Lempel-Ziv complexity measure, originally defined for finite symbol sequences, is computed on TMS-evoked EEG spatiotemporal response maps to yield the perturbational complexity index
PCI estimates both the information content and the integration of brain activations through the computation of the normalized Lempel-Ziv complexity (Lempel & Ziv 1976) of the significant EEG spatiotemporal responses to TMS.
← linguistics
using the hierarchical structure of language (syntax and grammar) as evidence and model for how the brain organizes serial behavior, against associative-chain theories
syntax is not inherent in the words employed or in the idea to be expressed
← behavioural priming experiments
the inferential logic of behavioural priming - infer the properties of a representation from how much repeating a stimulus changes the response to it - carried into fMRI as MR adaptation
In a manner analogous to the use of behavioral measures in priming experiments, the MR adaptation technique seeks to draw inferences about the response properties of single neurons from the degree of stimulus invariance of BOLD signal adaptation (Grill-Spector et al. 1999; Kourtzi and Kanwisher 2001; Vuilleumier et…
← artificial intelligence
reinforcement learning used as a normative framework to model brain decision-making
analysis at the computational level has drawn on ideas from reinforcement
← machine learning / computer science
The temporal difference algorithm and its prediction-error signal, taken from machine learning, are used as the model of midbrain dopamine cell activity.
Furthermore, several features of DA cell activity match properties of the prediction error signal of the temporal difference (TD) algorithm for machine learning, leading to the hypothesis that DA cell activity may be providing a teaching signal within a neural analog of a TD learning system in the brain
← machine learning
the temporal difference algorithm, imported as a candidate account of what dopamine cells compute
In the temporal difference algorithm, an estimate of the expected reward at a particular time step t is derived from the difference between the prediction of all future rewards at that time step, P ( t ), and the prediction of all future rewards that was generated at the previous time step, P ( t - 1) ( Sutton, 1988…
← classical conditioning theory
the century-old requirement that some trace of the cue survive until the reward arrives, here identified with the eligibility trace
The concept that for delayed associative conditioning to occur there must be some memory or trace of the antecedent signal at the time of a subsequent reward is as old as the study of classical conditioning itself
← reinforcement learning practice
the known trade-off that high lambda with low alpha buys stable early learning, used here as an adaptive argument
A low learning rate may be considered a disadvantage. However, previous studies in machine learning have found that when λ is set high to enable learning to begin early in training, low values of α improve the stability of learning
← bayesian statistics
a Bayesian model of location inference used to predict how grip aperture compensates for coordinate-transformation uncertainty
the amount of compensation is predicted by a Bayesian model for location inference that uses eye-centered storage. information and for changes in CTU when the target INTRODUCTION When humans reach out and grasp an object, information about the object’s location arrives at different times through multiple sensory…
← network science / graph theory
applying complex-network / graph-theoretic analysis (small-world structure, motifs, global measures) to map and characterize the brain connectome
Both genome and connectome constitute complex networks
← genomics
the genome as the model for a complete, standardised structural inventory - invoked here as the comparison against which the connectome's elements are shown to be harder to define
The compilation of the genome was aided by the fact that base pairs and genes are relatively straightforward choices as basic structural elements.
← engineering signal analysis
the chirp - a linear frequency sweep - used as a stimulus to read a biological system's frequency response
In principle, part of the frequency preference of individual cells could result from slow adaptation (due to e.g., ChR2 dynamics, cellular adaptation, and/or calcium buildup). To examine this possibility we tested a subset of units with both ascending (0–40 Hz) and descending (40-0 Hz) chirps
← filter theory
low-pass filter and band-pass filter as the names for the two candidate explanations of the same band-limited discharge
Theta band-limited discharge of PYR upon PV neuron activation can occur for at least two reasons. First, at high frequencies the high density of spikes emitted by PV cells can tonically suppress their targets, whereas at lower frequencies PYR can still fire in longer windows devoid of strong PV activity, creating in…
← visual perception / visual cortical processing
The Reverse Hierarchy Theory, first formulated to describe top-down influence of higher visual cortical areas on lower ones, is taken over to explain top-down modulation of auditory processing and extended below cortex to the brainstem.
Because the top-down mechanism was originally proposed for the impact of higher-order visual cortical areas to lower-order cortical areas, the focus has been primarily on the intracortical feedback pathway.
← electrosensory neurobiology of mormyrid electric fish
The adaptive-sensory-processor / 'negative image' account of anti-Hebbian STDP in the cerebellum-like electrosensory lobe is imported as a candidate functional model for the mammalian dorsal cochlear nucleus.
The auditory system faces a similar task in that it must differentiate spectral changes in a sound introduced by the animal’s own movements from spectral changes introduced by the movement of an external sound source relative to the animal.
← electrosensory neuroscience in mormyrid fish
anti-Hebbian STDP building a negative image that cancels the sensory consequences of the animal's own movements, imported as the candidate function of the dorsal cochlear nucleus
In this way, anti-Hebbian STDP adjusts parallel fiber synaptic weights in order to sculpt a “negative image” of the neural response caused by the fish’s own movements.
← visual perception theory
the Reverse Hierarchy Theory, built for higher-to-lower visual cortical areas and extended here to corticofugal control of the brainstem
The RHT postulates that the performance of a perceptual task is first based on the highest available level of sensory representation. If the task cannot be accomplished at that level (because of poor sensory resolution), it proceeds down the representational hierarchy to obtain more detailed, lower-level cues that…
← cerebellar physiology
the parallel-fiber and climbing-fiber arrangement, used both as the structural analogy for the DCN and as the model for how auditory nerve activity might induce plasticity
Cerebellum-like structures act as adaptive sensory processors in which the signals conveyed by parallel fibers in the molecular layer predict the patterns of sensory input to the deep layers through a process of associative anti-Hebbian synaptic plasticity
← reproductive endocrinology / clinical cytology
vaginal smear staging, imported as an independent readout of hormonal state so that a behavioural manipulation can be checked against circulating estrogen
For the TAM study, vaginal cytology was obtained through daily vaginal smears (12:00 to 14:00).
← oncology pharmacology
tamoxifen, a clinical antiestrogen, repurposed as a laboratory tool for asking whether a behaviour requires estrogen receptors
Based on its antiestrogenic properties, TAM has been used as a tool to evaluate the role of estrogen in sexually dimorphic behaviors such as anxiety ( 47 ), agonistic behavior (e.g., ref. 48 ), and sexual receptivity (e.g., ref. 49 ).
biology 26 transfers
← flow cytometry
spillover compensation, carried from flow cytometry - where fluorophore emission spectra overlap - into gene signature scoring, where marker genes overlap
The simulations also revealed another limitation of the raw scores: closely related cell types tend to have correlating scores (Additional file 2: Figure S5). That is, scores may show enrichment for a cell type due to a “spillover effect” between closely related cell types. This problem mimics the spillover problem in…
← statistics
null-distribution fitting for a presence test, carried from statistical hypothesis testing to ask whether a cell type is in a mixture at all
In five of the cell types the scores from the random mixtures consistently produced 0; thus, we define those distributions as constant 0.001 (Additional file 2: Figure S7).
← linguistics
distributed word representations / the Skip-gram model, applied to protein sequences
as a distributed representation for words, has been recently established in natural language processing (NLP)
← linguistics
The Skip-gram model and the whole distributional idea that meaning is fixed by context, carried over by treating a 3-residue k-mer as a word and a protein as a sentence
The basic idea behind training such vectors is that the meaning of a word is characterized by its context, i.e. neighboring words.
← linguistics
The word-analogy demonstration (king - man + woman = queen) imported as the evidence that embedding spaces carry structure worth looking for in sequences
Interesting patterns have been observed by training word vectors using Skip-gram in natural language.
← cognitive psychology
Content-addressable memory as the original motivation for distributed representation, credited explicitly rather than assumed
Distributed representation was originally inspired by the structure of human memory, where the items are stored in a “content-addressable” fashion.
← macro-ecology
the keystone-species concept is carried from macro-ecology into microbiome research, where hub species in a network are hypothesised to play the same role
Hub species in networks are often hypothesized to serve as keystone species, a concept which has been transferred from macro-ecology into microbiome research [ 82 ].
← ecology of multicellular organisms
one whole family of microbiome definitions is built on concepts taken from the ecology of multicellular organisms rather than from microbiology
Definitions based on ecology describe the microbiome following the concepts derived from the ecology of multicellular organisms.
← statistics
model comparison by ratio of sums-of-squared-residuals, carried from linear regression into a per-sequence classifier - and deliberately stripped of the inferential guarantee it carries in its home field
The frequency-based score statistic is best thought of as a transformation that takes as input two values—the ratio of the sum-of-squared residuals, and the number of observations—and outputs a score that is a better classification statistic than the ratio of the sum-of-squared residuals alone.
← statistics
a two-component mixture model, carried from statistical modelling to represent total DNA as contaminant plus sample
Let total sample DNA (T) be a mixture of two components (T = C + S): contaminating DNA (C) present in uniform concentration across samples and true sample DNA (S) present in varying concentration across samples.
← clinical guideline development
the consensus-panel procedure itself, carried from clinical guideline development into terminology - a category settled by documented deliberation rather than by experiment
To prepare, panellists developed a discussion outline and target questions. Several delivered brief presentations that addressed background and core issues. Discussion ensued for each issue until consensus was achieved. After the meeting, individual panellists wrote sections of the summary, which were compiled by…
← bulk rna-seq analysis
parameter regularisation by pooling across similar features, carried from bulk RNA-seq differential-expression error models into single-cell normalisation
We therefore considered the possibility of constraining the model parameters through regularization, by combining information across similar genes to increase robustness and reduce sampling variation. This approach is commonly applied in learning error models for bulk RNA-seq in the context of differential expression…
← statistics
generalized linear models and Pearson residuals, carried from regression theory to serve as the normalised data values themselves rather than as a diagnostic
We utilize the Pearson residuals (response residuals divided by the expected standard deviation), effectively representing a variance-stabilizing transformation (VST), where both lowly and highly expressed genes are transformed onto a common scale.
← network science / statistical physics
applying complex-network (scale-free) analysis to the large-scale organization of cellular metabolism
has benefited from recent advances in understanding the generic properties of complex networks
← animal nutrition
dry matter intake, a livestock-nutrition unit, used to convert rodent dietary fibre loadings into a comparable human daily intake
Animal studies which use dietary fiber supplementation to manipulate colonic SCFA tend to use relatively high fiber supplementation; 5 – 20% w/w NDC in animal dry matter intake (DMI).
← the disciplines that study speciation
species taxonomy is asked to take in theory, methods and data from the disciplines that study the origin, limits and evolution of species, rather than to work from morphology alone
Nowadays, species taxonomy is confronted with the challenge to fully incorporate new theory, methods and data from disciplines that study the origin, limits and evolution of species.
← ecology
`superorganism`, an ecological and evolutionary term for a colony treated as one individual, applied to a human plus their resident microbes
Considering the characteristics of gut microbiota such as the large diversity, the stability and resilience, and the symbiotic interaction with the host, we can define the host and the microorganisms inhabiting it as a “superorganism” \ [8, 9\] which performs immune and metabolic functions
← physics
Fermi estimation, carried from physics pedagogy into quantitative cell biology and defended there as a sanity check rather than as a placeholder for measurement
Doing so, we repeat and reflect on the assumptions in previous back-of-the-envelope calculations, also known as Fermi problems. We find such estimates as effective sanity checks and a way to improve our quantitative understanding in biology.
← physiology
mass balance, carried from chemistry and physiology to audit a cell COUNT by checking the total mass those cells would have to have
It is prudent in making such estimates to approach the analysis from different angles. In that spirit, we now ask does the cumulative mass of the cells counted fall within the expected range for a reference adult?
← computer science / data science
large-scale machine learning and big-data computing infrastructure applied to genomics
large-scale machine learning systems, and a computing infrastructure that can support flexible and dynamic queries
← experimental particle physics
the data-retention practice of particle physics - discard the raw data after processing and keep only the reduced product - held up as the lesson genomics should learn as sequencing volumes outgrow storage
For RNA-seq and other ‘omics applications, genomics will benefit greatly from the lessons learned in particle physics, in which in most cases raw data are discarded almost as fast as they are generated in favor of higher level and greatly compressed summaries.
← information theory
quantifying information processing in living systems using mutual information and entropy
In 1948 Shannon asked whether we could attach a number to the amount of information we gain
← animal science
resistant-starch feeding trials in pigs, carried into human gut physiology as a model for dietary regulation of SCFA transporters
Similar observations were made in pigs, where SLC16A1 mRNA levels increased in cecal and colonic mucosa after dietary supplementation with RS compared to digestible starch (DS) ( 41). In contrast, SLC5A8 mRNA levels (encoding SMCT1) were not affected by RS or DS diet ( 41), showing a specific regulation of MCT1…
← food regulation
the Codex Alimentarius definition of dietary fibre, a food-regulation standard used here to fix what counts as the substrate
Here, we aim to provide an overview of microbial SCFAs production in the intestine and their effect on intestinal cells and the immune response. Moreover, gut microbiome changes in IBD are reviewed and how they are related to impaired intestinal SCFAs production and associate to cell metabolism and signaling pathways…
← machine learning
machine learning, proposed for decoding individualised microbiome patterns - a response to inter-individual variance being larger than the disease signal
Finally, the microbiome configuration and immune responses are both increasingly appreciated to be highly variable among human individuals, with more variances typically explained by inter-individual variation than by disease state.
← genomics
shotgun metagenomic sequencing and the wider multi-omics stack, carried from genomics into immunology to replace a genus-level instrument
In addition, many studies focusing on microbiome-immunity interaction have utilized 16S rRNA sequencing to characterize the microbiome, but this modality is limited by its genus-level and purely compositional resolution. Given that strain level resolution and functional insights are better served by shotgun…
artificial-intelligence 18 transfers
← machine learning / artificial intelligence
pattern-recognition and model-interpretation methods are imported wholesale into the working practice of pure mathematics, as an addition to the mathematician's toolkit
We propose a framework for augmenting the standard mathematician’s toolkit with powerful pattern recognition and interpretation methods from machine learning and demonstrate its value and generality by showing how it led us to two fundamental new discoveries, one in topology and another in representation theory.
← classical statistics
the gradient-based attribution method used to interpret the trained network is identified as the machine-learning counterpart of sensitivity analysis
In this work we use gradient-based techniques 40 , broadly similar to sensitivity analysis in classical statistics and sometimes referred to as saliency maps.
← machine learning
supervised regression and gradient-based attribution, imported into pure mathematics not to prove anything but to indicate where a relationship might exist
Our contribution shows how mature machine learning methodologies can be adapted and integrated into existing mathematical workflows to achieve novel results.
← machine learning
the mathematician's toolkit is augmented with pattern-recognition and attribution methods taken from machine learning, used to propose conjectures rather than to prove them
We propose a framework for augmenting the standard mathematician’s toolkit with powerful pattern recognition and interpretation methods from machine learning and demonstrate its value and generality by showing how it led us to two fundamental new discoveries, one in topology and another in representation theory.
← neuroscience
the architecture of the mammalian visual cortex, carried into network design - the CNN's local receptive fields are presented as a simulation of cells that sense only small regions of a scene
DL, a subset of ML (Fig. 2), is inspired by the information processing patterns found in the human brain. DL does not require any human-designed rules to operate; rather, it uses a large amount of data to map the given input to specific labels.
← computer vision
pre-trained representations carried from natural-image datasets into medical imaging, and the paper's own report that this particular transfer does not work
Nevertheless, although TL enhances the accuracy of several tasks in the fields of pattern recognition and computer vision, there is an essential issue related to the source data type used by the TL as compared to the target dataset. For instance, enhancing the medical image classification performance of CNN models is…
← group theory and physics
group representation theory - E(3), tensor rank, parity and spherical harmonics - carried from physics into the design of a network's internal feature space
In contrast, the method outlined in this work uses relative position vectors rather than simply distances (scalars) together with features comprised of not only scalars, but also higher-order geometric tensors. This makes internal features instead equivariant to rotation and allows for angular information to be used…
← statistical learning theory
power-law learning curves and their exponents, carried from statistical learning theory into a claim about what a symmetry does to sample complexity
The exponent of this power-law (or equivalently the slope in log-log space) determines how fast a learning algorithm learns as new data become available. Empirical results have shown that this exponent typically remains fixed across different learning algorithms for a given data set, and different methods only shift…
← educational psychometrics
SAT analogy problems - 374 of them, an instrument built to test American secondary-school pupils - collected and used as a few-shot benchmark for a language model
To test GPT-3 on another task that is somewhat unusual relative to the typical distribution of text, we collected a set of 374 “SAT analogy” problems [TLBS03].
← psycholinguistics and reading research
the Cloze task of Taylor 1953 - delete a word from a passage and ask a reader to supply it - made the pre-training objective of a transformer language model as the masked language model
BERT alleviates the previously mentioned unidirectionality constraint by using a “masked language model” (MLM) pre-training objective, inspired by the Cloze task (Taylor, 1953).
← graph theory
the matching problem - find a subset of edges sharing no vertices - is taken from graph theory and used to pair unlabelled samples in a semi-supervised learner
Their approach is inspired by _matching_, a concept from graph theory where one tries to find a subset of edges in a graph such that the edges do not share any vertices.
← game theory
a minimax two-player game between a generator and a discriminator, adapting game-theoretic adversarial competition to train generative models
This framework corresponds to a minimax two-player game
← cognitive-neuroscience
global-workspace / access-consciousness as the mechanism gating which primed information becomes reportable and modulates behaviour
← statistics / variational bayesian inference
variational Bayes / approximate posterior inference combined with neural networks (a recognition/encoder model) to learn deep generative models
fitting an approximate inference model
← computer vision
a convolutional network taking raw pixels as input, used as the function approximator for the action-value function in reinforcement learning
The model is a convolutional neural network, trained with a variant of Q-learning, whose input is raw pixels and whose output is a value function estimating future rewards.
← neuroscience
incorporating neurophysiological insights into deep neural-network architectures (e.g. the Neocognitron)
Apart from deep GMDH networks (Sec. 5.3), the Neocognitron (Fukushima, 1979, 1980, 2013a) was perhaps the first artificial NN that deserved the attribute deep, and the first to incorporate the neurophysiological insights of Sec. 5.2.
← evolutionary biology
dropout as a neural-net regularizer inspired by the evolutionary role of sex - breaking co-adaptations, analogous to genetic recombination
A motivation for dropout comes from a theory of the role of sex in evolution
← philosophy
takes the philosophical question can machines think? and replaces it with an operational, empirical test (the imitation game)
I shall replace the question by another, which is closely related to it and is expressed in relatively unambiguous words
environmental-science 16 transfers
← hydrology
downhill flow accumulation from hydrological modelling, used here as a probability that inadequately managed waste reaches the nearest water body
For 173 countries with available data, we calculated annual plastic emissions entering aquatic ecosystems using a distance-based probability function. This function estimates the proportion of inadequately managed waste to reach the nearest aquatic ecosystem based on spatially explicit waste generation and downhill…
← development economics
World Bank income classification, a development-economics instrument used as the stratifying variable for waste infrastructure
This requires plastic waste generation to be reduced by 40% in HI, 35% in UMI and LMI, and 25% in LI countries compared with the BAU trajectory. Levels of managed waste must reach 99% in HI and UMI countries, 80% in LMI countries, and 60% in LI countries. Recovery of 40% of annual global emissions by 2030 is needed
← organochlorine toxicology
the persistent-organic-pollutant framework, carried from chlorinated chemicals to fluorinated ones, including the expectation that concentrations rise with age - which fails here
For PFOS, PFOA, and PFNA, however—unlike lipophilic POPs whose serum concentrations increase with age —concentrations were quite similar among the four age groups (Tables 2–5), a finding that agrees with previous data.
← microbiology
the surface-area-to-volume argument, taken from microbial ecology to explain why the smallest particles vanish fastest
This process becomes more important as plastic particles become smaller since at decreasing particle size the surface area∶volume relationship is increased dramatically and oxidation levels are higher, enhancing their biodegradation potential.
← international environmental law
the essential-use test, carried from the Montreal Protocol's ozone regime into chemicals policy, where the question becomes which uses of a persistent substance justify themselves rather than whether the substance is harmful
However, there are specific uses that make an immediate ban of all PFAS impractical. Some specific uses of PFAS may currently be essential to health, safety or the functioning of today’s society for which alternatives so far do not exist. On the other hand, if some uses of PFAS are found to be non-essential, they…
← analytical chemistry
suspect-screening by accurate mass spectrometry, supplied here with a list of exact monoisotopic masses per use category so that a laboratory can look for substances nobody has yet measured
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are of concern because of their very high persistence and impacts on human and environmental health. Currently, many different PFAS (on the order of several thousands) are used in a wide range of applications and there is no comprehensive source of information on the many…
← regulatory toxicology
reliability scoring from regulatory toxicology - Klimisch-style criteria for judging whether a study's data may be used in hazard and risk assessment - applied to microplastic occurrence studies
Recently, Hermsen et al. proposed a weight-of-evidence scoring method for studies of microplastic ingestion by marine biota ( Hermsen et al., 2018). This method defined minimum quality criteria for various aspects of the analytical procedure, such as sampling, sample treatment, use of controls and polymer…
← hydrology
land-surface hydrology - the GLDAS/NOAH runoff model built for terrestrial water and energy budgets - carried into a plastic-transport estimate as the seasonality term
Nonetheless, it is important to notice that comparisons between river discharge predictions from GLDAS and observations in 66 basins worldwide demonstrated that predictions are somewhat dryer than observations. The authors of this validation study attributed the differences to uncertainties in precipitation rates.
← oceanography
mean particle masses and the micro-to-macro ratio measured in the open ocean, carried into rivers to convert particle counts into mass where studies reported only counts
Not all studies considered here reported micro- and macro-plastic concentrations at surface waters of rivers. As such, for our midpoint estimate, we homogenized our data set using the mean ratio micro- to macro-plastic numerical concentration from studies reporting both types (mean ratio equals to 0.04). For…
← physical oceanography
Lagrangian particle advection with wave, wind and current forcing, carried from physical oceanography into an inventory of manufactured debris
As buoyant plastics can be missed by surface trawls due to wind-driven mixing, we then estimated the ‘depth-integrated’ mass and numerical plastic concentrations (Ci) for all type/size categories at each of the trawl sampling locations using the equations described in ref.. Supplementary Methods 1 provides details on…
← disaster response and beach monitoring
a dated, located mass release - the 2011 Tohoku tsunami - used as a natural tracer experiment to constrain a transport parameter
The dependence of the particle trajectory on the windage coefficient predicted by our model is in good agreement with sightings and modelling of debris originated from the 2011 Tohoku tsunami in Japan. The first identified Japanese debris items that arrived after 10 to 12 months on the North American shores were…
← air pollution and human risk assessment
the PM2.5/PM10 convention of reporting an operationally defined mass concentration per unit volume is adopted wholesale as the way to quantify plastic in blood
One approach to quantifying plastic particles in the nascent field of plastic particle HRA is based on mass concentrations of polymers from plastic present as particles, analogous to PM10 for instance. ### 1.3.
← pharmacokinetics
first-order elimination kinetics and the half-life construct, carried from single-dose animal pharmacokinetics onto an observational human cohort with no known dose and no defined time zero
We used WinNonlin software, version 4.1 (Pharsight Corporation, Mountain View, CA) to calculate the half-life of elimination based on the mean value of the split analyses. The data were linear when plotted as the logarithm of serum concentration versus time. Therefore, we assumed a first order model.
← renal physiology
the renal transporter explanation, carried from rodent sex-difference studies to account for a between-species difference in humans
The diversity of proximal tubular organic anion transporters and potential for genetic variation have indicated that the long elimination half-life in humans compared with that in other species may be due to differential expression of organic anion transporters and could be linked to either low-level transport into…
← physical oceanography
particle-transport mechanisms carried from physical oceanography - cascading, convection, saline subduction, canyon funnelling and Taylor columns - to explain how a textile fibre reaches the abyssal floor
In addition, a number of oceanographic processes could aid in the transfer of microplastics to depth. These processes include dense shelf water cascading, severe coastal storms, offshore convection and saline subduction. All these induce vertical and horizontal transfers of large volumes of particle loaded waters…
← biological oceanography
marine snow, a biological-oceanography construct for aggregated organic debris, used as the vehicle that makes a buoyant synthetic fibre settle
Some negatively buoyant particles will sink; however, because of surface tension and oceanographic currents, most plastics are initially held at the sea surface. Colonization by organisms, adherence to phytoplankton and the aggregation with organic debris and small particles in the form of marine snow will eventually…
psychology 13 transfers
← psychology
the paper takes Bower and Forgas's theory of emotional priming — a psychological account of mood-congruent recall — and uses it as the explanatory engine for a political-communication effect
We rely on Bower and Forgas’s (2001) theory of emotional priming to argue that specific emotions from IRAs play an important role in activating racial attitudes.
← human memory research
the human occluded-picture-naming priming paradigm is converted into a classification task so it can be run on monkeys
As in priming studies in which humans were asked to name partially occluded images that they either had or had not seen previously ( Mitchell, 2006 ; Snodgrass & Feenan, 1990 ), we required monkeys to classify partially occluded photographs that they either had or had not seen previously.
← human cognitive science / experimental consciousness research on humans
They take the cross-over double-dissociation marker of nonconscious processing, developed and validated only in verbal human subjects, and transplant it into nonhuman-primate comparative research as a nonverbal test for awareness
Critically, by importing one of the strictest indicators of genuine nonconscious processing in human studies
← human cognitive science
the cross-over double dissociation of visual awareness, rebuilt as a nonverbal saccade task so that it can be run on a species that cannot be asked what it saw
Much work in human cognitive science has shown that under certain circumstances, people display opposite behavioral signatures when they are consciously aware of stimuli (i.e., when they are exposed to clearly visible stimuli—supraliminal stimuli) versus when they are not aware (i.e., when they are exposed to stimuli…
← existing fear scales
the item pool itself, taken from thirty existing fear scales built for other populations and diseases
First, an extensive literature review was conducted to assess all general scales on fear. Thirty measures on fear were identified that assess fear on different populations and diseases (available on request from the corresponding authors). Relevant and possible items were pooled by two researchers (i.e., the third and…
← psychometrics
reliability, specificity, generalizability and validity - the criteria of psychological measurement - carried into an audit of what a whole literature's vocabulary is entitled to assert
Four criteria must be met to justify a reverse inference that a particular facial configuration expresses and therefore reveals a specific emotional state: reliability, specificity, generalizability and validity (explained in Table 2 and Figure 3). These criteria are commonly encountered in the field of psychological…
← cognitive neuroscience
reverse inference, and the conditional probability that formalises it, carried from neuroimaging methodology into the reading of faces
When you see someone smile and infer that the person is happy, you are making what is known as a reverse inference: you are assuming that the smile reveals something about the person’s emotional state that you cannot access directly (see Figure 3).
← economics / decision theory
expected-utility theory, the economists' normative model of choice under risk, taken into psychology as the descriptive model to be tested and then replaced
This paper presents a critique of expected utility theory as a descriptive model of decision making under risk, and develops an alternative model, called prospect theory.
← epidemiology and public health
the disease model is adapted to gambling so that harm spreads from the person who gambles to family, friends and community, with that person as the index case rather than the source
Consistent with the public health approach and the adaption of a disease model to understand gambling, a clear theme of the contagion of harm from the individual to family and friends, and then community emerged, noting that the person who gambles is the index case and not the source.
← public health
framing gambling harm as a public health matter broadens the focus from the individual gambler to the population
This is an important broadening of focus that assists in addressing gambling related harm from a public health perspective.
← information theory
analyzing the limits of human perception and memory using information theory (channel capacity, bits)
the results are analyzed in terms of the concepts of information theory
← communication engineering
Shannon's information measure, the channel and its capacity, carried into psychology - and the paper is explicit that the experiments would not exist without it
Since these experiments would not have been done without the appearance of information theory on the psychological scene, and since the results are analyzed in terms of the concepts of information theory, I shall have to preface my discussion with a few remarks about this theory.
← statistics
A translation table offered in the other direction, so psychologists could read the information measure as the variance they already knew
The "amount of information" is exactly the same concept that we have talked about for years under the name of "variance."
social-psychology 13 transfers
← psycholinguistics / speech-production research
cascade models of language production are imported wholesale as a model for how parallel primed responses become serial social behaviour
Accordingly, recent work in our lab has begun to apply cascade models of language production (e.g., Dell, 1986 ; Morsella & Miozzo, 2002 ; Navarette & Costa, 2004 ) to these next-generation questions concerning social behavior production ( Morsella, Levine, & Bargh, 2005 ).
← cognitive linguistics and the study of language use
Lakoff and Johnson's conceptual-metaphor theory, Clark's analysis of conversational language use, and Dell's speech-production model are proposed as the solution to social psychology's own two problems
It is suggested that models of complex conceptual structures ( Lakoff & Johnson, 1980 ), language use in real-life conversational settings ( Clark, 1996 ), and speech production ( Dell, 1986 ) might hold the key for solving these two important ‘second-generation’ research problems.
← language-comprehension research
the paper traces the concept of priming itself as an import into social cognition from Lashley's analysis of language
The notion of priming originated in Karl Lashley’s (1951) analysis of language comprehension; how we need to hold some sentential information temporarily in mind in order to comprehend it.
← classic cognitive psychology and psycholinguistics
the priming method and the surrounding cluster of concepts (availability, accessibility, activation, applicability) were imported into social psychology, where their nature was altered to fit social-cognitive phenomena
Although the idea of priming per se originated within classic cognitive psychology and psycholinguistics, its nature and the set of related ideas changed when they were applied to phenomena that interested social psychologists.
← race relations research, human development and cultural psychology
the nested-levels model of influence, imported to relate individual racial bias to the systems around it
Models of nested levels of influence in the study of race relations 17 , human development 18 and culture 19 , 20 can be used to consider the relation between racial bias and broader systemic factors (Fig. 1 ).
← epidemiology
the basic reproduction number from epidemiology, applied to users who begin posting about a topic rather than to infected individuals
Furthermore, we model the spread of information with epidemic models, characterizing for each platform its basic reproduction number ( R0 ), i.e. the average number of secondary cases (users that start posting about COVID-19) an “infectious” individual (an individual already posting on COVID-19) will create. In…
← journalism fact-checking
a third-party fact-checking organisation's outlet ratings, used as the ground truth for content reliability
We tag links as reliable or questionable according to the data reported by the independent fact-checking organization Media Bias/Fact Check34. In order to clarify the limits of an approach that is based on labelling news outlets rather than single articles, as for instance performed in33,48, we report the definitions…
← a commercial general-knowledge board game
the 42-item general knowledge instrument taken wholesale from Trivial Pursuit (1984/1987) and used as the dependent measure for primed intelligent behaviour
The general knowledge task consisted of a questionnaire with 42 difficult multiple-choice questions borrowed from the game Trivial Pursuit (1984/1987).
← system-justification theory
the epistemic / existential / social motive taxonomy, carried from system-justification theory into the study of conspiracy belief
This research suggests that people may be drawn to conspiracy theories when—compared with nonconspiracy explanations—they promise to satisfy important social psychological motives that can be characterized as epistemic (e.g., the desire for understanding, accuracy, and subjective certainty), existential (e.g., the…
← philosophy of science
normative standards of causal explanation from the philosophy of science, used to characterise what conspiracy theories are
In general, empirically warranted (vs. speculative), parsimonious (vs. complex), and falsifiable explanations are stronger according to normative standards of causal explanation (e.g., in science; see). However, conspiracy theories appear to provide broad, internally consistent explanations that allow people to…
← economics
the paper claims the subject of money has been left to economists and argues that the psychological side of it explains events economics could not
For decades, economists have had the last (and often the only) word on money, and yet some of the biggest worldwide events of recent history stem from a failure to understand the psychology of money.
← cognitive psychology
priming - raising the accessibility of a concept with an unrelated task - carried from cognitive psychology into a platform-deployable intervention against misinformation
Prior to deciding which headlines they would share on social media, participants were subtly primed to think about accuracy by being asked to rate the accuracy of a single non-COVID-related news headline. This minimal, content-neutral intervention nearly tripled participants’ level of discernment between sharing true…
← behavioural economics
the nudge frame from behavioural economics: change what is salient at the moment of choice rather than what the chooser knows or is allowed to do
Such interventions are easily scalable and do not require platforms to make decision about what content to censor.
cognitive-psychology 12 transfers
← natural language processing / computational linguistics
target-level sentiment analysis (assigning a polarity label to a text-target pair), plus a purpose-built annotated Spanish headline dataset, imported into a cognitive/social neuroscience study to quantify the emotional valence attached to each candidate in the press
This problem is usually called target-level sentiment analysis, in which a polarity label is assigned to a pair (text, target), where the target is present on the text.
← industrial telegraphy and telephony
the practical demand that created the modern short-term memory task — operators holding rapid dot-dash series, then subscriber numbers — which the paper offers as the ecological source of the nonsense-syllable laboratory
The nonsense syllables that Ebbinghaus had invented as a tool can be seen to have acquired more ecological validity in an industrial age with expanding information demands, perhaps highlighting the practical importance of primary memory in daily life.
← neurophysiology
the cell assembly, imported to give short-term memory a physical criterion independent of awareness
One might relate short-term memory to a pattern of neural firing that represents a particular idea and one might consider the idea to be in short-term memory only when the firing pattern, or cell assembly, is active ( Hebb, 1949 ).
← probability theory
the independence rule for a union of two events, S+L−SL, used to split a single recall probability into contributions from two stores
This model assumes that, for any particular serial position within a list, the likelihood of successful short-term storage (S) and long-term storage (L) are independent, so that the likelihood of recalling the item is S+L−SL.
← perception research
the compound stimulus — a large digit built from small characters — borrowed so the cover task can be about the components while the pattern lives in the whole
Each number was composed of either little X ’s or of little O ’s, and participants were asked to indicate as quickly as possible, using the keyboard, whether the number they saw was composed of X ’s or O ’s (cf. Navon, 1977 ).
← implicit learning research
the finding that conscious search damages extraction of complex structure, imported as the prediction that an explicit version of the task will show no effect
One proposed explanation for these findings maintains that the conscious mind cannot apprehend complex structures of this sort, and so conscious search is bound to fail (cf. Reber, 1993 ).
← computational neuroscience / neural network modelling and single-cell neurophysiology
The gain parameter of neural network models, together with attentional gain modulation observed in primate single-cell recordings, is imported as the computational mechanism of the psychological attentional sensitization model
Gain is a parameter in neural network modeling, which influences the probability that a neuron fires at a given activation level ( Hamker, 2005 ).
← clinical trials
the argument against discarding subjects who fail an awareness check is made by analogy with a clinical trial: excluding those subjects is like removing from the analysis the patients the drug killed
Actually, the practice is analogous to eliminating all the patients from a clinical trial that have died from the drug under investigation.
← physics simulation engines
the simulation engine that renders a game world is used as the model of intuitive physics: the mind is proposed to run something like it to predict what happens next in a scene
This is directly analogous to how simulation engines can be used for intuitive physics, to predict what will happen next in a scene or to infer objects’ dynamical properties from how they move.
← neuroscience
the representations and algorithms of the connectionist approach were drawn from neuroscience rather than from cognitive psychology, and the paper marks that as the choice which shaped it
The representations and algorithms used by this approach were more directly inspired by neuroscience than by cognitive psychology, although ultimately it would flower into an influential school of thought about the nature of cognition—parallel distributed processing (PDP) (McClelland et al., 1986; Rumelhart…
← statistical machine learning
the systematicity failure is reframed using machine learning's own assumption that training and test data come from the same distribution
This can be seen as a trivial confirmation of the basic principle of statistical machine learning that your training and test data should come from the same distribution.
← physiology
the concept of unconscious cerebration, and the interest in implicit memory that followed from it, is traced to a general nineteenth-century attempt to relate physiology and psychology
Carpenter's concept of unconscious cerebration and consequent interest in implicit memory derived from a more general attempt to relate physiology and psychology.
digital-humanities 11 transfers
← data science / machine learning / computer science
the core analytic concepts of data science (objects, features, feature space, distance, dimension reduction) are imported wholesale as a framework for art-historical and humanistic study
I present a number of core concepts from data science that are relevant to digital art history and the use of quantitative methods to study any cultural artifacts or processes in general.
← data science
the term "features" is adopted into digital art history in place of the sciences' "variable", and stretched to cover existing metadata as well as computed attributes
I suggest that in digital art history we adapt the term “features” to refer to both information that can be extracted from objects through computer analysis and the already available metadata.
← probabilistic text modelling
the document-and-words structure of latent Dirichlet allocation carried over to collaborative filtering, with a user standing in for a document and the movies chosen standing in for its words
A user and the movies chosen are analogous to a document and the words in the document (respectively).
← epidemiology
the susceptible-infected-recovered epidemic model, carried from epidemiology to measure which users a message reaches and with what leaning
These results indicate that information diffusion is biased toward individuals who share a similar leaning in some social media, namely Twitter and Facebook. In contrast, in others—Reddit and Gab in our analysis—this effect is absent.
← network science
homophily and community detection, carried from network science into a test of a psychological construct
Then, we use these elements to assess echo chambers’ presence by looking at two different aspects: 1) homophily in interactions concerning a specific topic and 2) bias in information diffusion from like-minded sources.
← natural language processing
the computational apparatus of natural language processing - tokenisation, distributional similarity, network construction - applied to figurative language in a corpus of liturgical poetry
This article suggests a computational method for the analysis of figurative language as a network, using methods from natural language processing (NLP), particularly topic classification and network analysis.
← natural language processing
word embeddings (word2vec) applied across time to quantify historical semantic change
quantifying semantic change by evaluating word embeddings (PPMI, SVD, word2vec) against known historical changes
← linguistics
word-embedding vector-space models (Mikolov/Pennington), applied to measure cultural meaning (class, gender, race)
embeddings are high-dimensional vector-space models of text in which each unique word in the corpus is represented as a vector in a shared vector space
← political science
Adcock and Collier's background/systematized concept distinction and their notion of content validity, imported to discipline the conceptualization step of computational text analysis
If we want to move beyond the use of ad hoc definitions, it can be useful to distinguish between what political scientists Adcock and Collier ( 2001 ) call the “background concept” and the “systematized concept.”
← literary studies
Close reading carried into computational work not as a rival but as a validation step that informs the model
Model outputs tell us something about the texts, while a close reading of the texts alongside those outputs tells us something about the models that can be used for more effective model building.
← geography
GIS and spatial analysis carried into the reading of ancient narrative, together with an explicit statement of where the transfer breaks - the formalism cannot hold the uncertainty that makes the material interesting
More recently, the spatial analysis of texts via Geographic Information Systems (GIS) is trending as a research method.
medicine 10 transfers
← toxicology
the hormesis biphasic dose-response model, with noise dose defined by analogy to an ingested toxicant dose (sound level times duration)
Corresponding to the dose of toxicity that was ingested by organisms, the exposure dose of noise for organisms was the value of exposure sound level times exposure duration.
← statistics
principal components analysis, carried from multivariate statistics to collapse 228 repeat-length measurements into a single MSI score that can be cut into categories
To determine MSI status, 114 intronic homopolymer repeat loci with adequate coverage on the CGP panel were analyzed for length variability and compiled into an overall MSI score via principal components analysis. The 114 loci were selected from a total set of 1897 that have adequate coverage on the FMI FoundationOne…
← survey sampling
resampling simulation, carried from survey methodology to ask how small a genomic panel may be before the rate it estimates stops being the rate
We finally sought to determine the effects of sequencing different amounts of the genome and how that might affect our ability to accurately determine TMB. We sampled the number of mutations that we would expect to see at different TMB levels (100 mutations/Mb, 20 mutations/Mb, 10 mutations/Mb) and at different…
← artificial intelligence
deep convolutional networks, developed in computer vision, adopted as the methodology of choice for medical image analysis (classification, detection, segmentation)
Deep learning algorithms, in particular convolutional networks, have rapidly become a methodology of choice for analyzing medical images
← statistics
statistical meta-analysis methodology for pooling and summarizing results across studies, standardized as a transparent reporting standard for medical evidence synthesis
Statistical methods (meta-analysis) may or may not be used to analyze and summarize the results of the included studies
← economics
the 17-year translation lag is a figure produced by an economic calculation of the returns to medical research, including spillovers to the wider economy
(The remaining 30% arise from ‘spillovers’ benefiting the wider economy.) This level of benefit was calculated using an estimated lag of 17 years.
← artificial intelligence
a deep convolutional network (DenseNet) applied to detect disease from chest X-rays at radiologist level
a 121-layer convolutional neural network trained on ChestX-ray14
← artificial intelligence
convolutional networks applied to biomedical image segmentation
outperforms the prior best method (a sliding-window convolutional network) on the ISBI challenge for segmentation of neuronal structures in electron microscopic stacks.
← statistics
the randomized controlled trial methodology (randomization / experimental design from statistics) as the gold standard for evaluating medical interventions
Randomised controlled trials, when appropriately designed, conducted, and reported, represent the gold standard in evaluating healthcare interventions
← epidemiology / statistics
the epidemiological and statistical methodology of observational study designs (cohort, case-control, cross-sectional) and confounding control, standardized for transparent medical reporting
We defined the scope of the recommendations to cover three main study designs: cohort, case-control, and cross-sectional studies
materials-science 10 transfers
← quantum electrodynamics
the concept of chirality - a projection of pseudospin onto momentum - carried over from relativistic quantum field theory to describe graphene's charge carriers
By analogy with QED, one can also introduce a quantity called chirality6 that is formally a projection of σr on r and is positive (negative) for electrons (holes).
← software engineering
software version control - Subversion, revision numbers, change logs, checkout of prior states - carried from programming practice into the curation of a scientific data record
Since the COD identifier of a structure, once assigned, remains unchanged, a problem might arise when a deposited COD file needs to be changed for some reason, say, a syntax or data error must be corrected after the deposition. Currently, we have adopted a version control system called Subversion (Collins-Sussman et…
← system administration
bulk distribution protocols from system administration - rsync, tarballs, anonymous repository checkout - used so that the database can be taken away entire rather than queried a record at a time
For anybody who wishes to use the COD and the PCOD databases, the collected files are presented using standard open protocols and formats. The database can be searched online on the COD server using a simple web-based search form, and the structural results can be downloaded either one by one or in a compressed .zip…
← measurement theory
inter-rater reliability logic from measurement theory - asking how far two independent determinations of the same quantity sit from each other before scoring a third against either
The apparent mean absolute error between experimental measurements and our calculations is 0.096 eV/atom. In order to estimate how much error to attribute to the DFT calculations, we also examine deviation between different experimental measurements themselves where multiple sources are available, and find a…
← machine learning
neural scaling laws, carried from language and vision into materials-stability prediction
Consistent with observations in other domains of machine learning, we observe that our neural networks predictions improve as a power law with the amount of data.
← quantum electrodynamics / high-energy physics
graphene charge carriers behave as massless Dirac fermions, letting a condensed-matter experiment probe relativistic QED and cosmology-relevant physics
the subtle and rich physics of quantum electrodynamics
← quantum chemistry
the bond-order concept from chemical bonding theory, used as the empirical function of interatomic distance that lets a classical potential break bonds
Alternatively, empirical interatomic potentials that are based on classical principles require significantly fewer computational resources, which enables simulations to better describe dynamic processes over longer timeframes and on larger scales. Such methods, however, typically require a predefined connectivity…
← machine learning
deep learning architectures and their training machinery - mini-batches, ADAM, max-norm regularisation, early stopping - carried from image and speech recognition into quantum chemistry
This cost function was chosen because of its robustness in handling outliers in data sets, a property that achieves 2 to 4 times lower error upon training an ANI potential.
← vibrational spectroscopy
normal mode analysis, carried from vibrational spectroscopy into a sampler for generating training conformations
The choice of temperature is dependent on the intended use of the ANI potential being trained. However, it should be noted that this method of sampling the potential surface of a molecule is simply an approximation for generating structures.
← silicon semiconductor device modelling
TCAD device-modelling tools and physical models developed for silicon, applied to ultrawide-bandgap semiconductors
Much can be borrowed from this legacy silicon TCAD, but there are significant challenges.
statistics 9 transfers
← machine learning
variational inference used to approximate difficult Bayesian posterior densities in statistics
we review variational inference (VI), a method from machine learning that approximates probability densities through optimization
← machine learning
flexible machine-learning estimators used for the nuisance functions of a causal parameter, with Neyman-orthogonal scores and cross-fitting added so their regularization bias does not carry into the estimate
the impact of regularization bias and overfitting on estimation of the parameter of interest θ0 can be removed by using two simple, yet critical, ingredients: (1) using Neyman-orthogonal moments/scores that have reduced sensitivity with respect to nuisance parameters to estimate θ0, and (2) making use of cross-fitting…
← twenty-four fields at once
the fitting procedure is deliberately applied across twenty-four data sets from unrelated branches of enquiry, so that the method rather than any one field's data is what is tested
The twenty-four data sets we study are drawn from a broad variety of different branches of human endeavor, including physics, earth sciences, biology, ecology, paleontology, computer and information sciences, engineering, and the social sciences.
← biostatistics
intention-to-treat is a statistical concept imported into the conduct and reporting of randomized controlled trials to handle noncompliance and missing outcomes
One potential solution to this problem is a statistical concept called intention-to-treat (ITT) analysis.
← randomization theory
the analysis set is defined by the randomized assignment rather than by the treatment actually received, which is what preserves the randomization
ITT analysis includes every subject who is randomized according to randomized treatment assignment.
← stochastic approximation
stochastic optimization following noisy gradient estimates, applied to the variational objective so inference need not pass over the whole data set each iteration
In this paper we derive a more efficient algorithm by using stochastic optimization (Robbins and Monro, 1951), a technique that follows noisy estimates of the gradient of the objective.
← information geometry
the natural gradient, which rescales the step by the Fisher information of the variational family rather than using the Euclidean gradient
With one more detail—the idea of a natural gradient (Amari, 1998)—stochastic variational inference has an attractive form: 1.
← probability / diagnostic testing
applying the positive-predictive-value / Bayesian framework from diagnostic testing to estimate the probability that a published research finding is true
the post-study probability that it is true is the positive predictive value, PPV
← machine learning
extending Breiman random forests to estimate heterogeneous treatment effects with valid statistical inference
we explore the use of ideas from the machine learning literature to improve the performance of these classical methods with many covariates
economics 7 transfers
← psychometrics / structural equation modelling
The authors take the latent-variable measurement models built in psychometrics and extend them so that a choice variable (schooling) and background variables can enter the measurement equations of an economic model.
the problems of endogeneity and measurement error. Our method extends the LISREL model
← psychology
two psychology instruments - the Rotter Locus of Control Scale and the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale - are imported into labour economics to stand for noncognitive skill
The noncognitive measures available in the data set are the Rotter Locus of Control Scale which was administered in 1979 and the Rosenberg 5 Self-Esteem Scale which was administered in 1980.
← military psychometrics
cognitive skill is measured with five subtests of the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery, an instrument built for military selection and re-used as an economic variable
Our analysis of test scores uses five measures of cognitive skills (arithmetic reasoning, word knowledge, paragraph comprehension, mathematical knowledge, and coding speed) derived from the Armed Services Vocational Aptitude Battery (ASVAB), which was administered to all sample participants in 1980 and 1981.
← statistics / machine learning
regression-tree (recursive partitioning) methods adapted to estimate heterogeneous treatment effects
Our approach builds on regression tree methods, modified to optimize for goodness of fit in treatment effects
← cryptography / computer science
using cryptographic proof (hashes, digital signatures, proof-of-work) to build a currency and payment system with no trusted third party
What is needed is an electronic payment system based on cryptographic proof instead of trust
← topology / fixed-point theory
The existence proof imports Kakutani's fixed-point theorem for convex-valued closed-graph set correspondences and applies it to the game's countering correspondence.
The author is indebted to Dr. David Gale for suggesting the use of Kakutani's theorem to simplify the proof and to the A. E. C. for financial support.
← social / cognitive psychology
using a subtle money-priming manipulation (a psychology method) to study its effects on economic and social behavior
Reminders of money, relative to nonmoney reminders, led to reduced requests for help and reduced helpfulness toward others
linguistics 7 transfers
← cognitive psychology
categorization in terminology is based on Prototype Theory, using degrees of typicality as the configurational pattern for conceptual categories
The model of categorization in Cognitive Linguistics and sociocognitive terminology is based on Rosch’s (1978) Prototype Theory, which uses degrees of typicality as the configurational pattern for conceptual categories or domains.
← cognitive linguistics
frames are carried into terminology as cognitive structuring devices based on experience, providing the background knowledge that motivates the existence of words
Frames also fall within cognitive linguistic approaches, and are a type of cognitive structuring device based on experience that provide the background knowledge and motivation for the existence of words in a language as well as the way those words are used in discourse.
← neural network language modelling
distributed vector representations of words, taken from neural language models into large-scale computational linguistics and simplified until they could be trained on billions of words
Probably the most successful concept is to use distributed representations of words [10].
← information retrieval / linear algebra
global matrix factorization (from latent semantic analysis) combined with local context windows to learn word vectors
combines the advantages of the two major model families in the literature: global matrix factorization and local context window methods
← psycholinguistics of comprehension
priming between production and comprehension, and between writing and speaking, is read as evidence that the two processes draw on the SAME representations - a claim that carries structure across the production/comprehension divide
Indeed, priming between production and comprehension, just like priming between writing and speaking, supports the claim that both processes draw on common representations of linguistic information, particularly ones associated with syntax.
← social interaction and politeness
the cases from Thomason of assuming leadership in a group and switching to the familiar pronoun, accommodation as a SOCIAL move imported to explain the conversational one
Another familiar case, involving even more painful risks, is establishing intimacy, as in beginning to use a familiar pronoun to someone in a language like French or German.
← the pragmatics of scalar implicature
the local and intermediate accommodation dispute is aligned with the embedded-implicature debate, and the same grammatical-versus-Gricean split is proposed for both
As Beaver and Zeevat note, the topic of local/intermediate accommodation has considerable parallels to the ongoing debate about whether there are “em- bedded implicatures”.
media-and-communication-studies 7 transfers
← cognitive and social psychology
The paper imports the dual-process account of cognition wholesale and uses it as the machinery for distinguishing media priming from political priming in communication research.
It then applies dualprocess models to the study of priming to illustrate the cognitive processing that occurs within media priming (and political priming).
← psychology
Chooses Kahneman's and Stanovich and West's System 1 / System 2 vocabulary, in preference to the communication field's own ELM and HSM, as the framework for the new theory.
Given that the System 1 and System 2 description encapsulates many of the propositions put forth in the ELM, the HSM, and other dual-process models, it will be utilized here.
← peace research
the taxonomy of news values used throughout journalism studies originates in a 1965 peace-research paper on the structure of foreign news, and is here re-tested rather than assumed
One of the most influential and frequently cited of these is a paper by Johan Galtung and Mari Ruge (1965), “The Structure of Foreign News”, published more than 50 years ago.
← content analysis
the criteria are put to the test by an empirical content analysis of published news, importing a quantitative method into a literature that had treated the list as given
Just as that study put Galtung and Ruge’s criteria to the test with an empirical content analysis of published news, this new study explores the extent to which Harcup and O’Neill’s revised list of news values remains relevant given the challenges (and opportunities) faced by journalism today, including the emergence…
← television and media-effects research
Kubey and Csikszentmihalyi's finding that people watch heavy TV in dysphoric states, carried across to the internet as self-medication
Similar ideas about the compen- satory potential of media use was suggested in an early study by Kubey and Csikszentmihalyi (1990), who claimed that people were more likely to engage in bouts of heavy TV watching when they were in dysphoric states.
← early communication research
the historical move from direct effects to mediating variables is proposed as the transition internet addiction research must now make
Williams, Yee, & Caplan (2008) have argued that game re- search needs to undergo the same transition as early communi- cation research did, where the direct effects model was made more nuanced by the addition of mediating variables.
← psychiatry and its philosophy of science
Ingleby's argument that the governing principles of a field are philosophical rather than empirical, applied to why more findings have not produced theory
What matters, Ingleby argues, are the fundamental principles which gov- ern the acquisition and interpretation of ‘‘findings’’; and these principles, although they are governed by matters of fact, are not themselves discovered empirically – they are as much philosophi- cal as scientific ones (p. 24).
machine-learning 7 transfers
← physics
the conservation law, taken from physics and imposed on relevance flowing between network layers
The underlying Formula (2) can be interpreted as a conservation law for the relevance R in between layers of the feature processing.
← database change detection
a divergence built for change detection in data streams, taken into statistical learning theory as the domain-distance term of a generalisation bound
The H-divergence resolves both problems associated with the L1 divergence. First, for hypothesis classes H of finite VC dimension, the H-divergence can be estimated from finite samples (see Lemma 1 below). Second, the H-divergence for any class H is never larger than the L1 divergence, and is in general smaller when H…
← statistical hypothesis testing
binary classification itself used as a measuring instrument - a discriminator trained to separate two unlabeled samples, with its error read as a distance
Our basic plan of attack will be as follows: Label each unlabeled source instance with 0 and unlabeled target instance as 1. Then train a classifier to discriminate between source and target instances. The H-divergence is immediately computable from the error.
← machine learning
The size-agnostic transferability of graph neural networks, demonstrated in robot control, wind power estimation and weather prediction, is imported into production scheduling to make a scheduler that works on unseen shop sizes
We utilize such transferability of GNNs to accomplish the transferable property in our JSSP scheduler.
← deep reinforcement learning
Proximal Policy Optimization, a policy-gradient algorithm from the RL literature, is adopted to train the representation and dispatching modules of a job-shop scheduler end to end
We use proximal policy optimization (PPO) [37] algorithm, a variant of policy-based RL, to train the GNN based state representation module and the parameterized decision-making policy jointly.
← tabular and vector data mining
SMOTE and Borderline-SMOTE were built to interpolate new points for imbalanced TABULAR data and are carried over to images
SMOTE and the extension of Borderline-SMOTE [30] create new instances by interpolating new points from existing instances via k-Nearest Neighbors.
← human learning and cognition
transfer learning is explained by the anecdote that a pianist learns guitar faster, and augmentation by analogy with imagination and dreaming
For example, a human intelligence anecdote of transfer learning is illustrated in learning music.
computer-science 6 transfers
← mathematics / logic
modelling data as mathematical n-ary relations queried via predicate calculus, giving data independence
A model based on n-ary relations, a normal form for data base relations, and the concept of a universal data sublanguage are introduced
← information retrieval
precision and recall from information retrieval, carried into vision as the basis of average precision and then of the field's single headline number
The most commonly used metric is Average Precision (AP), derived from precision and recall. AP is usually evaluated in a category specific manner, i.e., computed for each object category separately. To compare performance over all object categories, the mean AP (mAP) averaged over all object categories is adopted as…
← natural language processing
additive soft attention, carried from sentence-to-sentence machine translation into a convolutional network over medical images, and re-based on an image grid so the coefficients can be local
We take the attention approach proposed by a step further by proposing grid-based gating that allows attention gates to be more specific to local regions. This improves performance compared to gating based on a global feature vector.
← neuroscience
the brain as the model for the architecture - `mimicking how the brain perceives and understands multimodal information` is inside the definition rather than beside it
Deep learning allows computational models of multiple processing layers to learn and represent data with multiple levels of abstraction mimicking how the brain perceives and understands multimodal information, thus implicitly capturing intricate structures of large‐scale data.
← computer vision
ultra-deep residual neural networks for pixel-level labeling
To further improve supervised learning methods for contact prediction, we borrow ideas from very recent breakthrough in computer vision.
← 2d object detection
the focal loss, carried from single-stage 2D image detection into 3D point-cloud detection to handle the same foreground-background imbalance
Our network usually generates ∼70k anchors within a KITTI point cloud. Unfortunately, there are usually only a few ground truths, each of which generates only 4–6 positives. This leads to an extreme imbalance between the foreground and background classes.
chemistry 6 transfers
← biological taxonomy
the rank names of Linnaean biological taxonomy - Kingdom, SuperClass, Class, SubClass - are carried across to name the levels of a CHEMICAL taxonomy
Inspired by the original Linnaean biological taxonomy [ 4 ], we assigned the terms Kingdom, SuperClass, Class, and SubClass to denote the first, second, third and fourth levels of the chemical taxonomy, respectively.
← artificial intelligence
graph neural networks / deep learning, applied to predict quantum-chemical properties of molecules
using machine learning (and especially deep learning)
← artificial intelligence
a variational autoencoder mapping molecules (SMILES strings) into a continuous latent space for automatic chemical design
We apply such generative models to chemical design, using a pair of deep networks trained as an autoencoder to convert molecules represented as SMILES strings into a continuous vector representation
← machine learning on text
the variational autoencoder with recurrent encoder and decoder, taken from Bowman et al.'s work on English sentences and applied to molecules as strings
Variational autoencoders with recurrent neural network encoding/decoding were proposed by Bowman et al. in the context of written English sentences, and we followed their approach closely. 20
← generative modelling of images, speech and music
the idea that a low-dimensional continuous code supports interpolation and analogy, imported as the reason a molecular latent space should be navigable
Such models usually also produce low-dimensional continuous representations of the data being modeled, allowing interpolation or analogical reasoning for natural images, 19 text, 20 speech, and music. 21 , 22
← artificial intelligence
deep convolutional neural networks applied to model quantum interactions in molecules
Deep learning has the potential to revolutionize quantum chemistry
ecology 6 transfers
← statistical physics / random matrix theory
random matrix theory and the cavity method applied to the stability of ecological communities
presenting new results in random matrix theory, which are obtained using a quaternionic parameterization of the cavity method
← random matrix theory and statistical physics
the cavity method, extended with a quaternionic parameterisation, to obtain eigenvalue results for structured ecological community matrices
Here we study the effect of modularity on the local stability of ecological dynamical systems, by presenting new results in random matrix theory, which are obtained using a quaternionic parameterization of the cavity method.
← climate science
tipping elements
We have borrowed this analogy from the climate system that is now also believed to have distinct tipping elements 11 .
← climatology and forest ecology
potential analysis
To detect alternative states in the intestinal bacteria, we used potential analysis that was recently applied to study analogous state shifts in climatology and forest ecosystems 13 , 14 .
← network science / statistical physics
the robustness/fragility (error- vs attack-tolerance) framework from complex networks applied to ecological food webs
which have been shown to display a very high homeostasis against random removals of nodes
← statistical physics of complex networks
the error-and-attack-tolerance analysis of scale-free graphs, applied to species loss in ecological communities
The trophic organization of species-rich communities is similar to other complex network topologies (Albert et al 2000, Jeong et al 2000).
art-history 6 transfers
← artificial intelligence
generative adversarial networks adapted to generate art that deviates from style norms
We build over Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN), which have shown the ability to learn to generate novel images simulating a given distribution
← psychology
Berlyne theory of aesthetic novelty and arousal used to design the creativity objective
Berlyne emphasized that the most significant arousal-raising properties for aesthetics are novelty
← artificial intelligence
convolutional neural networks trained for object recognition, repurposed to synthesize artistic images
biologically inspired vision models called Deep Neural Networks
← neural style transfer
the style-transfer idea of separating content from style, taken from that literature and built into the generator architecture so that style is injected at each convolution layer - the network is named after it
Motivated by style transfer literature [27], we re-design the generator architecture in a way that exposes novel ways to control the image synthesis process.
← semantic web and information science
Linked Data, reference ontologies and authority files, applied to art-historical research and found to fit only part of it
In Digital Humanities (DH) research this process and its specific structure has to be represented on a data level.
← digital humanities / computational text analysis
text mining, a method the authors note is common in other disciplines but rare in art history, is turned back onto art-historical writing itself to study the discipline's own historiography
we decided to use digital methods on DAH scholarship, namely text mining, to elucidate the historiographic and theoretical concerns in the uptake of computational methods in art history.
social-sciences 6 transfers
← nursing and midwifery
cultural safety is carried from Maori nursing practice in Aotearoa New Zealand into medical education and health-practitioner regulation more broadly
Irihapeti Ramsden and Māori nurses in the 1990s [74], and in 1992 the Nursing Council of New Zealand made cultural safety a requirement for nursing and midwifery education [32].
← transcultural nursing
transcultural nursing is defined as a subfield of nursing and its competency framing is what this paper argues against carrying further
Leininger (1994) defined transcultural nursing as being a subfield of nursing, focusing on comparative study and analysis of different cultures and is the basis on which the theory of culture care diversity and universality was formed.
← philosophy
the definition of what a concept IS is taken from philosophy and adapted for social-science methodology: a concept has components and is defined by them
What is a concept? When defining of the term concept, I follow and adapt the approach of Deleuze and Guattari in their What Is Philosophy? (1991), in which they hold that “every concept has components and is defined by them” (p. 15).
← grounded theory
conceptual framework analysis is built as a procedure of theorization on the grounded theory method
Conceptual framework analysis offers a procedure of theorization for building conceptual frameworks based on grounded theory method.
← grounded theory
the stopping rule for data collection is taken from grounded theory and applied across qualitative research generally, where the theoretical apparatus that gave it meaning is absent
In broad terms, saturation is used in qualitative research as a criterion for discontinuing data collection and/or analysis.1 Its origins lie in grounded theory (Glaser and Strauss 1967), but in one form or another it now commands acceptance across a range of approaches to qualitative research.
← grounded theory
theoretical saturation carries over grounded theory's criterion - that the properties of theoretical categories are adequately developed - rather than a criterion about the data
In contrast to data saturation and inductive thematic saturation, the first model of saturation considered, theoretical saturation—as based on the grounded theory notion of determining when the properties of theoretical categories are adequately developed— indicates that the process of analysis is at a more advanced…
education 5 transfers
← mathematical/combinatorial optimization
the design of instructional material is recast as a combinatorial optimization problem — identifying, ranking and sequentially ordering interdependent elements to minimise a measured cost function (cognitive load)
Optimization is essential because creating coherent and contiguous relational knowledge is a complex combinatorial problem involving the identification, ranking, and sequential ordering of many interdependent elements and associated relationships.
← cognitive psychology
cognitive load theory, originally developed from short-term memory experiments, is imported as the cognitive-domain measure in a STEAM education acceptance model
Cognitive load theory was first proposed by a cognitive psychologist based on empirical research on short-term memory ability
← cognitive psychology
schema-based instruction and mathematical representations grounded in cognitive-load theory, applied to teaching students with learning difficulties
in the literature on cognitive load theory
← information systems research
The information-quality construct and its role as a determinant of satisfaction and use are taken from the DeLone and McLean model of information systems success and applied to primary-school learning tools
As part of the DeLone and McLean model (D&M) of information systems success, information quality was often used to measure system quality (DeLone and McLean, 2003).
← adult learning and health promotion
the two competing readings of health literacy - clinical risk against personal asset - are traced to two different parent traditions, clinical care on one side and adult learning and health promotion on the other
Nutbeam [ 52 ] refers to the opposing medical and public health views on health literacy as respectively a "clinical risk", and a "personal asset" approach, and points out that they are rooted in the different traditions of clinical care, and adult learning and health promotion, respectively.
political-science 5 transfers
← network science / computational social science
social-network-structure analysis applied to measure political polarization on Twitter
we collect data from Twitter related to both social network structure and tweet content for a large set of users (679,000) engaging with US politics
← computational social science
digital trace data linked to survey response, carried from computational social science into a question political science had been answering with self-report
We link a representative online survey (N = 3500) to behavioral data on respondents’ Facebook sharing history during the campaign, avoiding known biases in self-reports of online activity.
← machine learning
a supervised text classifier from information retrieval, used not to make the finding but to draw the boundary of the outcome variable
Our BuzzFeed-based list began with 30 domains identified by that site’s reporting as purveyors of intentionally false election-related stories generating the most Facebook engagement. To do this, the journalists, led by Craig Silverman, used keywords and existing lists combined with the analytics service BuzzSumo. To…
← natural language processing
transformer encoder models (multilingual mBERT, and the Hebrew-targeted AlephBERT and HeRO) and LLM decoders, applied to detect political delegitimization discourse in Knesset and social media text
For encoders, we use the multilingual mBERT (Devlin et al., 2019), and Hebrew-targeted encoders AlephBERT (Seker et al., 2022), HeRO (Shalumov and Haskey, 2023) and the base and large variants of DictaBERT (Shmidman et al., 2023).
← political methodology
the weighted log-odds method for identifying tokens most strongly associated with a group, applied to political blocs
Using the weighted log odds method proposed by Monroe et al. (2008), we identify the PDD target tokens most strongly associated with each political bloc.
genetics 4 transfers
← statistics
negative-binomial generalized linear models with empirical-Bayes shrinkage applied to detect differential gene expression in RNA-seq
using shrinkage estimation for dispersions and fold changes to improve stability
← mathematics / statistics
applying numerical counting and statistical ratio analysis to inheritance, revealing constant proportions and combinatorial segregation of traits
definitely to ascertain their statistical relations
← linguistics
the word2vec word-embedding model, applied to DNA k-mers
Our method is based on the popular word embedding model word2vec, which is trained on a shallow two-layer neural network
← single-cell sequencing
gene signature quantification, taken from single-cell sequencing practice into bulk TCGA/GTEx analysis
However, the existing data cannot present the expression distribution of a certain immune-cell cluster across cancer types. In this case, researchers can use GEPIA2 to easily obtain the immune-cell cluster signature profile in a pan-cancer manner. For example, one can readily find that Th1-like signature in stomach…
philosophy 4 transfers
← machine learning
framing the philosophical problem of AI safety concretely in terms of machine-learning methods (supervised learning, reinforcement learning)
in terms of classic methods in machine learning, such as supervised classification and reinforcement learning
← engineering
importing the engineering notion of accidents and safety into the analysis of AI systems
This issue arises in almost any engineering discipline
← cognitive science / neuroscience
using the explanatory framework of cognitive science and neuroscience (computational and neural mechanisms) to demarcate the tractable easy problems of consciousness from the hard problem
The easy problems of consciousness are those that seem directly susceptible to the standard methods of cognitive science
← physics
using the physics image of a field of force (with boundary conditions) to model the holistic web of scientific knowledge and its contact with experience
total science is like a field of force whose boundary conditions are experience
sociology 4 transfers
← mathematics
the Erdos-Renyi random graph as the incumbent model of complex network topology, taken up and then shown to be the wrong model because real networks grow and attach preferentially
Traditionally, networks of complex topology have been described using the random graph theory of Erd˝os and R´enyi (ER) (7), but in the absence of data on large networks the predictions of the ER theory were rarely tested in the real world.
← philosophy
the metaphor of a net of a given mesh laid over a stained surface is taken over and developed into the paper's own model of how each discipline's theoretical production captures reality partially and differently
Developing this metaphor, each intellectual construct whatever the origin would thus appear as a net whose mesh shape is different from another net or in other words, another discipline, another school of thought, another approach, etc.
← statistical physics / network science
percolation and network analysis (robustness, phase transitions) applied to a society-scale communication network
social networks are robust to the removal of the strong ties, but fall apart following a phase transition if the weak ties are removed
← the sociology of friendship networks
Feld's friendship paradox - that your friends have more friends than you do - taken as the frame for reading the degree distribution of the whole Facebook graph
Feld’s observation that ‘your friends have more friends than you’ is an important psychological paradox, applying to friendship as well as sexual partners.
physics 4 transfers
← statistics
statistical significance testing (p-values, sigma levels) used to establish the discovery of a new particle against background fluctuations
the p-values corresponding to significances of 1 to 6
← algebraic topology
1-homologies and 1-cohomologies over Z2 used to describe the protected subspace of the lattice model, so that the stored information is a topological invariant rather than a local one
In a more abstract language, the algebra (with coefficients from Z2), 1-homologies and 1-cohomologies.
← quantum mechanics
resonance theory from quantum mechanics - alpha decay, poles of a continued Green function, the Bohr-Sommerfeld rule and WKB scattering off a barrier - carried into the calculation of black hole oscillation frequencies
In general with this approach one can calculate quite accurately the low-lying (relatively small imaginary part) QNM modes, but it fails to give accurate results for higher-order modes.
← classical astrophysics
the asteroseismological programme of inferring stellar interiors from an oscillation spectrum, carried from classical astrophysics to neutron stars where the spectrum includes modes of the spacetime
From tests performed using polytropic stars to provide data for the above relations it was seen that these equations predict the masses and the radii of the polytropes usually with an error less than 10%. There is work underway towards extracting the parameters of the star from a noisy signal.
network-science 4 transfers
← linguistics
the Skip-gram word-embedding architecture (word2vec), applied to graph nodes
We proceed by extending the Skip-gram architecture to networks
← mathematics
building the study of complex networks on the foundation of mathematical graph theory, with statistical-physics methods
The study of networks, in the form of mathematical graph theory, is one of the fundamental pillars of discrete mathematics.
← finance
Planar Maximally Filtered Graph
Previously, a graph filtering technique called Planar Maximally Filtered Graph (PMFG) has been applied to many real-world data sets such as financial stock prices and gene expression to extract meaningful and relevant interactions.
← other domains
network analysis approaches
These observations suggest that the biological networks may follow the similar evolutionary dynamics, and thus network analysis approaches from other domains are very helpful for understanding biological networks[ 4 ].
quantitative-finance 4 transfers
← physics
the scale of elementary transactions is named by borrowing physics' own word for its smallest level of description
The first level deals with ultra-high frequency scales: that of elementary transactions (a level that in physics is called “microscopic”).
← the physics of anomalous diffusion
the Hurst exponent and the diffusion picture are carried into order-flow analysis, so that a market's memory is measured the way an anomalous diffusion process is
The use of the Hurst exponent is motivated by the relationship to diffusion properties of the integrated process.
← stochastic processes / statistical physics
fractional Brownian motion with a Hurst exponent below 1/2 used as the model of log-volatility, in place of the standard semimartingale volatility models of finance
Our main result is that log-volatility behaves essentially as a fractional Brownian motion with Hurst exponent H of order 0.1, at any reasonable time scale.
← neurobiology
the architecture and vocabulary of the biological nervous system - neurons, synapses, axons, signals passed between layers - carried into empirical asset pricing as the description of a feed-forward network
Analogous to axons in a biological brain, layers of the networks represent groups of "neurons" with each layer connected by "synapses" that transmit signals among neurons of different layers.
epidemiology 4 transfers
← econometrics
the instrumental-variable estimator is imported from econometrics and its instrument is a genetic variant rather than an economic one
Mendelian randomisation is an analytical method that uses genetic variants as instrumental variables for modifiable risk factors that affect population health.
← economics
genetic variation is read as a natural experiment, the design economics uses to get causal estimates out of observational data
Mendelian randomisation uses genetic variation as a natural experiment to investigate the causal relations between potentially modifiable risk factors and health outcomes in observational data.
← network science / statistical physics
modelling epidemic spreading on scale-free contact networks
We define a dynamical model for the spreading of infections on scale-free networks
← biological epidemiology
the susceptible-infected-susceptible model and the notion of an epidemic threshold, applied to computer virus outbreaks on the Internet
The epidemiological analysis of computer viruses has been the subject of a continuous interest in the computer science community [10,13–15], following mainly approaches borrowed from biological epidemiology [11].
behavioural-psychology 4 transfers
← artificial intelligence
The credit-assignment problem is taken over from AI and made the central question that an operant conditioning process must answer
the core problem of assignment of credit, a term from artificial intelligence that refers to the question
← evolutionary biology
Darwin's natural selection is imported as the model for operant conditioning, with reinforcement as the selective agent acting on a variable repertoire of emitted acts
immediately forged a link with the dominant idea in biology: Charles Darwin’s natural selection, according to which adaptation arises via selection from a population that contains many heritable variants
← computer science
The reinforcement-learning framework is adopted as the normative account within which both Pavlovian and operant behaviour are interpreted
The computational field of reinforcement learning has provided a normative framework within which both Pavlovian and operant conditioned behavior can be understood.
← evolutionary biology
Darwinian selection from a varied population, imported to explain how one behaviour is picked out of an emitted repertoire by reinforcement
The view of operant behavior as a repertoire of emitted acts from which one is selected by reinforcement, immediately forged a link with the dominant idea in biology: Charles Darwin’s natural selection, according to which adaptation arises via selection from a population that contains many heritable variants, some…
engineering 4 transfers
← metallurgy
the Hume-Rothery binary solid-solution size rule, carried from alloy metallurgy into multicomponent ceramics and then re-measured
The original Hume-Rothery solid-solution rule suggests that (rsolute−rsolvent)/rsolvent ≤ 15% is one of the necessary conditions for forming a binary solid solution.
← steel metallurgy
the twinning-induced plasticity mechanism, recognised first in Hadfield manganese steels and copper thin films and applied here to explain an entropy-named alloy
In addition to the high- and medium-entropy alloys, there are now several other materials known to benefit from twinning, including copper thin films and 11–15 wt.% (Hadfield) Mn-steels (used in the mining industry for rock crushers because of their hardness and fracture resistance) and their modern variant known as…
← mineralogy
buserite, a layered manganese oxide known as a mineral, used as the structural model for a discharge product in a battery electrode
Notably, the XRD pattern of the rinsed cathode differs from that of previously reported species (e.g., MnOOH, spinel ZnMn2O4 , birnessite, tunneled γ-ZnMnO2 , and layered L-ZnxMnO2 ) in discharged MnO2 electrodes (Supplementary Fig. 4d). Rietveld refinement of the XRD data of the discharged electrode suggests the…
← synchrotron physics
synchrotron X-ray absorption spectroscopy, carried from structural physics into reading the oxidation state and local coordination of a cycled electrode
A comparison of the crystallographic structure between β-MnO2 and Zn-buserite suggests that the co-insertion of Zn2+ and H2O and the dissolution of Mn distort the pyrolusite framework, leaving Mn vacancies in the upper/underlying layers and generating layered Zn-buserite. This tunnel-to-layer phase transition is…
genomics 4 transfers
← experimental design
the latin square, carried from agricultural experimental design into the layout of an RNA mixture so that no two populations' concentrations are collinear
For this purpose, we designed an in vitro RNA mixture experiment (Fig. 3a). Immune populations were purified from healthy donors’ peripheral blood; their RNAs were extracted and mixed in highly variable concentrations (from 0.7 to 46 % of the sample’s RNA). The RNA proportions of the populations were arranged in two…
← signal detection theory
the ROC curve and the signal-to-noise ratio, carried from signal detection into the selection criteria for a gene marker
Three criteria were then calculated for each feature (probe set) within the discovery set: a) the mean log2-expression difference between positive and negative samples (a threshold of 2 was applied); b) the area under the ROC curve (AUC) of the feature for the identification of the positive samples (threshold of…
← genome sequencing
the GemCode gel-bead-in-emulsion barcoding platform, carried from genome haplotyping, structural variant analysis and de novo genome assembly into single-cell RNA counting
The scRNA-seq microfluidics platform builds on the GemCode technology, which has been used for genome haplotyping, structural variant analysis and de novo assembly of a human genome.
← statistics
the two-genome mixture model with a Gibbs sampler and Stephens relabelling, carried from mixture-model statistics into deciding which transplanted cells are whose
While previous studies have used existing SNVs from DNA sequencing or large-scale copy number changes in the transcriptome data to distinguish cells by genotype, these methods cannot be applied to transplant samples where donor and host genotype is not known a priori, and when donor and host are closely matched in…
information-theory 3 transfers
← convex optimization / mathematics
recovering a sparse signal from few frequency samples by solving a convex l1-minimization (linear-programming) problem
exact recovery may be obtained by solving a convex optimization problem
← statistical mechanics
entropy itself - the quantity H, its form, and its identification with the H of Boltzmann's theorem, carried out of statistical mechanics and made the measure of information in a communication channel
The form of H will be recognized as that of entropy as defined in certain formulations of statistical mechanics8 where pi is the probability of a system being in cell i of its phase space. H is then, for example, the H in Boltzmann’s famous H theorem.
← rate distortion theory in communication
the rate-distortion trade-off curve and its cardinality specification, taken from lossy source coding and re-drawn in the information plane as the bottleneck curve
These curves, analogous to the rate distortion curves, exists for every choice of the cardinality of ˜X.
astronomy 3 transfers
← signal processing / statistical detection theory
optimal matched filtering (from signal detection theory) applied to extract gravitational-wave signals from detector noise
using optimal matched filtering with waveforms predicted by general relativity
← statistics / computational statistics
Bayesian inference via Markov chain Monte Carlo used to estimate cosmological parameters from the cosmic microwave background
sampled, along with cosmological parameters, during Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) exploration of the likelihood
← statistics
Bayesian statistical inference and Monte Carlo simulation applied to Type Ia supernova data to infer the expansion history and cosmic acceleration
we used a Monte Carlo simulation to understand how SNe Ia in our nearby and distant samples were c hosen
mathematics 3 transfers
← compressive sampling in signal acquisition
the compressed-sensing result that an object can be recovered exactly from far fewer measurements than its dimension, carried over from signal acquisition to the recovery of a low-rank matrix from a sample of its entries
Our work is inspired by results in the emerging field of compressive sampling or compressed sensing, a new paradigm for acquiring information about objects of interest from what appears to be a highly incomplete set of measurements [10, 12, 16].
← ergodic theory / harmonic analysis
adapting ergodic-theory and Szemeredi-style combinatorial methods, plus a transference principle, to prove the primes contain arbitrarily long arithmetic progressions
our paper has at least as much in common with the ergodic-theoretic approach as it does with the harmonic analysis approach
← statistical physics / thermodynamics
importing entropy and monotonicity ideas from statistical physics to build monotonic functionals for the Ricci flow, used to resolve geometric and topological questions
The interplay of statistical physics and (pseudo)-riemannian geometry occurs in the subject of Black Hole Thermodynamics
psychophysics 3 transfers
← detection theory
Introducing catch-trials turns the psychophysical experiment into a detection situation, so the whole apparatus of detection theory can be applied to psychophysical problems.
is relatively new, perhaps, is the realization that introducing them brings the psychophysical experiment under the rubric of detection, thereby rendering psychophysical
← radar/receiver detection engineering
The likelihood-ratio distribution functions already computed for signals in uniform gaussian noise are taken over directly to derive the psychophysical function for a human listener.
Fortunately, Peterson and Birdsall (15) have calculated these functions for a wide variety of signals presented in uniform gaussian noise.
← communication theory / signal processing
The sampling theorem is imported so that a band-limited receiver input over an interval can be represented as a finite set of 2TW random variables.
The Sampling Theorem. We shall need one form of the so-called sampling theorem
earth-science 2 transfers
← social science
a content-analysis coding methodology (independent raters categorizing texts) applied to quantify the scientific consensus on anthropogenic global warming
Each abstract was categorized by two independent, anonymized raters
← artificial intelligence
deep learning / data-driven methods (developed for image recognition and NLP) applied to weather forecasting
Data-driven approaches, most prominently deep learning, have become powerful tools for prediction in many
law 2 transfers
← computer science
differential-privacy tools and a Lipschitz metric formalism applied to define and enforce fairness in classification
how tools developed in the context of differential privacy may be applied to fairness
← statistics / machine learning
probabilistic fairness criteria (calibration, error-rate balance) applied to risk scores used in consequential legal / policy decisions
concern over discrimination in machine learning has led to a large body of new work seeking to better understand and prevent it
robotics 2 transfers
← computer vision
a convolutional network taking raw camera pixels, used in place of the perception-plus-control pipeline of robotics so that steering is learned end to end
We trained a convolutional neural network (CNN) to map raw pixels from a single front-facing camera directly to steering commands.
← artificial intelligence
deep convolutional networks trained end-to-end from perception to control for robotic manipulation
as well as a novel CNN architecture designed for robotic control
educational-neuroscience 2 transfers
← cognitive neuroscience / functional neuroimaging
the paper imports the neuroimaging meta-analytic apparatus (coordinate-based ALE and MACM on fMRI data) into mathematics-education research in order to derive teaching strategies
this study intends to further investigate which educational strategies can scientifically and effectively promote students’ mathematical creativity based on exploring the cognitive neural basis of creativity and mathematical competence through a cognitive neural meta-analytic approach
← cognitive neuroscience
coordinate-based meta-analysis of fMRI activation, imported into education research to adjudicate a question behavioural methods could not settle
Cognitive neuroscience can not only examine behavioral changes but also study the correlation of these behavioral changes with brain structure and function.
science-education 2 transfers
← machine learning / deep learning
an LSTM plus convolutional-neural-network architecture, imported to classify students' coded learning-behaviour sequences
Long short-term memory (LSTM) and the convolutional neural network (CNN) algorithm architecture were applied to identify behavioral sequences based on the data.
← cognitive psychology
working memory as a capacity limit, used to define germane load and thereby to ground an instructional-design construct in a memory construct
Germane cognitive load is defined as the amount of working memory capacity required for managing intrinsic load.
social-neuroscience 2 transfers
← economics / decision theory
discounting - the devaluation of a reward by the cost of obtaining it - applied to effort rather than to delay or probability, and used as the computational frame for prosocial choice
This phenomenon, referred to as effort discounting, relies on computations in which rewards are devalued by exerting effort.
← cultural psychology
Markus and Kitayama's independent/interdependent self-construal distinction, imported as the cognitive variable that might explain a cultural difference in neural empathy
According to Markus and Kitayama (2010) , an independent schema of self organizes behavior primarily in reference to an individual’s own thoughts and feelings and results in a weakened sense of in-group/out-group relationship so that people can move between in-group and out-group relatively easily.
consumer-psychology 2 transfers
← attitude psychology
The tri-component ABC model of attitudes is imported as the organizing scheme for a marketing/consumer-behaviour priming framework.
In developing the priming framework, each type of prime is categorized by priming outcome: affective, behavioral, and cognitive, which follows suit with the tri-component ABC model of attitudes (Breckler, 1984).
← psychology
The procedural priming paradigm, developed and used in psychology, is imported into consumer/marketing research as a tool for inducing and detecting spontaneous product inferences.
Although procedural priming has been used in psychology, it has not been applied in a marketing context, despite its potential as a managerial tool for inducing favorable product inferences.
experimental-economics 2 transfers
← social psychology
the word-search priming procedure itself, lifted from psychology experiments and applied inside an incentivised economic game where money is at stake
Using priming techniques from social psychology, we activate the concept of cooperation and explore the extent to which this intervention brings about changes in people’s voluntary contributions to the public good and self-reported emotional responses.
← natural language processing / machine learning
Prompt-engineering techniques for eliciting language-model reasoning are imported into the agent-based-modelling tradition of experimental economics, with prompts standing in for experimental instructions to human subjects.
To situate our approach within existing methodological traditions, we note that our use of LLM-based generative agents as substitutes for human participants builds on the lineage of agent-based modeling in experimental economics, while integrating recent advances in natural language reasoning through prompt…
comparative-political-economy 2 transfers
← psychology / social-science research on identity priming
The concept of priming - that individuals hold multiple identities whose salience can be cued, thereby shifting their political preferences - is imported to explain when consumers defend or abandon platform firms.
Our theoretical position draws on the priming literature in social science, which posits that individuals have multiple identities, the salience of which can influence their political preferences on a given political issue.
← european union integration studies
The permissive-consensus model of EU public opinion is borrowed as the analogy for how consumer support licenses platform firms until salient issues break it.
The orientation of today’s consumers with respect to companies enjoying platform power can perhaps best be made by analogy to what Hooghe and Marks (2009) called the permissive consensus in public opinion.
health-psychology 2 transfers
← qualitative sociology
grounded theory's open coding step, taken into a health-services interview study and run alongside a fixed rating scale on the same transcripts
A single coder (CS), trained in qualitative analysis methods, analyzed the transcripts and identified themes using an open coding process, which does not use a priori codes or codes created prior to the analysis and places an emphasis on information that can be extracted directly from the data.
← speech technology
automatic speech transcription, used as the route from recording to analysable text with a manual verification pass
The interviews were conducted by 20 undergraduate researchers trained in qualitative methods and the use of the interview survey guide described above. None of the authors conducted the interviews. All interviews were conducted via Zoom [22] and were audio recorded. The recordings were later transcribed using Otter.ai…
anthropology 1 transfer
← experimental economics
the Ultimatum and Dictator Games - anonymous one-shot allocations of real money, built as economic instruments - used as the cross-cultural measure of fairness and punishment in small-scale societies
Foremost among these experiments, the Ultimatum Game provides a pair of anonymous subjects with a sum of real money for a one-shot interaction.
literature 1 transfer
← natural language processing
sentiment analysis applied to works of fiction to extract their emotional arcs
we use a simple, robust sentiment analysis tool to extract the reader-perceived emotional content of written stories as they unfold on the page
quantum-computing 1 transfer
← number theory / mathematics
reducing integer factorization to order/period-finding (a number-theory reduction), then solving it on a quantum computer via the quantum Fourier transform
factorization can be reduced to finding the order of an element
control-theory 1 transfer
← control theory
framing and analyzing reinforcement learning with the tools of optimal control, using the Linear Quadratic Regulator as the baseline
the Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) with unknown dynamics, perhaps the simplest and best-studied problem in optimal control
operations-research 1 transfer
← artificial intelligence
using machine learning to learn heuristics for combinatorial optimization problems
at leveraging machine learning to solve combinatorial optimization problems
marketing 1 transfer
← health risk communication
the health-risk literature's account of how messages at different levels of construal are processed, carried into consumer research on self-regulatory depletion
Building on the health risk literature, we suggest that processing health messages that convey high (vs. low) levels of risk consumes more self-control resources and thus will undermine subsequent self-control in performing health behaviors unrelated to the depleting message.
strategic-communication 1 transfer
← psychology
the study imports theoretical apparatus from psychology and neighbouring consumer-research fields into strategic-communication research on influencer content
To understand audience members’ perceptions of influencer-produced sponsored content from a variety of perspectives, this research combined theoretical insights from several fields, including corporate communication, psychology, media studies, marketing research, and advertising.
sensory-science 1 transfer
← psychophysics / signal detection theory
d-prime as the measure of sensory difference, so that food-discrimination tests are scored on a psychophysical sensitivity scale rather than by proportion correct
However, in some cases the SD-2- AFC produced lower d-prime values indicating lower absolute levels of sensory differentiation.
behavioural-science 1 transfer
← behavioural economics
prospect theory and the incentive-response account of choice, taken from behavioural economics into the design of population-wide health behaviour-change interventions
As such, behavioural economics has been mostly concerned, broadly, with how people respond to incentives – and the landmark model in this field, prospect theory (Kahneman & Tversky, 1979), describes how people actually make risky financial decisions.
behavioral-economics 1 transfer
← cognitive / behavioral psychology
nudging / choice-architecture interventions (priming, defaults) drawing on heuristics-and-biases psychology, applied to influence food choice
Nudging is attracting considerable interest due to its understanding and application of heuristic biases among consumers
information-systems 1 transfer
← communication science / social psychology
the theory of how humans accommodate their speech to an interlocutor, re-applied to design a chatbot that accommodates its style to the user
Our study will further contribute to research by adapting communication accommodation theory (Giles et al., 2010) to the context of human-AI interaction, thereby showing that adapting the CA’s communication style to users has the potential to positively influence their user experience.
quantitative-psychology 1 transfer
← communications and radar detection theory
signal detection theory, carried into psychology to quantify discrimination between two stimulus types - and it brought its vocabulary with it, so psychological stimuli are still called `signal` and `noise`
Psychologists first applied the theory in studies of perception, where subjects discrimi nated between signals (stimuli) and noise (no stimuli).
theoretical-neuroscience 1 transfer
← politics / electoral competition
The structure of a democratic election — primaries, a winning party that stays in power and shapes later events, and opinion polls — is imported as an explicit working model of how transient neuronal coalitions compete and how one comes to dominate and constitute the conscious percept.
The winning coalition associated with an object or event would correspond to the winning party, which would remain in power for some time and would attempt to influence and control future events.
political-economy 1 transfer
← psychology
The online-processing model of attitude formation, taken from psychological work on impression formation and persuasion, is used to explain why candidate preference moved without any measurable gain in factual knowledge
Drawing on work from psychology (Norman H. Anderson and Stephen Hubert 1963, and W. A. Watts and W. J. McGuire 1964), political scientists have constructed models of online processing of political information
artificial-intelligence-and-law 1 transfer
← sociology
Weber's ideal-type model of bureaucratic administration is applied to rule-based legal expert systems, which is what licenses the paper's reclassification of them as 'bureaucratic' rather than 'legal' expert systems
Most of us would describe this kind of application of the law as a function of an ideal Weberian bureaucracy.
experimental-jurisprudence 1 transfer
← modal logic
an axiom of modal logic — that what is actual is thereby possible — is imported to turn the two response patterns into a demonstrable contradiction and so to derive the experimental prediction
According to most systems of modal logic, if there exists even a single retrospective law, it follows that retrospective laws certainly could exist—in virtue of axiom M.
neuroeconomics 1 transfer
← cognitive neuroscience / neuroimaging
brain and body measurement techniques (fMRI, EEG, fNIRS, galvanic skin response, heart rate, eye-tracking) are taken over into the design of economic experiments on decision making
The aim of the article is to show how neuroscience techniques can contribute to economic experiments, especially those concerning decision making. The overview and presentation of the possibilities of such tools is shown regarding different stages of the decision making process and related experimental studies.
medical-education 1 transfer
← evidence-based medicine / clinical research
The review's whole object is the import of evidence-based medicine's appraisal principles and evidence hierarchies into medical education, an import it judges conceptually and methodologically problematic and then reworks into an education-specific matrix.
While the principles of evidence-based medicine have substantially shaped clinical decision-making, their direct transfer to educational contexts has proven conceptually methodologically challenging.
ai-ethics 1 transfer
← evidence synthesis
systematic-review methodology from evidence-based medicine, applied semi-systematically to normative documents rather than to trials
Designed as a semi-systematic evaluation, this paper analyzes and compares 22 guidelines, highlighting overlaps but also omissions. As a result, I give a detailed overview of the field of AI ethics. Finally, I also examine to what extent the respective ethical principles and values are implemented in the practice of…
computational chemistry 1 transfer
← machine learning
deep tensor neural networks unified with the many-body Hamiltonian concept, to predict quantum-chemical observables at DFT accuracy while remaining size-extensive
We unify concepts from many-body Hamiltonians with purpose-designed deep tensor neural networks, which leads to size-extensive and uniformly accurate (1 kcal mol −1 ) predictions in compositional and configurational chemical space for molecules of intermediate size.